Dan White

Victims
2 killed at San Francisco City Hall, 1978; manslaughter. Mayor George Moscone and Supervisor Harvey Milk; not guilty of murder, guilty of two counts of voluntary manslaughter, May 21, 1979.
Years active
November 27, 1978
Location
San Francisco, California
Method
Voluntary manslaughter (two counts); tried on charges of first-degree murder
Status
Sentenced July 3, 1979, to seven years and eight months, the maximum term, affirmed on appeal in 1981; paroled January 6, 1984; died by suicide in San Francisco, October 21, 1985

At San Francisco City Hall on November 27, 1978, Dan White killed the mayor of the city, George Moscone, and one of the eleven members of its Board of Supervisors, Harvey Milk. Earlier that month White had resigned his own seat on that board. He had then asked the mayor to give it back, and the mayor had decided not to. White surrendered to police the same day and gave them a taped statement.

Prosecutors tried him for first-degree murder, an offense that could have carried a death sentence. The defense never denied that he had caused both deaths. It argued instead that a deep depression had left him unable to form the mental state that murder requires. On May 21, 1979, the jury found him not guilty of murder and guilty of two counts of voluntary manslaughter. He was sentenced to seven years and eight months, the longest term the verdict allowed, served a little more than five years, and was paroled in January 1984. He died by suicide in San Francisco on October 21, 1985, at the age of 39.

Daniel James White was born on September 2, 1946, in Los Angeles County. By the time he entered city politics he had worked in San Francisco as a police officer and then as a firefighter. He was a social conservative, and his support came largely from blue-collar voters.

San Francisco had just adopted district elections for its Board of Supervisors, and in November 1977, in the first vote under the new system, White won District 8, a conservative, working-class district. The same night the voters of District 5 elected the man White would later kill. Both newcomers took their seats on the board on January 8, 1978. The board's salary was $9,600 a year, and money would become one of the reasons White gave for leaving it.

The mayor who would refuse White his seat had spent most of his career in San Francisco government. He sat on the Board of Supervisors from January 1964 to the start of 1967 and in the California State Senate from 1967 to 1976. The city elected him mayor in December 1975, and he held the office from 1976 until the day he died.

The two freshmen supervisors began on good terms. In their first months the District 5 supervisor backed White's choice of a committee chair. The break came in April 1978 over a proposed facility for juvenile offenders in White's district. White had counted on his colleague's vote against it, and the colleague reversed his position.

On November 10, 1978, he announced his resignation, giving personal responsibilities as the reason, though the salary and his frustrations with the board lay behind it. The resignation mattered beyond White himself, because the mayor would choose his successor, and a new appointee could tilt a closely divided board toward its liberal wing.

Within days White changed his mind. After meetings with supporters among police and real estate leaders, he asked to withdraw the resignation and to be reappointed to the seat he had just left. The mayor at first appeared willing. Then, after meeting with the District 5 supervisor, who argued against the reappointment, he settled on another candidate. On November 26, 1978, White learned from a reporter that the mayor would not give him the seat.

The next morning White went to City Hall and met the mayor, who told him he would not be reappointed. He killed the mayor, and then the District 5 supervisor. He surrendered to police that day, gave his taped statement, and was charged with two counts of murder, with special circumstances alleged.

The trial opened on May 1, 1979. The prosecution's theory was simple: White had gone to City Hall with a purpose and had acted with premeditation, deliberation and malice, the elements of first-degree murder. The jury heard White's taped statement in his own voice.

The defense did not dispute what White had done. Its case was about his state of mind. The aim was a manslaughter verdict: if depression and the pressures on White had driven him to act in a passion, without the capacity for the reflection that murder requires, the law of the time allowed the jury to find the lesser crime. Two psychiatrists testified for the defense about his depression, and a psychologist joined them; together they told the jury that White had lacked the capacity to deliberate, to premeditate or to harbor malice. The prosecution answered with a psychiatrist of its own who found no disorder that would have impaired his ability to premeditate. White himself never took the stand.

The phrase "Twinkie defense" came from the press, not the courtroom; the psychiatric testimony treated White's binges on junk food as a symptom of his depression, not its cause.

On May 21, 1979, the jury returned its verdicts: not guilty of murder, and guilty of two counts of voluntary manslaughter, one for each death. Voluntary manslaughter, under section 192 of the California Penal Code, was a lesser offense included within the murder counts. That night a protest at City Hall turned into a riot.

What the verdict meant was later spelled out by the state Court of Appeal. It said it had to assume that the jury accepted the defense evidence about White's state of mind at the time of the killings, even though the evidence could well have supported a conviction for first-degree murder.

On July 3, 1979, the trial judge sentenced White to seven years and eight months, the maximum term for the two manslaughter counts.

White appealed the sentence, not the verdict. On March 25, 1981, the Court of Appeal for the First Appellate District, Division Two, affirmed it. The court presumed that the trial judge had weighed the circumstances in White's favor and held that the judge did not have to explain why he rejected them. It found that two of the reasons the judge had given for choosing the upper term were not proper grounds, but it called the error harmless: valid factors, among them premeditation and the abuse of a position of trust, amply supported the term, and a new sentencing hearing was not reasonably likely to end differently. White had also argued that the two deaths were a single indivisible act that could carry only one enhancement. The court disagreed, holding that the killings had two separate people as their objects. It left the calculation of his conduct credits to the Department of Corrections.

The federal government weighed a second prosecution. On November 21, 1983, the United States attorney in San Francisco announced that the department would not bring charges. It found the evidence insufficient: federal law required proof that the two officials were killed because of their status or their political activity, and the department found no evidence that they were.

White served his sentence in a California state prison. The state Board of Prison Terms recommended that the terms of his parole keep him out of San Francisco. He was paroled for good behavior on January 6, 1984, after slightly more than five years. He spent his year of parole in Southern California under an assumed name, out of work, and was released from parole on January 6, 1985. He then returned to San Francisco and kept out of sight.

He died by suicide in San Francisco on October 21, 1985. He was 39.

White's motive was the contested question at trial. The prosecution said he went to City Hall intending to kill. The defense said his depression had robbed him of the capacity to form that intent, and the jury rejected murder in favor of manslaughter. He was angry that the mayor had refused him and blamed the District 5 supervisor for opposing his reappointment, but his deeper motives remain unknown.

Timeline

September 2, 1946: Daniel James White is born in Los Angeles County, California.

November 1977: White is elected supervisor for District 8 in San Francisco's first district elections; the District 5 seat goes to the man he would later kill.

January 8, 1978: White and the District 5 supervisor take their seats on the new Board of Supervisors.

April 1978: White and the District 5 supervisor split over a juvenile facility proposed for White's district.

November 10, 1978: White announces his resignation from the board.

November 18, 1978: White's request to withdraw his resignation becomes public; the mayor first appears willing.

November 26, 1978: White learns that the mayor will not reappoint him.

November 27, 1978: White kills the mayor and the District 5 supervisor at City Hall, surrenders to police and is charged with two counts of murder, with special circumstances alleged.

May 1, 1979: Trial opens.

May 21, 1979: Jury finds White not guilty of murder and guilty of two counts of voluntary manslaughter; a riot follows at City Hall.

July 3, 1979: White is sentenced to seven years and eight months.

March 25, 1981: The Court of Appeal affirms the sentence.

November 21, 1983: The Justice Department announces that it will not prosecute White under the federal civil rights laws.

January 6, 1984: White is paroled after slightly more than five years.

January 6, 1985: White is released from parole; he later returns to San Francisco.

October 21, 1985: White dies by suicide in San Francisco.