Clément Kayishema

Victims
Tens of thousands of Tutsi killed in Kibuye Prefecture, 1994. Convicted by the UN tribunal for Rwanda on May 21, 1999, of four counts of genocide; affirmed on appeal June 1, 2001.
Years active
April 14 to June 30, 1994 (court findings: Gishyita commune April 14-16; Kibuye town April 17 and 18; Bisesero April to June)
Location
Kibuye town and Gishyita and Bisesero area, Kibuye Prefecture, Rwanda; Arusha, Tanzania; Bamako, Mali
Method
Genocide, as an individual who ordered and took part in attacks, and as a superior responsible for his subordinates
Status
Imprisonment for the remainder of his life (May 21, 1999); appeal dismissed June 1, 2001; sent to Mali December 9, 2001; died while serving the sentence

Clement Kayishema was a trained physician who had run hospitals before the government of Rwanda made him prefect of Kibuye, the western prefecture on the shore of Lake Kivu. In April 1994, in the first weeks of the genocide against the Tutsi, thousands of Tutsi men, women and children gathered in places in and around Kibuye town that had sheltered people in earlier waves of violence. The International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda found that Kayishema, the most senior civil authority in the prefecture, brought gendarmes, communal police, local officials and militia to those places and led the massacres that followed, and that he went on directing attacks in the hills of Bisesero into June.

On May 21, 1999, Trial Chamber II of the tribunal, sitting in Arusha, Tanzania, found him guilty on four counts of genocide, one for each of four crime sites, and sentenced him to imprisonment for the remainder of his life. The judges found that about 8,000 Tutsis were killed at the first site, between 8,000 and 27,000 at the second, between 4,000 and 5,500 at the third, and that the dead in the Bisesero area numbered well into the tens of thousands. The Appeals Chamber dismissed his appeal on June 1, 2001. Six months later he was among the first prisoners of the tribunal flown to Mali to serve their sentences, and he died while still serving his.

A doctor in public service

Kayishema was born in 1954 in Bwishyura sector, Gitesi commune, in Kibuye Prefecture. In 1974 he was appointed registrar of a canton tribunal, and the following year he won a scholarship to the faculty of medicine of the National University of Rwanda in Butare. After graduating he practiced general medicine and surgery. In 1984 the government sent him to work as a doctor in a camp for refugees from Uganda. From 1986 to 1991 he was medical director of the hospital at Nyanza, and he was then transferred to the hospital in Kibuye, his native prefecture.

Rwanda opened to multiparty politics in 1992. In April of that year Kayishema joined the Christian Democratic Party, and on July 3, 1992, he was appointed prefect of Kibuye. The prefect was the state's highest representative in the prefecture, and the trial judgment found that he held legal authority over the bourgmestres who ran each commune, over the communal police and over the gendarmes. After the airplane carrying President Juvénal Habyarimana crashed on its approach to Kigali on April 6, 1994, the interim government kept Kayishema in his post. The massacre of civilians began throughout Rwanda almost at once, and the trial judgment found that it was carried out under a plan aimed at the Tutsi as a group.

Four counts of genocide

The indictment was built around four places in Kibuye where Tutsis fleeing attacks in the communes had gathered, and each became a count of genocide: Count 1, the Catholic Church and Home Saint-Jean complex in Kibuye town; Count 7, the stadium in the same town; Count 13, the church at Mubuga, in Gishyita commune, about 20 kilometers away; and Count 19, the hills of the Bisesero area. The trial chamber found that the people at the first three sites had gone there of their own accord, and that once they were there they could not leave.

The first of the killings in time took place in Gishyita commune between April 14 and 16. Of the thousands gathered there, the chamber found, only a few survived. The indictment did not allege that Kayishema was personally present, but five witnesses placed him there, and the chamber found beyond a reasonable doubt that he and his subordinates, among them local authorities, gendarmes, communal police and members of the Interahamwe militia, were present and took part in the attacks.

