On May 28, 2021, a jury in Davenport, Iowa, found Cristhian Bahena Rivera guilty of murder in the first degree in the death of Mollie Tibbetts of Brooklyn, a town of about 1,700 people in Poweshiek County, some seventy miles east of Des Moines. The verdict was unanimous. Three months later, in the county courthouse at Montezuma, he received the only sentence Iowa law allows for that offense: life in the custody of the state's Department of Corrections, with no possibility of parole. On October 11, 2023, the Iowa Court of Appeals affirmed the conviction.
In the summer of 2018 the case held the country's eye for a month while local, state and federal agencies worked to learn what had happened in a small farm town on the evening of July 18. In the courts, it turned on something narrower and more lasting: a long interview in a county sheriff's office in August 2018, conducted in Spanish, during which the defendant went from being a man free to walk out the door to a man held on an immigration detainer, and finally to the man who led officers to the victim.
Bahena Rivera came to the United States from Mexico as a teenager and was living in the country without legal status. He was 24 in August 2018. For about four years he had worked at a dairy operation in Poweshiek County, putting in long shifts, thirteen days in a row followed by two days off, and he spoke little English. Iowa court records showed no criminal history before 2018, and the appellate court later noted that he had no prior experience with the criminal justice system.
From July 19, when her absence was first brought to law enforcement, the Poweshiek County Sheriff's Office, the Iowa Division of Criminal Investigation and federal agents worked the case together. For almost four weeks the effort produced no solid information about what had happened to her.
In mid-August the inquiry finally turned up a lead. On August 16, a Poweshiek County deputy sheriff spoke with a man who identified himself as Bahena Rivera. The conversation was hampered by a language barrier, but the deputy learned that he worked at a local dairy farm. He denied any involvement.
Officers went to the dairy farm in the early afternoon of August 20. They spoke with all the employees there, and three agents spoke with Bahena Rivera, with an agent of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security translating. He agreed to go to the sheriff's office in Montezuma to answer more questions once his supervisor confirmed he could leave work, and he rode there with an agent of the Division of Criminal Investigation, unrestrained. At the office he waited alone in the lobby with his phone.
The interview began late that afternoon with a native Spanish-speaking officer and a second officer proficient in Spanish. Before it started, they showed him that the door was unlocked and told him he could leave at any time and use his phone whenever he wished. The first two hours concerned his background. When the questioning turned to the victim, he at first denied ever having seen her, then said he had driven past her once while running errands. The officers pressed him, told him they did not believe him and claimed to have evidence placing him in the area, most of which they did not have at that point. He then said he had seen her several times while driving, but he denied speaking to her.
Late that evening, after a break for food, he was told that a federal immigration detainer was being placed on him. That formally ended his freedom to leave, and officers took his phone. The Spanish-speaking officer then tried to recite his Miranda rights from memory but left one of the required warnings out, a defect the State later conceded.
The questioning continued into the early morning of August 21, broken by about nine pauses of between three minutes and half an hour. He was tired; he dozed during breaks and said so several times, though his answers remained coherent. Shortly before dawn two English-speaking agents entered the room and urged him to tell the truth. He asked to speak with the Spanish-speaking officer alone, and once the others had left he gave an account that, for the first time, placed him with the victim that evening. He said she had threatened to call the police, that this made him angry, and that a confrontation followed which he said he could not remember, because he sometimes blacked out when he was angry. He then led officers to her that morning.
Afterward the officer gave him a second, complete set of Miranda warnings in Spanish. He said he understood them and wanted to keep talking, and he repeated the substance of what he had already said. The interview was recorded on video from start to finish and later translated and transcribed by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
He was arrested on August 21 and charged with murder in the first degree, and in September 2018 he pleaded not guilty.
The defense moved to suppress his statements and the discovery of the victim. After a hearing in Montezuma in November 2019, the trial court ruled in part for each side. From the first contact at the dairy farm until the detainer was placed, it found, he had not been in custody, so no warnings had been required and those statements were admissible. It agreed that officers had failed to give proper warnings when the detainer was imposed, and it suppressed everything he said from that point until the second set of warnings. It found that his statements were not involuntary and that no improper promises of leniency had been made, and it admitted what he said after the second warnings.
The defense asked the Iowa Supreme Court for permission to appeal that ruling before trial; on February 4, 2020, a justice of that court denied the application. Because of pretrial publicity, the trial was moved out of Poweshiek County and eventually to the Scott County Courthouse in Davenport.
