Cristian Fernandez

Victims
1 death: his toddler half-brother, Jacksonville, March 2011 (guilty plea to manslaughter and aggravated battery, February 8, 2013).
Years active
March 2011
Location
Jacksonville, Florida (killing); Jacksonville, Florida (trial)
Method
Blunt-force head trauma (prosecutors' account; never tested at trial).
Status
Committed to the Department of Juvenile Justice until his 19th birthday, then eight years of probation. Released January 15, 2018; on probation as of February 2018.

Cristian Fernandez was 12 years old in March 2011, when his toddler half-brother died in Jacksonville, Florida, two days after being injured while the two boys were together. Within three months a Duval County grand jury had indicted him for first-degree murder, and he was moved from juvenile detention to the county jail to await trial as an adult. No one younger had ever been indicted for murder in Duval County. If he had been convicted as charged, Florida law at the time called for life imprisonment without parole.

The case never reached a jury. Over the next two years the trial judge suppressed nearly everything he had said to detectives, prosecutors dropped a second felony count, and the defense fought the indictment itself on the strength of a new United States Supreme Court ruling on juvenile life sentences. On February 8, 2013, less than a month before his murder trial was to begin, he pleaded guilty to the lesser charges of manslaughter and aggravated battery. Under the agreement he was committed to the Florida Department of Juvenile Justice until his 19th birthday, to be followed by eight years of probation. He was released on January 15, 2018, and as of February 2018 he was serving that probation.

He was born in Miami in 1999, to a mother who was 12 years old. The man who fathered him was convicted of sexually assaulting her. Court records and reporting gathered after his arrest described a childhood shaped by neglect and violence almost from the start.

When he was 2, he was found alone on a South Florida street in the middle of the night, naked and dirty. The grandmother who had been looking after him was arrested on charges of neglect and drug possession, and he and his mother, then 14, were both placed in foster care.

In 2007, when he was 8, the Florida Department of Children and Families investigated a report that an older cousin had sexually abused him, and officials later said other troubling incidents involving him had been reported in those years. By the time of the murder charge, both sexual and physical abuse of the boy had been confirmed, and he had never received counseling.

In October 2010 he and his mother were living in Hialeah, a Miami suburb, with her new husband. School officials saw that he had been hurt, and he told police that his stepfather had punched him. When officers went to the family's apartment, they found that the stepfather had taken his own life. Soon afterward the family moved north to Jacksonville, where Cristian enrolled in middle school and earned straight A's.

The injuries that led to the case were inflicted on March 14, 2011. The boy who was hurt was Cristian's half-brother, the youngest of their mother's children, and he died two days later. The state's case, set out in charging papers and in statements by prosecutors over the following two years, was that Cristian had caused his injuries.

Jacksonville Sheriff's Office detectives first questioned Cristian as a witness. During that interview he gave an account of an accident; detectives judged the injuries too severe for what he described, and the questioning turned. Once he became a possible suspect, the detectives stopped the interview. He was arrested in March 2011 and charged with murder. At first he was held in juvenile detention.

His mother was charged separately in connection with the death, and in March 2012 she pleaded guilty to aggravated manslaughter.

Florida gives prosecutors a route to adult court for a child of any age: a grand jury indictment on an offense punishable by death or life imprisonment. The State Attorney in Jacksonville took that route. In early June 2011 a Duval County grand jury indicted Cristian for first-degree murder. The indictment alleged premeditation. He was 12.

The indictment moved the case out of the juvenile system and into adult court, and it moved Cristian too. He was transferred from juvenile detention to the Duval County jail, where he was held without bond, kept with other juveniles and given access to a counselor. The previous record for the youngest person indicted for murder in the county had belonged to a 13-year-old, decades earlier. The case drew national attention almost at once because of his age.

By October 2011 both sides were saying in public that they were close to a plea agreement. A trial date was set for February 2012. No deal came.

Instead the case grew. Prosecutors brought a second first-degree felony charge against Cristian, a separate count involving another, younger half-brother. Like the murder charge, it carried a possible life sentence.

In 2012 a team of private Jacksonville lawyers took over the defense from the Public Defender's Office and worked the case without fee. Investigators and court reporters also donated their services.

The defense's first major move was a motion to suppress Cristian's statements to the police. The video recordings of his questioning were the subject of a four-day hearing that summer before the circuit judge presiding over both cases.

On August 7, 2012, the judge granted the motion. Where a juvenile waives the rights explained to him under Miranda, the state carries a heavy burden to show the waiver was knowing and voluntary, and the judge found that the state had not met it. Cristian, she ruled, had been incapable of understanding and waiving those rights. The moment the ruling turned on came after he had signed the waiver and spoken with a detective: he asked whether the rights on the paper were just between the two of them. To the court that question showed that he had not grasped what he was giving up. All of his statements made after the warnings were excluded from both trials. The judge did not exclude everything. She denied the motion as to one statement he had made before he was read his rights.

The state filed notice of an appeal with the First District Court of Appeal, then on September 18, 2012, told that court it would not go forward: the State Attorney's Office and the Office of the Attorney General had both concluded that the appeal should be dismissed. The ruling stood.

In June 2012, while the suppression fight was under way, the United States Supreme Court decided Miller v. Alabama. The Court held that a mandatory sentence of life without parole for an offender who was under 18 at the time of the crime violates the Eighth Amendment, because the sentencer must be able to take the offender's youth into account. Florida's first-degree murder statute had not been changed in response, and at the time it still prescribed death or life without parole.