The chamber did not find that he gave the order to attack in Gishyita, and for that site it held him responsible as a superior. It found that he knew or had reason to know that a large-scale massacre was imminent: attacks on Tutsis were already under way across Rwanda, he was aware of them, and the attackers were men over whom he held either legal or actual control. His duty as prefect to keep public order, the judges held, placed him under a positive duty to stop his subordinates, and no evidence was offered that he tried.

In Kibuye town the attack on the Count 1 site came on April 17. Six witnesses who had known Kayishema before the events identified him there. The chamber found beyond a reasonable doubt that he knew the attack was coming, that he ordered and instigated it, that the attack began on his order, and that he was present, took part and played a leading role. The chamber put the number killed there at about 8,000.

The next day, the chamber found, Kayishema ordered gendarmes, communal police and the Interahamwe to attack the thousands of Tutsis assembled at the Count 7 site, and he took part in the attack himself. The killing went on into a second day. The chamber's estimate of the dead there ran from 8,000 to 27,000.

Many of those who survived in and around Kibuye town fled into the hills of Bisesero, and the attacks on them went on through April, May and June. The trial chamber found that Kayishema led and directed those attacks throughout the period, with bourgmestres and councilors, communal police, the gendarmerie, the Interahamwe and soldiers taking part. At one point, the judges found, his co-accused, a businessman from the prefecture, directed a group of attackers under Kayishema's overall lead. The chamber said the number who died in the Bisesero area was difficult to estimate but ran well into the tens of thousands.

Kayishema stayed in office until July 1994, when he left Rwanda for Zaire.

Arrest and trial

The United Nations Security Council created the tribunal on November 8, 1994, to try genocide and other serious violations of international humanitarian law committed in Rwanda that year. Its first chief prosecutor indicted Kayishema in November 1995. He was arrested in Zambia on May 2, 1996, transferred to the United Nations Detention Facility in Arusha later that month, and pleaded not guilty to every charge.

The trial opened before Trial Chamber II on April 11, 1997, the first joint trial in the tribunal's history. Kayishema faced 24 counts, six for each site: genocide, three counts of crimes against humanity (murder, extermination and other inhumane acts), and two counts of serious violations of the Geneva Conventions and Additional Protocol II. His co-accused faced the six counts for Bisesero. Survivors from every site testified for the prosecution, and Kayishema testified in his own defense. The evidence closed in November 1998.

The alibi

Kayishema's defense rested on an alibi. He testified that he had been in hiding from the morning of April 16, 1994, to the morning of April 20, which would have kept him away from the attacks in Kibuye town. He accepted that he had gone into the Bisesero area in May, but only on prefectoral business, and denied ever visiting the massacre sites there. He maintained that the witnesses who identified him were mistaken.

The chamber found the alibi riddled with contradictions. The defense witnesses' accounts conflicted with one another and with his own, and those who had seen him only at isolated meetings could say little about where he was when the killing took place. In an interview with tribunal investigators in November 1996, the judges noted, he had been unable to give any dates for his time in hiding; at trial he recalled exact dates, days and even times. The chamber concluded that the alibi raised no doubt about the prosecution's case.

The findings of law

The trial chamber held Kayishema responsible in two ways. Under the tribunal's statute he was individually responsible for crimes he planned, instigated, ordered, committed or aided and abetted at each site. He was also responsible as a superior for the crimes of his subordinates. Whether a civilian prefect could be held responsible as a superior was central to the case. The chamber looked first at Rwandan law, under which a prefect could requisition the communal police in times of grave public disorder (a 1963 law on the commune) and the gendarmes (a 1974 decree-law on the Gendarmerie Nationale). It then looked beyond formal authority to the control he actually exercised in 1994, and found both. He knew of the crimes, the judges held, failed to prevent them, and in fact directed and led the massacres himself.

Rwandan law, the chamber held, placed the bourgmestres under the prefect's hierarchical authority. The 1963 law on the commune allowed him to discipline a bourgmestre, to propose his dismissal to the Minister of the Interior, and to step in when communal authorities failed to act, and a 1975 decree-law on the prefecture gave him a general power of supervision over the acts of the communes. The chamber found it beyond any doubt that Kayishema held legal power over the bourgmestres, communal police, gendarmes and other law enforcement agencies identified at the massacre sites, and that throughout 1994 he went on treating the bourgmestres as his subordinates and expecting his requests to be carried out.

