Cole Younger was one of three brothers from western Missouri who stood before the Rice County District Court at Faribault, Minnesota, in November 1876 and pleaded guilty. The case arose from September 7, 1876, the day a band of eight riders came into Northfield and an attempt on the First National Bank there failed. Two townsmen died. Younger and two of his brothers were captured two weeks later, indicted by a Rice County grand jury, and on November 20, 1876, they pleaded guilty and were sentenced to life in the Minnesota State Prison at Stillwater. His pleas made him an accessory to the murder of the first of the two men to die, and admitted an assault on a man who survived and the robbery of the bank.
He served nearly twenty-five years. Governor after governor declined to release him. A 1901 statute allowing the parole of life prisoners opened the way, and in July 1901 the state paroled Younger and his surviving brother. A conditional pardon followed early in 1903, on terms that sent him out of Minnesota for good. He lived the rest of his life in Missouri and died in Lee's Summit on March 21, 1916.
Thomas Coleman Younger was born on January 15, 1844, near Lee's Summit, in Jackson County, Missouri.
The events in Northfield on September 7, 1876, took only a few minutes. The band that rode into town that afternoon included Cole, Jim and Bob Younger, and the attempt on the bank failed. One townsman died that day and a second several days later; a third man survived.
On September 21, 1876, the three Younger brothers were captured near Madelia, Minnesota, and they were taken to the county jail at Faribault, the seat of Rice County.
The case went before a Rice County grand jury that fall. There were four indictments in all. Between them they charged the brothers with the murder of the first of the two men, with the murder of Nicolaus Gustavson, with an assault on the man who survived, and with the robbery of the bank.
The brothers did not go to trial. On November 20, 1876, in the Rice County District Court at Faribault, Cole, Jim and Bob Younger pleaded guilty. Cole Younger's pleas were to being "accessory to the murder of J. L. Heywood," to assault on the man who survived, and to robbery of the First National Bank of Northfield. The court sentenced each of them to imprisonment for life in the state prison at Stillwater, and the judgment roll committed them there.
The Minnesota State Prison at Stillwater held Cole Younger for almost a quarter of a century. The sentence was life at hard labor. He worked in the prison's wood shop, served as an orderly and became the prison librarian, and in 1887 the brothers were among the founders of a prison newspaper. The first issue of the Prison Mirror came out on August 10, 1887.
Bob Younger died in the prison on September 15, 1889. Cole and Jim remained.
For two decades every request to free the brothers failed. The governor declined pardon applications for them in 1881, and the governors who followed declined as well.
Parole was no answer either. When Minnesota gave the prison's board of managers the power to parole convicts, in an act approved on March 27, 1893, the statute shut the door on men in Cole Younger's position in plain words: it applied to any prisoner "excepting life convicts," and it added that no convict serving a life sentence "shall be paroled." For a man serving life, only a pardon could end the sentence.
In November 1896 Minnesota voters amended the state constitution and moved the pardon power from the governor alone to a Board of Pardons made up of the governor, the chief justice of the state supreme court and the attorney general, whose decisions had to be unanimous. Under an act approved on February 26, 1897, the board could grant an absolute pardon or a conditional one, and a conditional pardon had to state its terms.
Cole and Jim Younger applied to the new board almost at once. Their applications, dated June 16, 1897, asked for a pardon or a commutation of sentence on the grounds that they had been imprisoned nearly twenty-one years, more than double the average time served by life prisoners, that their conduct had been perfect, and that they were reformed men. The board declined the applications on July 13, 1897.
In 1901 Minnesota rewrote its law on the parole of prisoners. The new section let the prison's board of managers parole a prisoner serving a time sentence, a sentence on the reformatory plan, "or for life," but it fenced the life prisoner in with conditions. No life prisoner was to go free on parole until he had served thirty-five years under his sentence, less the reduction for good conduct the law would have allowed him on a thirty-five-year term. Nor was he to be paroled at all without the unanimous written consent of the members of the Board of Pardons, and only if it appeared to the board of managers that there was "a strong and reasonable probability" that he would live and remain at liberty without violating the law. A paroled prisoner had to stay within Minnesota, stayed in the legal custody of the board of managers, could be taken back inside the prison walls at any time on the board's written order, and had to be returned if he exhibited himself, or let himself be exhibited, in any dime museum, circus, theater, opera house or other place of public amusement where admission was charged.
Cole and Jim Younger filed applications for parole on May 8, 1901, citing nearly twenty-five years served, obedience to the prison's rules and every evidence of reform. On July 10, 1901, the Board of Pardons, signed by the governor, the chief justice and the attorney general, recorded that it was satisfied that the act was a law and that the parole of the Youngers was valid, and the brothers were released on parole. Cole Younger's original parole agreement and an employment agreement are both dated July 23, 1901.
The parole required Cole Younger to stay in Minnesota, and the board supervised his movements and approved any job he took. In December 1901 he applied again, asking to be allowed to return home and go into business. The board denied the application, and Jim's with it, as "premature" in January 1902.
Cole Younger applied for a pardon in December 1902, asking for a conditional or an unconditional one and pointing to his reformation and to how hard it had been to earn a living on parole. The Board of Pardons granted it on conditions, under the signatures of the governor, the chief justice and the attorney general: he had to leave Minnesota immediately and never voluntarily come back, and he had to file a written promise never to exhibit himself, or allow himself to be exhibited, where admission was charged. The promise carried into his freedom the same line the parole statute had drawn around him while he was still in the board's custody. He accepted those terms on February 7, 1903, and left for Missouri.
Cole Younger died in Lee's Summit on March 21, 1916.
No court ever decided who fired in Northfield. The case against the three brothers ended in guilty pleas, so no jury heard evidence on the events in the town, and Cole Younger's conviction for the death in the bank was as an accessory.
The brothers refused to name the other members of the band.
January 15, 1844: Thomas Coleman Younger born near Lee's Summit, Missouri.
September 7, 1876: Attempt on the First National Bank of Northfield, Minnesota, fails; two townsmen die.
September 21, 1876: Captured with his brothers Jim and Bob near Madelia, Minnesota.
Fall 1876: Indicted by a Rice County grand jury on four indictments.
November 20, 1876: Pleads guilty in Rice County District Court, Faribault; sentenced to life at Stillwater.
1881: Governor declines pardon applications for the brothers.
August 10, 1887: First issue of the Prison Mirror.
September 15, 1889: Bob Younger dies in the prison.
March 27, 1893: Minnesota parole act approved, excluding life convicts.
November 1896: Constitutional amendment creates the Board of Pardons.
June 16, 1897: Cole and Jim Younger apply to the board for pardon or commutation.
July 13, 1897: Board declines the pardon applications of Cole and Jim Younger.
1901: A new Minnesota parole law allows parole of life prisoners under strict conditions.
May 8, 1901: Cole and Jim Younger file applications for parole.
July 10, 1901: Board of Pardons records the paroles as valid; the brothers are released on parole.
July 23, 1901: Parole agreement and employment agreement dated.
December 1901: Applies to return home; denied as "premature" in January 1902.
December 1902: Applies for a pardon.
February 7, 1903: Accepts a conditional pardon requiring him to leave Minnesota.
March 21, 1916: Dies in Lee's Summit, Missouri.