Craig Hicks

Victims
3 people killed in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, 2015. Pleaded guilty to three counts of first-degree murder, Durham County Superior Court, June 12, 2019.
Years active
February 10, 2015
Location
Chapel Hill (Durham County part), North Carolina (killings); Pittsboro, North Carolina (surrender); Durham, North Carolina (plea and sentencing)
Method
Shot (prosecution's case, admitted by guilty plea)
Status
Three consecutive life sentences without parole plus 64 to 89 months, June 12, 2019; no appeal on record. Imprisoned in North Carolina, serving life without parole, as of June 2019.

On the evening of February 10, 2015, Craig Stephen Hicks killed three young Muslim neighbors in Chapel Hill, North Carolina. He was 46 and lived near them, and within hours he had driven to Pittsboro, in neighboring Chatham County, and surrendered to sheriff's deputies. The next day police said their preliminary investigation pointed to a quarrel over parking. Four years later, without a trial ever being held, he pleaded guilty to all three murders.

The three had given much of their short adult lives to service. Deah Shaddy Barakat wanted to help Syrians who had fled the war. He set out to raise $20,000 for supplies and a week-long volunteer trip to the Turkish border with Syria, and he sold $5 kits of toothbrushes and toothpaste outside mosques in North Carolina to build the fund; when he died, the project he called Project Refugee Smiles had raised about $16,000. Yusor Mohammad Abu-Salha had already done that kind of work herself, helping refugees on the Turkey-Syria border. Razan Mohammad Abu-Salha worked with homeless people in Raleigh and raised money for children in Gaza. Together they cooked meals for people without homes, worked to improve a poor neighborhood of Raleigh, and had planned to spend part of the summer of 2015 volunteering at a clinic for Syrian refugees in Turkey.

The address where they died carries a Chapel Hill name but lies inside Durham County, so the case belonged to Durham. Hicks was charged with three counts of first-degree murder and held without bond, and within days a Durham County grand jury indicted him on those counts and one further count connected with the killings. The FBI opened a separate inquiry into whether any federal law, hate-crime statutes included, had been broken. No federal charge was ever brought.

Prosecutors filed notice on February 25, 2015, that they would seek the death penalty, and the case then sat in pretrial delay for four years with no trial date. In April 2019 a newly elected district attorney withdrew the death penalty and set a non-capital trial for July.

The trial never came. On June 12, 2019, in Durham County Superior Court, Hicks, then 50, pleaded guilty to three counts of first-degree murder and to the further count. The judge accepted the facts the prosecution put before the court and imposed three consecutive sentences of life imprisonment without parole for the murders, with a further term of 64 to 89 months for the remaining count. As of June 2019 he was serving those terms in the North Carolina prison system, and no appeal is on record.

At that sentencing hearing prosecutors argued that Hicks had killed the three out of bias against them rather than over parking, and the same afternoon the Chapel Hill police chief said publicly that the murders were about more than a parking dispute. No hate-crime charge was ever filed, and no court ever ruled on motive: the guilty plea admits the murders, not the reason for them.

Hicks's own account to investigators, as prosecutors described it in court, was that he lost control during an argument; the prosecution told the court that account was untrue. Reports also differ on whether the sentence came from a negotiated agreement: wire reports described the life terms as part of a plea deal, while the district attorney said no plea had been offered.

Timeline

February 10, 2015: Three young Muslim neighbors are killed in Chapel Hill, North Carolina; Hicks surrenders in Pittsboro and is charged with three counts of first-degree murder.

February 11, 2015: Chapel Hill police say the preliminary investigation points to a dispute over parking.

February 2015: A Durham County grand jury indicts Hicks; the FBI opens a separate inquiry.

February 25, 2015: Prosecutors file notice that they will seek the death penalty.

April 11, 2019: The district attorney withdraws the death penalty; trial set for July 2019.

June 12, 2019: Hicks pleads guilty to three counts of first-degree murder and the further count and is sentenced to three consecutive life terms without parole, plus 64 to 89 months; the Chapel Hill police chief says the murders were about more than a parking dispute.