The defense argued, with expert evidence, that those powers had been emptied of meaning in the political collapse that followed the president's death, and that the prefect had neither the means nor the standing to stop the killing. The judges found that account out of step with what had happened in Kibuye. The prefect was a well-known and respected figure in his community, and the administration, the law enforcement agencies and armed civilians had acted together in a common plan to destroy the Tutsi population. Kayishema, the chamber concluded, had legal authority over most of the attackers and actual control over all of them, and every attack charged, except the one in Gishyita, began on his orders. On punishment, the judges found no evidence that in the three months between the first attacks and his departure from Rwanda any step was taken that might have brought those responsible to justice.

On genocide, the chamber found beyond a reasonable doubt that Kayishema intended to destroy the Tutsi group in whole or in part. It drew that intent from the number killed at the four sites, from the methodical pattern of the attacks across the prefecture from April to June, and from words spoken by Kayishema and by men acting under his direction.

The chamber also looked past the four sites to the genocide as a whole. A national plan of genocide, it found, existed before the president's airplane went down and was carried out at the level of the prefectures, and Kayishema, as prefect, passed information to the officials above and below him along the established lines of the administration. Those who carried out the killings in Kibuye, the judges concluded, shared a single intent, to destroy the Tutsi group within the prefecture, and Kayishema played a pivotal role in carrying out that common plan.

A majority of the chamber held that the counts of murder and extermination as crimes against humanity rested on exactly the same conduct as the genocide count at each site and were subsumed by it. The counts of other inhumane acts failed because neither the indictment nor the evidence had identified the acts said to make up that crime. The counts under the Geneva Conventions and Additional Protocol II failed because the prosecution had not shown that the crimes were committed in direct connection with the armed conflict between the government and the Rwandan Patriotic Front; the victims, the chamber found, were civilians attacked by the authorities of their own country because of their ethnicity.

Verdict, sentence and appeal

The chamber unanimously found Kayishema guilty of genocide on Counts 1, 7, 13 and 19 and acquitted him of the other 20 counts. One of the three judges dissented on the cumulative charges and would have convicted him of murder and extermination as well. His co-accused, convicted of one count of genocide for Bisesero, received 25 years.

The sentencing decision, delivered the same day, weighed the gravity of the crime first. Genocide, the chamber said, was an offense of the most extreme gravity, and Kayishema's four convictions for it were offenses beyond human comprehension. Rwanda's own law, which reserved its heaviest penalties for those who planned or led the genocide or acted from positions of authority, pointed the same way.

The chamber found four aggravating circumstances: his disregard of the prefect's duty to protect the people and keep the peace, and his use of the office to carry out the crimes; the zeal with which he acted, shown in attacks on places long regarded as safe havens; the methodical and systematic way the crimes were carried out; and his failure afterward to punish the perpetrators. As a leader of the genocide in Kibuye, the judges held, his abuse of power and betrayal of his high office was the most significant aggravating circumstance of all. They also counted the irreparable harm done to the victims and their families and, in light of the convictions, his denial of guilt throughout the trial.

The defense asked the chamber to weigh the collapse of the rule of law in Rwanda in 1994 and the pressure of crowd behavior, and described Kayishema as loyal and honest. The chamber noted that he had voluntarily submitted to interviews with the prosecutor's investigators, but it gave the mitigating circumstances very little weight. It explained why he deserved a heavier sentence than his co-accused: he had held a position of high authority, he stood convicted on four counts rather than one, he had at least once instructed and praised his co-accused, and he was an educated physician who had betrayed the ethical duty he owed his community. It imposed imprisonment for the remainder of his life on each of the four counts, the terms to run concurrently, and gave the phrase its plain meaning, distinct from a life sentence under most national laws.