The defense moved to dismiss the murder indictment. Its argument was twofold. Sentencing a juvenile to life without parole was cruel and unusual punishment, and the indictment gave no notice of the punishment Cristian actually faced, as due process requires. Prosecutors answered that they had never sought a mandatory life sentence and that an older Florida law calling for 25 years to life could apply.

On November 8, 2012, before the motion was decided, prosecutors dropped the second count. Three things had undermined it: the suppression of Cristian's statements, which applied in that case as well as the murder case; conflicting statements by the younger child; and the absence of physical evidence. That left one charge, first-degree murder.

Twelve days later, on November 20, 2012, the judge denied the motion. She found the cruel-and-unusual-punishment argument premature, because Cristian had not been convicted of anything, and held that the indictment had given him all the notice then due. Miller, she wrote, required a sentencing court to weigh the offender's age and the totality of the circumstances, but it "did not foreclose the imposition of a sentence of incarceration for life without parole" for a juvenile convicted of first-degree murder. The murder trial was set for March 4, 2013.

On February 8, 2013, a little under a month before trial, Cristian Fernandez stood before the same judge and pleaded guilty to the lesser charges of manslaughter and aggravated battery. Charged as an adult, he was allowed to plead as a juvenile. Asked whether he understood what he was agreeing to, he answered, "Yes ma'am."

The agreement split the two counts. On manslaughter he received a juvenile sanction: commitment to the Department of Juvenile Justice until his 19th birthday, January 14, 2018. On aggravated battery he was sentenced as an adult to eight years of probation, to begin on his release, and adjudication of guilt on that count was withheld, so that for the time being he would not carry the label of a convicted felon. If he complied with every condition he could end probation after five years. If he violated it, he faced up to 15 years in a Florida state prison as an adult, with credit for time served.

The conditions were detailed. While in custody he was to undergo comprehensive psychological and psychiatric evaluation and treatment, take any prescribed medication and keep up his schooling. On release he had to attend school toward a high school diploma or work full time, or combine the two, and continue counseling. He could have no contact with his siblings unless their guardians agreed, or unless they sought him out once they were adults, and no unsupervised contact with anyone under 16 without his probation officer's approval.

From 2013 Cristian was held at a state-contracted Department of Juvenile Justice facility in Florida. Little about his years in custody became public. Court documents later showed that in August 2017 he was transferred to a different juvenile facility in northeast Florida.

In December 2017, a month before his release date, his lawyers told the court they might seek to change some of his probation conditions, writing that circumstances that had developed over the previous several months had made them unrealistic and problematic. On January 10, 2018, the circuit judge, with the prosecution's agreement, granted a temporary stay of the conditions.

Cristian Fernandez turned 19 on January 14, 2018, and was released the next day, January 15, 2018. His probation began with his release.

On February 15, 2018, the judge lifted the stay, and every condition took effect. Under the probation order he had to be a part-time or full-time student, hold a job and receive counseling, and his contact with his former siblings and with minors was limited. A violation could return him to custody. That was the position as of February 2018.

Because the case ended in a plea, no jury ever heard evidence or made findings. The state's account of how the injuries were caused was never tested at trial, and Cristian's statements to detectives after his Miranda warnings were excluded by a court ruling the state chose not to appeal.

The plea was to manslaughter, not murder. The state had charged premeditated first-degree murder; his defense said at the plea that he had not intentionally caused his brother's death. The plea left that disagreement unresolved.

Reports differ on the lesser count that went with the manslaughter plea: the contemporaneous court reports call it aggravated battery, while one Jacksonville legal paper called it aggravated assault.

The dropped count, involving a younger half-brother, was dropped before trial and was never proven in any court.

Timeline

1999: Born in Miami, Florida.

2007: The Florida Department of Children and Families investigates a report that an older cousin had sexually abused him.

October 2010: In Hialeah, he tells police his stepfather punched him; officers find the stepfather dead by his own hand. Soon afterward the family moves to Jacksonville.

March 14, 2011: His toddler half-brother is injured in Jacksonville, Florida; the child dies two days later.

March 2011: Cristian Fernandez, 12, is questioned by Jacksonville detectives, arrested and charged with murder; he is held in juvenile detention.

Early June 2011: A Duval County grand jury indicts him for first-degree murder; he is moved to the county jail.

October 2011: Both sides say a plea agreement is close; no agreement follows.

March 2012: His mother pleads guilty to aggravated manslaughter.

June 25, 2012: The United States Supreme Court decides Miller v. Alabama.

Summer 2012: A four-day hearing on the recordings of his police questioning.

August 7, 2012: The circuit judge suppresses his statements after the Miranda warnings.

September 18, 2012: The state abandons its appeal of the suppression ruling.

November 8, 2012: Prosecutors drop the second felony count.

November 20, 2012: The judge denies the motion to dismiss the murder indictment; trial set for March 4, 2013.

February 8, 2013: He pleads guilty to manslaughter and aggravated battery; committed to the Department of Juvenile Justice until his 19th birthday, then eight years of probation.

August 2017: Transferred to a different juvenile facility in Florida.

January 10, 2018: A judge temporarily stays his probation conditions.

January 15, 2018: Released from juvenile custody, the day after his 19th birthday.

February 15, 2018: The stay is lifted and all probation conditions take effect.