Chester Gillette was convicted of the murder of Grace Brown, a young woman from the farm country of central New York who died at Big Moose Lake, in the Adirondacks, on July 11, 1906. A Herkimer County jury found him guilty after a trial of about three weeks that was followed across the country, and he was sentenced to death. His appeal failed, clemency was refused, and he was executed at Auburn, New York, on March 30, 1908. He denied murder at his trial and never publicly admitted it afterward. No one saw what happened at the lake. The case against him was built from circumstance: his conduct in the days that followed, and the letters she had written to him in the weeks before she died. Theodore Dreiser later drew on it for his 1925 novel An American Tragedy.
Gillette was born in 1883. His father had been a successful businessman in Spokane, Washington, until a religious conversion turned him and his wife into roving missionaries for the Salvation Army. For several years the son helped with their charity work. He came to reject the spare life they had chosen for themselves and to believe that life was meant to be enjoyed as fully as possible. A loan from a wealthy relative paid for a stay at the preparatory school of Oberlin College, and it came to nothing, and he went to work in the Midwest as a brakeman on the railroad. From there he came east to Cortland, New York, to take a job in the skirt factory owned by his uncle, a business with about 250 employees. He was the owner's nephew, and before long he was moving in a more prosperous social circle in Cortland than the one he had arrived in.
She grew up on a farm in South Otselic, in Chenango County, a short distance from Cortland. Her friends called her Billy, after a popular tune of the day. She was lively and fond of dancing, and the dancing cost her membership in the Baptist church of her town.
She and Gillette met at his uncle's factory in Cortland. He called on her in the evenings, and in the summer of 1905 the two became lovers.
As Gillette made his way into the better society of Cortland, he began to neglect her, although he did not end the relationship. In mid-June 1906 she went back to her parents in South Otselic. From there she wrote him a stream of letters pleading with him to marry her. "I am so frightened, dear," she wrote in one. He barely answered them. At the same time he was paying court to the daughter of a well-to-do Cortland lawyer.
She did not let the matter rest. She warned him that she would make their relationship known, and in early July he proposed a trip together into the Adirondacks. She understood that it would end in their marriage.
On July 11, 1906, the two arrived at Big Moose Lake, in Herkimer County. Gillette registered under an assumed name, Carl Graham. She died at the lake that day, and she was found the next morning.
Gillette did not raise any alarm, and he left the lake. The coroner's examination gave the authorities reason to suspect foul play, and investigators connected the dead woman to the man who had registered with her. Three days after her death Gillette was arrested at Inlet, a short distance from the lake, still using the assumed name.
He said from the beginning that he had not killed her. His account of how she died changed after his arrest.
He was indicted for murder in Herkimer County, and his trial opened there on November 12, 1906. It lasted about three weeks and drew national attention.
The prosecution had no witness to the death and no confession. Its case rested on what the circumstances, Gillette's own conduct and the young woman's letters allowed the jury to infer: that he had planned her death so that he would be free to pursue women of a wealthier class. The letters were the center of the trial, and her pleading, read aloud to the jury in her own words, turned public feeling sharply against the defendant. The defense denied that there had been a murder.
The jury was out for about five hours. It found Gillette guilty of murder, and the court sentenced him to death. His lawyers appealed the conviction, and the appeal failed. Clemency was refused, and Chester Gillette was executed at Auburn, New York, on March 30, 1908.
Beyond the jury's verdict, exactly what happened at Big Moose Lake is not established. No witness saw the death. The prosecution's account came from inference, and the defense denied that there had been a murder at all.
Gillette protested his innocence publicly to the end. Accounts after his death held that he had privately admitted his guilt shortly before his execution, but he left no written confession, and the question has never been settled.
1883: Chester Gillette is born.
Summer 1905: He and the young woman from South Otselic become lovers in Cortland, New York.
Mid-June 1906: She returns to her parents in South Otselic and writes to him asking him to marry her.
Early July 1906: He proposes a trip into the Adirondacks.
July 11, 1906: The two arrive at Big Moose Lake, Herkimer County, where he registers under an assumed name; she dies there that day.
July 12, 1906: She is found.
Three days after her death: Gillette is arrested at Inlet, New York.
November 12, 1906: His trial for murder opens in Herkimer County.
Late 1906: The jury finds him guilty of murder after about five hours; he is sentenced to death.
Early 1908: His appeal fails and clemency is refused.
March 30, 1908: Gillette is executed at Auburn, New York.