On September 28, 1994, in central Mexico City, José Francisco Ruiz Massieu was killed shortly after a breakfast meeting with the ruling party's newly elected members of Congress. He was the secretary-general of the Institutional Revolutionary Party, the PRI, and he had been chosen to lead the lower chamber when the new Congress sat. The man detained at once was Daniel Aguilar Treviño, a 27-year-old from a farming village in Tamaulipas who had no political connections of his own. In March 1995 a federal judge in Mexico City sentenced him to 50 years in prison for qualified homicide, an offense under the federal arms law and criminal association.
His conviction was the easy part of the case. The question of who had paid for the killing pulled in a sitting member of Congress who vanished the day after it and, finally, Raúl Salinas de Gortari, the elder brother of the outgoing president, who was convicted as its mastermind in 1999 and cleared in 2005. Through all of it the man who had carried out the killing stayed in federal prison. In April 2017 a federal appeals court found that he had not had an adequate defense at trial, and in October 2017 his sentence was cut to 42 years and six months.
Aguilar Treviño came from Ejido Corralejo, a farming community in the municipality of San Carlos, Tamaulipas, roughly 80 kilometers from the state capital. He could not read or write, and before 1994 he crossed into the United States each year for the fruit harvest and returned when the season ended.
Nothing in his life before September 1994 tied him to national politics. The link ran through a chain of men from his own state. An acquaintance, Carlos Ángel Cantú Narváez, told him that Fernando Rodríguez González would pay for a job. Rodríguez González was a congressional staff member, the technical secretary of the Hydraulic Resources Commission of the Chamber of Deputies, and the compadre, a close family friend through godparenthood, of a PRI federal deputy from Tamaulipas. The prosecution's case put the payment at 50,000 pesos, shared between Aguilar Treviño and Cantú Narváez.
The man at the center of the case had served as governor of Guerrero and was counted among the rising, reform-minded figures of the PRI. He was a former brother-in-law of President Carlos Salinas de Gortari and of Raúl Salinas, through a marriage that ended in divorce, and a friend and longtime political ally of the president. In the elections of August 21, 1994, he won a seat in the federal Chamber of Deputies, and the party designated him to preside over the lower chamber when the new legislature opened. By then he was already the party's secretary-general.
He was killed in a year that had already shaken the country. On March 23, 1994, the PRI's presidential candidate, Luis Donaldo Colosio, had been assassinated in Tijuana. Ernesto Zedillo replaced him on the ticket, won the August election and was due to take office on December 1. The secretary-general was the second high-ranking PRI member assassinated that year.
Aguilar Treviño did not get far. He was detained in the minutes after the killing and handed over to the Federal Judicial Police. At the offices of the attorney general he first gave false names and claimed to be from Acapulco. His real name and his village in Tamaulipas were established within a short time, and he named Fernando Rodríguez González as the man who had hired him.
The case went to the Procuraduría General de la República, the federal attorney general's office, and arrests followed along the chain Aguilar Treviño had described. Jorge Rodríguez González, Fernando's brother, was detained on September 30, 1994, and said he had acted on his brother's instructions. Fernando Rodríguez González was arrested in Zacatecas, and Cantú Narváez was taken into custody days after the killing. The deputy from Tamaulipas disappeared on September 29, 1994, the day after the killing, and has not been found since. On October 7, 1994, a federal judge ordered his arrest as the alleged intellectual author of the crime.
By February 1995 Aguilar Treviño, Cantú Narváez and Fernando Rodríguez González were on trial before the 11th District Court in Mexico City for qualified homicide, an offense under the federal arms law and criminal association. More than a dozen others faced related charges, among them Jorge Rodríguez González, charged with homicide and criminal association.
Aguilar Treviño's own case moved fast. In March 1995 the judge of the 11th District Court in Mexico City sentenced him to 50 years in prison for the qualified homicide together with the arms-law offense and criminal association. Other defendants were sentenced at the same time. Fernando Rodríguez González, Jorge Rodríguez González and Cantú Narváez received terms for organizing the crime, and three more defendants were given 37 years and six months each. The judgment did not settle who stood behind the vanished deputy.
The convictions were reviewed by the Fourth Unitary Tribunal in criminal matters in Mexico City, which confirmed the 50-year sentence against Aguilar Treviño in 1996. Fernando Rodríguez González's term was later set at 37 years.
On February 15, 1995, Fernando Rodríguez González gave a new statement that named Raúl Salinas de Gortari as the man behind the deputy. On February 28, 1995, the attorney general's office announced that it was prosecuting Raúl Salinas as the intellectual author, and a federal judge in Toluca issued the order on which he was arrested that day. He denied any part in it. No motive was ever announced officially.
