Christopher Porco

Victims
1 murder and 1 attempted murder: convicted in 2006 of the murder of his own father and the attempted murder of his own mother, Bethlehem (Delmar), New York.
Years active
November 15, 2004
Location
Bethlehem (Delmar), Albany County, New York (killing and attempted killing); New York state prison (sentence).
Method
Struck with an axe; his father was killed and his mother injured in the same attack.
Status
Convicted 2006; 50 years to life. Court of Appeals affirmed, October 18, 2011. Motion to set aside the verdict announced January 2023. In a New York state prison as of January 2023.

In the early hours of November 15, 2004, a husband and wife who had been married for thirty years were attacked in their home in Bethlehem, the suburban town outside Albany, New York, that takes in the hamlet of Delmar. Peter Porco died. His wife survived. Within a year their younger son, Christopher, a University of Rochester undergraduate, had been charged with murdering his father and attempting to murder his mother. In 2006 a jury convicted him on both counts after a seven-week trial, and he was sentenced to 50 years to life.

The case drew national attention because the only living witness was the defendant's own mother. Paramedics testified that in the hours after the attack she nodded when asked whether her son was the person who had attacked her. She has said she has no memory of the attack and never identified him, and she testified for the defense at his trial. Whether the jury should ever have heard about that nod carried the case to the New York Court of Appeals, which in October 2011 held that even if admitting the testimony was a constitutional error, the error was harmless because the rest of the evidence was overwhelming.

By November 2004 Christopher was living in a dormitory at the University of Rochester, where he swam and belonged to a fraternity. In the days before the attack his father had confronted him in emails after finding his own signature on loan papers he had never signed.

That financial strain became a central part of the prosecution's case. The prosecution's account was that Christopher had forged his father's signature on a loan for a car and on a $31,000 loan for his schooling, that he was failing at school and deep in debt, and that his parents' deaths would bring him a large financial benefit.

The case also reached back two years. On the night of November 18 to 19, 2002, while Christopher was home from college for Thanksgiving, two laptop computers were taken from the family's property. He later stipulated in court that he had sold one of them online weeks after it disappeared. The trial court allowed the jury to hear about the 2002 theft, and the Court of Appeals later called that evidence "unique and highly probative" of identity.

The father was dead when help arrived. Detectives began looking for the younger son the same day, and he was questioned at a police station for about six hours. Investigators then spoke to his fraternity brothers in Rochester, none of whom could confirm his account that he had spent the night in a dormitory lounge.

That account never changed in substance. On five separate occasions, the Court of Appeals later noted, he said he had planned to sleep, or had slept, in the lounge of his dormitory. Seven students who were in the lounge during that period said they had not seen him there. He said he had tried to call his parents that day, but the telephone records did not show the call.

Other evidence placed him in Bethlehem. A neighbor gave an account of an early-morning sighting that tied Christopher to the family property. Records from the household alarm system pointed to someone who knew its master code, which only a handful of people knew, Christopher among them. Investigators also gathered camera footage and other records that, in the Court of Appeals' later description, placed him in the town that night.

On November 4, 2005, almost a year after the attack, Christopher Porco was charged with murdering his father and attempting to murder his mother. He was held without bail at first, then released on bail about a month later, and he remained free until trial.

The trial lasted seven weeks, and more than eighty witnesses were called. The paramedics who had treated the mother testified about the nod. A neurologist called by the defense testified that, given her condition, she probably could not have understood the questions put to her. Nine of Christopher's fraternity brothers testified about the night of November 14 to 15, as did the neighbor.

The defense case was that nothing recovered in the investigation tied Christopher to the attack, that the neighbor might have been mistaken, and that the mother's response in the hours after the attack could not be relied on. Christopher did not testify.

The jury deliberated for less than six hours and returned a unanimous verdict of guilty on both counts: the murder of his father and the attempted murder of his mother. The court sentenced him to 50 years to life.

The Appellate Division affirmed the conviction, and Christopher Porco took the case to the state's highest court. There his lawyer argued that letting the jury hear testimony that his injured mother had nodded when asked whether he was her attacker violated his constitutional right to confront the witnesses against him, since she said she remembered nothing of it.

The Court of Appeals decided the appeal on October 18, 2011, in a short memorandum. It did not resolve the confrontation question. It assumed, without deciding, that the testimony about the nod was constitutionally flawed, and held that any error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt because there was no reasonable possibility that it had affected the verdict.

The court set out why. It pointed to the evidence placing him in Bethlehem that night, including camera footage, alarm records tied to a code that only a few people knew, and the neighbor's testimony; to the repeated claims about the dormitory lounge that the other students contradicted; to the call to his parents that the records did not support; and to the 2002 theft, which in the court's view bore directly on identity. The order of the Appellate Division was affirmed.

In January 2023 a new lawyer for Christopher Porco announced a motion under the state's criminal procedure law asking the court to set aside the verdict. As of January 2023 he was serving his sentence of 50 years to life in a New York state prison.

Christopher Porco has maintained his innocence: he has called the financial motive argued at trial absurd and has said that the person responsible is still free.

The meaning of the nod described by the paramedics was contested at trial, where a defense neurologist testified that the mother probably could not have understood the questions. The Court of Appeals did not decide whether the jury should have heard that testimony; it held that the conviction stood without it.

Timeline

November 18 to 19, 2002: two laptop computers are taken from the family's property in Bethlehem, New York, while Christopher is home for Thanksgiving; he later stipulates that he sold one of them.

November 15, 2004: the father is killed and the mother injured in Bethlehem; Christopher is questioned for about six hours the same day.

November 4, 2005: Christopher Porco is charged with the murder of his father and the attempted murder of his mother; he is later released on bail until trial.

2006: after a seven-week trial with more than eighty witnesses, a jury convicts him on both counts; he is sentenced to 50 years to life.

October 18, 2011: the New York Court of Appeals affirms, holding any error in admitting the nod testimony harmless beyond a reasonable doubt.

January 2023: a motion to set aside the verdict is announced; he remains imprisoned in New York.