Cody Posey was 14 when his father, his stepmother and his stepsister died in Lincoln County, in south-central New Mexico, in July 2004. Within days he was under arrest and charged with three counts of murder and four counts of tampering with evidence. A jury in Alamogordo convicted him in 2006, and the question that remained was whether a boy that young would be punished as an adult or as a child. The law gave the court both roads, and the choice it made decided the rest of his youth.
The three people who died were Delbert Paul Posey, his father, and Tryone Posey, his stepmother, along with her daughter, a girl still in her childhood. The deaths are fixed in the court record as July 5, 2004. They came to light after the holiday weekend, and the Lincoln County Sheriff's Office settled on the household's 14-year-old son as its suspect almost at once. Deputies arrested him in July 2004, the day after the deaths were discovered.
The district attorney's office filed three counts of murder, one for each death, and four counts of tampering with evidence. The case stayed in the children's court of the state district court in Alamogordo, and he waited for trial in a juvenile detention center in New Mexico, in custody from the day of his arrest until the day of his release.
The trial opened in January 2006 and ran three weeks. The defense raised abuse. The jury returned its verdicts in February 2006, and they were not the same for each death. For his stepsister, the jury found him guilty of first-degree murder. For his stepmother, second-degree murder. For his father, voluntary manslaughter. It also convicted him on all four counts of tampering with evidence.
Under New Mexico's Children's Code, a 14-year-old found guilty of first-degree murder fell into the class the code calls youthful offenders, and the court could impose either an adult sentence or a juvenile disposition. An adult sentence required the judge to find, at a separate hearing, that the boy could not be treated or rehabilitated as a child in the facilities available. The state asked for adult sentences, which on the first-degree count meant life without parole. The judge decided instead that the boy could be rehabilitated, and in 2006 he sentenced Cody Posey as a juvenile, committing him to state custody until he turned 21, when the court's hold on him would end.
That day came in October 2010. He was released the day before his 21st birthday, with the court's jurisdiction over him at an end and no probation to follow.
The abuse claim was the central dispute of the case and was never settled outside the verdicts: the defense said he had been abused for years, and the state denied it. The jury's verdicts are the only formal finding the case produced.
The day of the deaths also shifted in the first reports. The sheriff said in the first days of the investigation that the three appeared to have died on the Saturday of the holiday weekend; the date later used in court and in the coverage of his release is Monday, July 5, 2004.
July 5, 2004: His father, stepmother and stepsister die on a ranch in Lincoln County, New Mexico.
July 2004: Deputies arrest Cody Posey, 14; he is charged with three counts of murder and four counts of tampering with evidence.
January 2006: His jury trial opens in the children's court in Alamogordo.
February 2006: The jury convicts him of first-degree murder, second-degree murder, voluntary manslaughter and four counts of tampering with evidence.
2006: The judge rejects the state's request for adult sentences, finds that he can be rehabilitated and sentences him as a juvenile to state custody until age 21.
October 2010: He is released the day before his 21st birthday, with court jurisdiction ended and no probation.