Christopher McCowen

Victims
1 murder: convicted November 16, 2006, of first-degree murder, aggravated rape and aggravated burglary in the death of Christa Worthington
Years active
January 2002
Location
Truro, Massachusetts (killing); Barnstable, Massachusetts (trial)
Method
Stabbed; she was also beaten (evidence at trial)
Status
Life without parole, with concurrent life terms, November 16, 2006; affirmed by the Supreme Judicial Court December 10, 2010. Imprisoned in Massachusetts as of July 2024.

Christopher McCowen was convicted in November 2006 of the first-degree murder, aggravated rape and aggravated burglary of Christa Worthington, a woman whose trash he had collected in Truro, near the tip of Cape Cod. She died in the first days of January 2002, and her death became known on January 6. Her young daughter was with her. For more than three years the investigation turned on the men who had been part of the victim's life, and none of them was charged. McCowen was arrested in April 2005, after a sample he had given investigators voluntarily a year earlier was finally examined and linked him to the case.

A Barnstable jury found him guilty on every count, and he was sentenced the same day to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Within days, three members of that jury came forward to claim that racial prejudice had entered the deliberations. McCowen is Black; the victim was white. The trial judge recalled the entire jury to answer questions in open court, then ruled that the verdict had not been tainted, and the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts agreed in December 2010. McCowen has maintained his innocence throughout, and further motions for a new trial have followed and failed.

She had grown up partly in Truro and spent much of her adult life far from it, in Hingham, then for several years in Paris, then London, then New York. In 1997 she came back to Truro and stayed, and she chose to live there year-round to raise her daughter. By January 2002 she was a single mother in the small town where she had grown up.

Her death began a three-year inquiry by the Massachusetts State Police and the Cape and Islands District Attorney's office. Investigators questioned the men they knew had been close to her, friends and former partners, and the evidence cleared each of them. The case went cold without going away. In early 2005 the district attorney's office asked the men of Truro to volunteer samples, an appeal that drew objections from civil liberties advocates.

The answer had already been sitting with investigators. McCowen drove the trash route that included her property, and twice he told police he did not know her. He had agreed to give a sample and provided it in March 2004, a year before the Truro appeal. It was not examined until the week before his arrest in April 2005, when it linked him to the case. On April 15, 2005, the district attorney announced that Christopher M. McCowen had been arrested and charged with the murder.

State police detectives questioned McCowen for about six hours. The interview was not recorded, and the detectives wrote their report about a week later from their notes. By that report, McCowen told more than one story over the session. He first denied any involvement. Confronted with the evidence, he gave an account that placed him with her that night but put the killing on a friend of his.

The friend, J.F., denied any part in it. No evidence from the scene matched him, and he was never charged. The way the statement was taken became one of the central disputes of the case: the defense argued that McCowen's intellectual limits and his impaired condition during the questioning made what the detectives wrote down a false confession.

McCowen went on trial in Barnstable Superior Court in the fall of 2006. The prosecution argued that he alone had committed the rape and the murder, and its case rested on the evidence that linked him to the victim and on his own admissions to detectives. Jurors were also instructed that under Massachusetts law they could convict him of murder even if they believed his friend had done the killing, on the theory of a joint criminal venture. The defense disputed the rape charge and attacked the handling of the investigation. McCowen did not testify.

The jury deadlocked, and during the deliberations the judge removed one juror over recorded telephone calls in which she had discussed press coverage of the case, and seated an alternate. Two days after deliberations began again, on November 16, 2006, the jury found Christopher McCowen guilty on all counts: murder in the first degree, aggravated rape and aggravated burglary. He was 34. Given the chance to speak, he told the court he was innocent. The judge imposed life in prison without the possibility of parole, with concurrent life sentences on the other counts. Under Massachusetts law the first-degree murder conviction went automatically to the state's highest court for review.

In December 2006 the defense moved for a new trial on the sworn statements of three jurors, among them the one who had been removed. They alleged that other jurors had made racially biased remarks about McCowen during deliberations; the jurors accused denied the remarks or said they had been misquoted or taken out of context.

The trial judge ordered the whole jury back to court, and on January 10, 2008, in Barnstable, he began questioning the jurors one by one, in public, about whether race had played a part in their verdict. In early April 2008 he denied the motion, finding that the defense had not shown that racial prejudice had tainted the deliberations.

The Supreme Judicial Court decided the appeal, Commonwealth v. McCowen, on December 10, 2010. The court was unanimous. It held that the trial judge had not erred in finding that McCowen was not denied his right to an impartial jury because of a juror's racial bias, upheld the convictions and refused a new trial.

That ruling did not end the case for McCowen. A new legal team filed further motions for a new trial in the Superior Court, and by July 2024 four had been denied. As of July 2024 he remained in prison in Massachusetts, serving life without parole and still maintaining his innocence.

McCowen has never admitted the murder or the rape. His account to detectives put the killing on a friend, who denied it, was never charged and was not linked to the scene by the evidence. Because the jury was told it could convict even if it believed the friend was the killer, the general verdict does not show which view the jurors took.

The reliability of the statement is contested. The interview was not recorded, the report was written from notes about a week later, and it records more than one version of events. The defense argued that McCowen's intellectual limits and his condition made the statement unreliable; the jury heard those arguments and convicted.

The jurors' claims of racial bias were tested in open court and rejected by the trial judge and the Supreme Judicial Court.

Timeline

1997: The victim returns to Truro, Massachusetts.

Early January 2002: She dies in Truro; her death is discovered on January 6, 2002.

2002 to 2005: State police and the Cape and Islands District Attorney's office investigate the men in her circle; none is charged.

March 2004: McCowen voluntarily gives investigators a sample.

Early 2005: The district attorney's office asks Truro men to volunteer samples.

April 2005: McCowen's sample is examined and links him to the case; his arrest is announced on April 15, 2005.

Fall 2006: Trial in Barnstable Superior Court; the jury deadlocks and a juror is replaced.

November 16, 2006: Guilty on all counts; life without parole, with concurrent life terms.

December 2006: Three jurors' sworn statements alleging racial bias support a motion for a new trial.

January 10, 2008: The trial judge begins questioning the recalled jury in open court in Barnstable.

Early April 2008: The trial judge denies the motion for a new trial.

December 10, 2010: The Supreme Judicial Court unanimously affirms the convictions in Commonwealth v. McCowen.

2017 to 2024: Further motions for a new trial are filed; by July 2024 four have been denied.

July 2024: McCowen remains in prison in Massachusetts, serving life without parole.