Colin Gunn, a man from the Bestwood area of Nottingham, was convicted of conspiracy to murder on June 29, 2006 at Birmingham Crown Court. The charge concerned the deaths of John and Joan Stirland in Lincolnshire on August 8, 2004. The following day the trial judge sentenced him to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 35 years, less 470 days already spent on remand. He was 39 at the time of his appeal.
The Court of Appeal, Criminal Division, dismissed his appeal against sentence on May 3, 2007. In the same year he received a further nine years for bribery of two police officers and conspiracy to corrupt. He is a Category A prisoner, and in March 2024 the High Court upheld the decision to keep him classified as a High Escape Risk prisoner.
John and Joan Stirland died in Lincolnshire on August 8, 2004. The conviction concerns the conspiracy to cause their deaths. Nobody was convicted of carrying out the killings themselves. The Court of Appeal recorded that the men who carried them out were never identified.
Gunn stood trial at Birmingham Crown Court before a judge and jury. The indictment charged him with conspiracy to murder. His co-defendants who were convicted of the same offense were John Paul Russell and Michael McNee. Several others tried with them were acquitted.
The trial court found that Gunn financed and organised the plan and recruited the men who were to carry it out. The Court of Appeal later summarized those findings. It recorded that Russell and McNee took part in preparatory work, and that the trial judge regarded Russell as a valuable and essential lieutenant. Gunn was convicted on June 29, 2006, together with Russell and McNee.
All three men were sentenced to life imprisonment on June 30, 2006. The minimum terms were as follows. Gunn received 35 years, less 470 days on remand. Russell received 30 years, less 289 days. McNee, who was 19 years and 4 months old at the time of the offense, received 25 years, less 402 days. The judge set the longest term for Gunn, who had been the organiser.
Gunn, Russell and McNee appealed against sentence, and Gunn's case reached the Court of Appeal on a referral by the Registrar of Criminal Appeals, with leave granted. The court heard the appeals before a bench led by the President of the Queen's Bench Division, and gave judgment on May 3, 2007.
There were three arguments. The first was that a discretionary life sentence was wrong in principle for these offenders. The second was that the sentencing scheme in Schedule 21 to the Criminal Justice Act 2003 should not have been applied to a conspiracy conviction. The third was that the minimum terms were too long. The court rejected all three. It held that the offense merited a discretionary life sentence, that the judge was entitled to use Schedule 21 given that the conspiracy ended in killings, and that he had made suitable distinctions between the three men, including for the age of the youngest. All the appeals were dismissed. The court concluded that the crime "merited punishment of the utmost severity."
In 2007 Gunn was tried separately on charges arising from payments to police officers. He was convicted of bribery of two police officers and conspiracy to corrupt, and was sentenced to nine years.
In February 2008 the Independent Police Complaints Commission published its findings on how Nottinghamshire and Lincolnshire Police had handled the Stirland case. It found that the protection given to John and Joan Stirland by Nottinghamshire Police was below an acceptable level and that they had received no professional advice on witness protection. In February 2010 HM Inspectorate of Constabulary reported on the intelligence and witness-protection arrangements of both forces, in connection with the inquests into the two deaths.
Gunn has served his sentence in the prison system of England. He has been classified as a High Escape Risk prisoner since September 2013. On February 13, 2023 the Ministry of Justice decided not to lower that classification, and Gunn brought a claim for judicial review.
A High Court judge heard the claim on March 13, 2024 and dismissed it in a judgment of March 25, 2024. He held that the decision to keep the classification was rational and that the refusal of an oral hearing was lawful on the facts, because a hearing would have served no useful purpose. He also held that a blanket exclusion of oral hearings in escape-risk cases could not be justified in principle.
Conspiracy to murder is an offense for which a court may impose a discretionary life sentence. The minimum term that must be served before the Parole Board may consider release is set under Schedule 21 to the Criminal Justice Act 2003. In the Gunn appeal the Court of Appeal held that the trial judge was not obliged to use the Schedule 21 starting points for a conspiracy conviction but was entitled to, because the conspiracy had led to deaths. Gunn's 35-year term was the longest of the three.
No person has been convicted of carrying out the killings. The men who did so were not identified, and the convictions of Gunn, Russell and McNee are for conspiracy. Several other defendants were acquitted at the same trial.
August 8, 2004: John and Joan Stirland die in Lincolnshire.
June 29, 2006: Gunn, Russell and McNee are convicted of conspiracy to murder at Birmingham Crown Court.
June 30, 2006: Life sentences; minimum terms of 35, 30 and 25 years.
May 3, 2007: Court of Appeal dismisses the appeals against sentence.
2007: Gunn receives nine years for bribery of two police officers and conspiracy to corrupt.
February 2008: Independent Police Complaints Commission publishes its findings.
February 2010: HM Inspectorate of Constabulary reports on intelligence and witness protection in both forces.
September 2013: Gunn is classified as a High Escape Risk prisoner.
March 25, 2024: High Court dismisses his judicial review claim.