Connor Betts was 24 years old and lived in Bellbrook, a suburb of Dayton, Ohio, when nine people died in the Oregon District, Dayton's entertainment district, in the early hours of Sunday, August 4, 2019. Dayton police put the number of injured at 27; other reports gave 17, a narrower count that left out people hurt in other ways that night. Dayton police officers killed Betts at the scene. The Montgomery County coroner later ruled all nine deaths homicides and found that every one of them was caused by Betts, not by the officers. One of the nine was his own sister.
Because he died where he stood, Betts was never arrested, never charged and never brought before any court. What is known of him comes from the coroner, from the Dayton Police Department and from the Federal Bureau of Investigation, which together spent more than two years reconstructing his life before closing the case in November 2021. Their conclusion was that he acted alone, that no organization directed him and that he belonged to no ideological movement.
He had grown up in Bellbrook and graduated from Bellbrook High School in 2013. After high school he stayed in the area, working at a gas station in Bellbrook and, at another point, as a grill cook, and he enrolled at Sinclair Community College in Dayton, where he was studying at the time of his death. As an adult he had no apparent criminal record.
On the night of Saturday, August 3, Betts went into the Oregon District with his sister and his closest friend. Later he left the other two and went on alone. The deaths came early on Sunday morning. His sister was among the dead. The friend who had spent the evening with her was among the injured and survived.
The Dayton police released the names of the dead. They were Lois Oglesby; Saeed Saleh, who lived in Dayton; Derrick Fudge, of Springfield; Logan Turner, of Springboro; Nicholas Cumer, who came from the Pittsburgh area; Thomas McNichols, known as T.J.; Beatrice Warren-Curtis, known as Nicole; and Monica Brickhouse, originally of Springfield. The ninth was Betts's own sister. They had come from Dayton itself, from Springfield and Springboro, and from western Pennsylvania, to spend a Saturday night in the same few blocks, and nothing tied most of them to Betts or to one another.
The coroner's office performed the autopsies. In mid-August 2019 the coroner found that Betts had caused all nine deaths and the police none, and the final autopsy reports, released in early December 2019, confirmed it: all nine deaths were ruled homicides, and every one was attributed to Betts.
The Dayton police and the FBI ran the investigation together. It had to answer why Betts acted, whether anyone had known in advance, and whether he had meant to kill his sister, all without the one person who could have told them. The work ran for 26 months and took investigators through more than 125 interviews in several states. They found that Betts had looked into violent ideologies, yet the Bureau's final word was that he was not directed by any organization and was not aligned with any specific ideological group. The question of whether a second person had known what he planned was settled the same way: the FBI concluded that no one else knew.
On November 29, 2021, the Dayton Police Department and the FBI announced that the investigation was closed. The findings came from the FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit, which concluded that Betts acted alone. It found that he had an "enduring fascination with mass violence" and that for at least a decade he had carried "suicidal and violent fantasies" of mass killing, serial murder and murder-suicide. It concluded that he likely suffered from mental illness and had struggled for about ten years with multiple mental health stressors. It named three main contributors to his decision to act: that fascination with mass violence, his inability to cope with a convergence of personal problems, and "the successive loss of significant stabilizing anchors" in the months before August. It did not set out publicly what those anchors were.
What the unit did not find mattered as much. Despite his history, the Bureau said, "there were no specific warnings he intended to commit a crime." It found that he had kept his plans from family and friends and no indication that he told anyone. To explain why no one had raised an alarm over the years, it described a pattern it called bystander fatigue: the passivity, inaction or inattention that settles over people long exposed to a person's troubling behavior, until a change in that behavior no longer registers. Dayton police released their own investigative report in January 2022.
Whether Betts meant to kill his sister was the question on which investigators divided most openly. In the days after the deaths, investigators within the Dayton department were reported to hold sharply different views on it. The department's final report in January 2022 found no evidence that he targeted or singled her out and concluded that "all of the victims appear to have been random." The FBI said the same month that it had reached no final conclusion.
His motive was never fixed beyond the FBI's description of contributing factors. He had looked into violent ideologies, but the Bureau found him aligned with none of them.
2013: Betts graduates from Bellbrook High School.
August 3, 2019: Betts goes to the Oregon District in Dayton with his sister and a friend, then leaves them and goes on alone.
August 4, 2019: Nine people die and many more are hurt in the Oregon District. Dayton police officers kill Betts at the scene. Police later release the names of the dead.
Mid-August 2019: The Montgomery County coroner finds that Betts caused all nine deaths and the police none.
December 2019: Final autopsy reports rule all nine deaths homicides caused by Betts.
November 29, 2021: The FBI and Dayton police close their investigation, finding that Betts acted alone and was not directed by or aligned with any group.
January 2022: Dayton police release their investigative report, finding no evidence that Betts targeted his sister.