Jury selection began on May 17, 2021, and the evidence ran from May 19 to May 27. The State's case rested on evidence linking him to the victim and on his own recorded statements, including the fact that he had led officers to her. Testifying in his own defense, Bahena Rivera denied the killing and blamed two other men.
On the afternoon of May 28, the jury returned its verdict: guilty of murder in the first degree.
After the verdict the defense moved for a new trial, citing a jail inmate's report that another man had claimed the killing and an earlier investigation the State had not disclosed. The trial judge denied the motion in a written ruling on August 2, 2021.
On August 30, 2021, at the Poweshiek County Courthouse in Montezuma, the judge sentenced Bahena Rivera, then 27, to life in prison without the possibility of parole, the mandatory penalty for a class "A" felony in Iowa. He was ordered to pay $150,000 in restitution and was transferred to the custody of the Iowa Department of Corrections.
Bahena Rivera appealed to the Iowa Supreme Court, which transferred the case to the Iowa Court of Appeals as No. 21-1202. A three-judge panel heard it, and on October 11, 2023, the court affirmed in a written opinion. He had raised two issues: that his statements should have been suppressed, and that he should have had a new trial on newly discovered evidence and on the State's failure to disclose evidence favorable to the defense.
On custody, the court walked through the period from the dairy farm to the detainer factor by factor. It accepted that officers had started the encounter at his workplace, that most of the questioning took place in a sheriff's office, and that the interview, about six hours long by the time of the detainer, became accusatory and was something other than simple fact-finding. Against that, he had been offered a choice about coming in, had been told and shown that he could leave, had kept his phone and could have arranged a ride, had been neither restrained nor blocked from the door, and had himself said he understood he was free to go. The court concluded that he was not in custody until the detainer was placed late that night, so no warnings had been required and those statements were properly admitted.
On the second set of warnings, the court found that the officer's grammatical slips in Spanish did not rob the warnings of their meaning and that police were not required to tell him in so many words that his statements could be used in court. His waiver was knowing.
On voluntariness, the court set out the factors on both sides with care. He was 24, sober, fed, allowed breaks, and coherent throughout, and he had just been warned again. Against that, officers had used deceptive tactics, including false claims about evidence; he had no experience of the justice system; he had been detained and questioned for more than six hours after the detainer and questioned nearly continuously since late afternoon; and he had been awake since early the previous morning. In the court's words, "We acknowledge other factors prior to the second set of warnings could weigh towards a finding of involuntariness." It held nonetheless that fatigue alone does not make a statement involuntary, that he was alert when he led officers to the victim, and that the State had "proved by a preponderance of the evidence that Bahena voluntarily waived his Miranda rights." It also deferred to the trial court's finding that the incomplete first warnings were a mistake, not a deliberate two-step tactic, and held his complaint about promises of leniency waived for want of specific examples, and without merit in any event.
On the new-trial claims, the court held that the defense had known of the first inmate's report before the verdict, that neither report would probably have changed the outcome, and that the undisclosed investigation, even assuming it had been suppressed and might have been favorable, was immaterial to the case.
As of the Court of Appeals decision in October 2023, Bahena Rivera was serving life without parole in the custody of the Iowa Department of Corrections, with his conviction affirmed.
Bahena Rivera has denied the murder since he took the stand at trial, and his trial testimony blamed two other men; the jury rejected that account, and no one else has been charged. The claimed jailhouse confession and the undisclosed investigation were examined by the trial court and the Court of Appeals, and both found that they would probably not have changed the verdict. The voluntariness of his overnight statements remains the most closely argued point in the case: the appellate court acknowledged the deceptive tactics, the length of the questioning and his exhaustion, and still upheld the trial court's ruling.
July 18, 2018: The victim's death in Brooklyn, Poweshiek County, Iowa, as later charged.
July 19, 2018: Law enforcement is notified; local, state and federal agencies take up the case.
August 16, 2018: A Poweshiek County deputy speaks with Bahena Rivera, who denies involvement.
August 20, 2018: Interview at the dairy farm and then in Montezuma; a federal immigration detainer is placed late that night.
August 21, 2018: He leads officers to the victim and is arrested and charged with first-degree murder.
September 2018: He pleads not guilty.
November 2019: Suppression hearing; the court later suppresses only the statements made between the detainer and the second warnings.
February 4, 2020: Iowa Supreme Court denies pretrial review.
May 17 to 28, 2021: Trial at the Scott County Courthouse in Davenport; guilty verdict, May 28.
August 2, 2021: New-trial motion denied.
August 30, 2021: Sentenced in Montezuma to life without parole.
October 11, 2023: Iowa Court of Appeals affirms the conviction (No. 21-1202).