Kayishema appealed against conviction and sentence, challenging the fairness of the trial, the specificity of the indictment, the rejection of his alibi, the findings of genocide and the finding that he had command authority over the forces that did the killing. On June 1, 2001, the Appeals Chamber found no error of law or fact in the trial judgment, dismissed every ground and affirmed the convictions and the life sentence. The prosecution's own appeal against the acquittals was held inadmissible, with one judge dissenting, because its brief had been filed out of time.

In its reasons the Appeals Chamber began from the limits of its own role. It was not retrying the case, it said, and the burden of showing that the trial chamber's findings were unreasonable rested on Kayishema; an appellant who simply proposed another conclusion the trial judges might have reached had not shown an error.

On the alibi, the Appeals Chamber set out the rule in plain terms. The duty to give notice of an alibi and of the evidence for it, it held, places no burden of proof on the defense, which need only produce evidence likely to raise a reasonable doubt about the prosecution's case. The prosecution must always prove the facts charged and the accused's responsibility for them, and failure to prove an alibi must not be treated as a sign of guilt. Measured against that rule, the trial chamber's handling of his alibi disclosed no error.

On his authority, Kayishema argued that where a prefect held no legal authority over the attackers he could hold no actual authority over them either. The Appeals Chamber called that argument misconceived. The question, it held, turned on whether the superior had effective control over the people who committed the crimes, and that control could rest on legal authority or on the facts. On intent, it held that explicit statements of criminal intent are, for obvious reasons, rare in criminal trials, and that the intent required for genocide may normally be inferred from the relevant facts and circumstances.

On December 9, 2001, Kayishema was one of six convicted men flown from the detention facility in Arusha to Bamako, Mali, the first prisoners of the tribunal transferred to a national prison to serve their sentences. The records of the International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals, which took over the tribunal's remaining work, list him among the persons convicted by the tribunal who died while serving their sentences.

Disputed and unproven points

Kayishema denied the charges throughout. He maintained at trial that he had been in hiding during the April killings in Kibuye town and had never visited the massacre sites in Bisesero, and on appeal he argued that he had lacked the authority to command the forces that carried out the killings. Both the trial chamber and the Appeals Chamber rejected those arguments, and the convictions are final.

Several of the prosecution's allegations were not proved. The chamber did not find that Kayishema ordered the Tutsis to gather at the Count 1 site, or that he was present on the second day of the killing at the Count 7 site. Of the 24 counts, he was convicted on the four counts of genocide only, and because the prosecution's appeal was dismissed as filed out of time, the acquittals were never reviewed on their merits.

The numbers killed are the trial chamber's estimates. For the Count 7 site in particular, the range it gave, from 8,000 to 27,000, reflects how widely the evidence varied.

Timeline

1954: Born in Bwishyura sector, Gitesi commune, Kibuye Prefecture, Rwanda.

1975: Begins medical studies at the National University of Rwanda in Butare on a scholarship.

1986 to 1991: Medical director of the hospital at Nyanza; then transferred to the Kibuye hospital.

April 1992: Joins the Christian Democratic Party.

July 3, 1992: Appointed prefect of Kibuye.

April 6, 1994: The airplane carrying President Juvénal Habyarimana crashes at Kigali; massacres begin across Rwanda.

April 14 to 16, 1994: Killings at the Count 13 site, Gishyita commune.

April 17, 1994: Killings at the Count 1 site in Kibuye town.

April 18 and 19, 1994: Killings at the Count 7 site in Kibuye town.

April to June 1994: Attacks in the Bisesero area.

July 1994: Leaves Rwanda for Zaire.

November 1995: Indicted by the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda.

May 2, 1996: Arrested in Zambia; later that month transferred to Arusha.

April 11, 1997: Joint trial opens before Trial Chamber II.

May 21, 1999: Convicted on four counts of genocide and sentenced to imprisonment for the remainder of his life.

June 1, 2001: Appeals Chamber dismisses his appeal and affirms the convictions and sentence.

December 9, 2001: Transferred to Bamako, Mali, to serve his sentence.