On January 21, 1999, a judge convicted Raúl Salinas of the murder and sentenced him to 50 years in prison. On appeal the sentence was reduced to 27 years and six months. In June 2005 a collegiate tribunal in Toluca granted him a final amparo that annulled the conviction, after more than ten years in prison. No further appeal lay against the ruling, it did not affect the other people convicted in the case, and he left prison that month. In law he bears no responsibility for the death.
The acquittal left the case with convicted men at the bottom of the chain and no one convicted at the top. The deputy accused of organizing the plot has never been found or tried.
In custody Aguilar Treviño gave more than one version of how he came to be in Mexico City that day. His first statements to federal investigators named Fernando Rodríguez González as his employer, and through him the chain led to the deputy from Tamaulipas. In those statements he did not name Raúl Salinas.
In 1999, while Raúl Salinas was on trial, Aguilar Treviño told an American news magazine that intermediaries of Raúl Salinas had arranged the killing and that refusing the job would have cost him his own life. His account was difficult to confirm, because many of the people in it were in prison or beyond reach. No court tested it, and the man it pointed to was later cleared.
He also alleged that he had been tortured after his arrest and forced to incriminate himself.
In April 2017 the Third Collegiate Tribunal in criminal matters in Mexico City granted Aguilar Treviño an amparo, Mexico's constitutional challenge, against the 50-year sentence. The tribunal found that he had not had an adequate defense during his proceedings. When his conviction was appealed in 1996, the same lawyer had represented both him and Cantú Narváez, and because the two men's statements bore on each other, the court held that acting in the interest of one client harmed the other. At the core of the ruling was that conflict of interest. The ruling did not reopen the finding that he had carried out the killing.
The tribunal ordered the case sent back for a new sentence, which could not exceed the original 50 years, and directed the Fourth Unitary Tribunal to appoint him a new lawyer, different from the one who had acted for him two decades earlier. It also ordered the federal attorney general's office and the Mexico City prosecutor's office to investigate his torture allegation, so that those authorities could determine whether the offense of torture was established. At the time of the ruling he was being held in a federal prison in Tabasco.
In October 2017 the Fourth Unitary Tribunal in criminal matters of Mexico City issued the new sentence. It reduced his term from 50 years to 42 years and six months. In the same period it reduced Cantú Narváez's sentence from 37 years to 31 years and 10 months. Fernando Rodríguez González had won his own amparo in December 2015, which also ordered his proceedings repeated.
As of 2018 Aguilar Treviño was held in a high-security federal prison in Jalisco, with the reduced term still running. Whether he has since been released is unknown.
Aguilar Treviño's conviction rests on his detention at the scene and on the statements gathered in 1994 and 1995. Who ordered the killing has never been settled in court. The deputy from Tamaulipas was charged as the intellectual author and has never been found or tried. Raúl Salinas was convicted as the mastermind in 1999 and cleared on amparo in 2005. The accusation against him rested chiefly on the 1995 statement of Fernando Rodríguez González, a statement the defense said had been bought.
Aguilar Treviño's own accounts conflict. His early statements led to Rodríguez González and the deputy without naming Raúl Salinas; his 1999 account blamed intermediaries of Raúl Salinas, a claim never tested in any court. The size of his payment also differs: 50,000 pesos in the prosecution's case and a $15,000 fee in the 1999 account. His allegation that he was tortured into incriminating himself was referred by the 2017 court to two prosecutors' offices for investigation.
March 23, 1994: PRI presidential candidate Luis Donaldo Colosio is assassinated in Tijuana.
August 21, 1994: The secretary-general is elected to the federal Chamber of Deputies.
September 28, 1994: The secretary-general is killed in Mexico City; Aguilar Treviño is detained within minutes.
September 29, 1994: The PRI federal deputy later charged as the alleged intellectual author disappears.
September 30, 1994: Jorge Rodríguez González is detained.
October 7, 1994: A federal judge orders the deputy's arrest as the alleged intellectual author.
February 15, 1995: Fernando Rodríguez González gives the statement that implicates Raúl Salinas de Gortari.
February 28, 1995: Raúl Salinas de Gortari is arrested.
March 1995: The 11th District Court in Mexico City sentences Aguilar Treviño to 50 years.
1996: The Fourth Unitary Tribunal confirms the sentence.
January 21, 1999: Raúl Salinas is convicted and sentenced to 50 years; the term is later reduced to 27 years and six months.
June 9, 2005: A collegiate tribunal in Toluca grants Raúl Salinas an amparo that annuls his conviction.
December 2015: Fernando Rodríguez González wins an amparo ordering his proceedings repeated.
April 2017: The Third Collegiate Tribunal grants Aguilar Treviño an amparo for inadequate defense and orders an inquiry into his torture allegation.
October 2017: The Fourth Unitary Tribunal resentences him to 42 years and six months.
2018: He is held in a high-security federal prison in Jalisco.