Chérif and Saïd Kouachi

Victims
12 people killed at Charlie Hebdo, Paris, 2015; never tried. Attributed to the brothers by the Paris prosecutor's office and police; both were killed by the GIGN on January 9, 2015
Years active
January 7, 2015 (Paris); both died January 9, 2015
Location
Paris; Gennevilliers; Reims; Dammartin-en-Goële (France)
Method
Twelve deaths attributed to them by the Paris prosecutor's office and police (never tried); Chérif's 2008 offense: criminal association with a terrorist enterprise
Status
Chérif, 2008: three years, eighteen months suspended, already covered by pretrial custody. Both brothers killed by the gendarmerie at Dammartin-en-Goële on January 9, 2015

On January 7, 2015, twelve people were killed in Paris at Charlie Hebdo, the satirical weekly whose cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad had drawn threats against it for years. Within hours the Paris prosecutor's anti-terrorism section had opened an investigation, and before the day was out the police had named the two men they were looking for: Saïd Kouachi, 34, and his brother Chérif, 32, both born in Paris. Warrants were issued for each of them that day. They were never arrested. Two days later, on January 9, the gendarmerie's intervention group, the GIGN, killed both brothers at Dammartin-en-Goële, a town northeast of the capital, and with their deaths the case against them ended before it could be brought.

No court has ever tried the Kouachi brothers for the twelve deaths. In law the killings remain attributed to them by the prosecutor's office and the police rather than proven against them in a courtroom. What the courts did establish concerns an earlier chapter, and it belongs to Chérif alone. Saïd Kouachi was never convicted of anything.

Saïd was born in Paris on September 7, 1980. Chérif followed on November 29, 1982, born in the city's 10th arrondissement. They spent part of their boyhood in the 19th arrondissement, in the northeast of the city, and several years in the Corrèze department of central France. By about 2000 both were back in the 19th arrondissement, living on small and irregular incomes. Chérif delivered pizzas and later worked at a fish counter; Saïd took occasional jobs as a waiter and kitchen hand.

In January 2005 Chérif was arrested in an investigation into a group in the 19th arrondissement that sent volunteers to fight in Iraq, and on May 14, 2008, a Paris court convicted him of criminal association with a terrorist enterprise, association de malfaiteurs en relation avec une entreprise terroriste, sentencing him to three years with eighteen months suspended; the twenty months he had already spent in custody covered the rest. Saïd was questioned in the same investigation and released without charge. After his release Chérif moved to Gennevilliers, a suburb on the northwest edge of Paris.

In 2010 Chérif was placed under formal investigation, mis en examen, as a suspected participant in a plan to free Smaïn Aït Ali Belkacem, a man serving a life sentence for his part in the Paris bombings of 1995. The case against him did not hold. The investigating magistrates closed it with a non-lieu, finding insufficient evidence to send him to trial. Saïd was questioned and again released without charge.

From 2011 the intelligence directorate of the Paris police prefecture, the DRPP, kept Saïd under surveillance. That year one of the brothers traveled to the Sultanate of Oman, a journey the National Assembly's commission of inquiry later concluded had almost certainly allowed him to cross into neighboring Yemen, and came back to France a few weeks later. Interceptions resumed after his return and were dropped because they produced nothing conclusive. The DRPP tapped Saïd's telephone again in 2014, then abandoned the watch in June, when he moved to Reims, in the Marne department, outside its jurisdiction. In July it handed the file to the national domestic intelligence service, the DGSI, and the surveillance of the brothers was ended for good, because nothing gathered had established any terrorist activity on the part of either of them. When the twelve deaths came six months later, neither brother was under active watch.

Twelve people died at Charlie Hebdo that Wednesday: Frédéric Boisseau, Franck Brinsolaro, Jean Cabut, Elsa Cayat, Stéphane Charbonnier, Philippe Honoré, Bernard Maris, Ahmed Merabet, Mustapha Ourrad, Michel Renaud, Bernard Verlhac and Georges Wolinski. Eight of them belonged to the paper's editorial staff, and three of those were known by their pen names: Cabu, Charb and Tignous. Eleven more people were wounded, several of them gravely.

By the afternoon of January 7 the police had identified Saïd Kouachi, and warrants went out against him and then against Chérif. On January 8 the police released photographs of both brothers and warned the public that the men were dangerous. On January 9 the GIGN located them at Dammartin-en-Goële, in the Seine-et-Marne department, and killed them both late that afternoon.

Because Chérif and Saïd Kouachi died on January 9, 2015, neither was ever charged, placed under formal investigation or tried for the deaths of January 7, and no French court has delivered a verdict on their guilt. The attribution rests on the findings of the police investigation and the prosecutor's office, and on the official chronology later set out by the National Assembly's commission. The nearest any court came to the brothers was in judging the people accused of helping them. Fourteen defendants went on trial in Paris on September 2, 2020, before the special assize court; three of them were tried in absentia. On December 16, 2020, the court convicted all fourteen. It found the principal defendant guilty of complicity in the terrorist crimes committed by Saïd and Chérif Kouachi and their associate, and sentenced him to thirty years. For six of the defendants it set the terrorist charge aside, finding no sufficient proof that they had known of the attackers' plans, and convicted them of ordinary criminal association instead. Only two defendants appealed. On October 20, 2022, the appeal court raised the principal defendant's sentence to life imprisonment, with twenty years before any release could be considered, and cut the second defendant's term from twenty years to thirteen.

None of that changed the brothers' own legal position. The verdict described the crimes as theirs, but they were not before the court, and it was given against others. When the Senate's commission of inquiry into jihadist networks reported in April 2015, it recorded that one of the two brothers had never come before the courts and that the other's first conviction had been for terrorism. The only judgment ever entered against either of them remains Chérif's conviction of May 14, 2008. Saïd Kouachi died without a criminal record.

The deaths of January 7, 2015, were never tested in a court with the brothers as defendants, and their guilt rests on the investigation, not on a verdict against them. The 2020 judgment that names them as the authors of the crimes was given in a trial of other people, held after their deaths.

Which of the two brothers made the 2011 journey to Oman and Yemen was never settled. The National Assembly's commission recorded only that one of the brothers made the trip; American officials named Saïd, and at one point news reports suggested both brothers had gone. What the traveler did in Yemen, and what contact, if any, the brothers kept afterward with Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula, remain unproven.

Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula later claimed to have directed the killings. No court ever examined that claim in a case against the brothers, and American intelligence officials said they had found no sign of contact between the brothers and the group after September 2011.

Chérif Kouachi was placed under formal investigation in the 2010 escape plan but was cleared by a non-lieu, and no court found that he took part in it.

Timeline

September 7, 1980: Saïd Kouachi born in Paris.

November 29, 1982: Chérif Kouachi born in Paris.

About 2000: both brothers are back in the 19th arrondissement of Paris after years in Corrèze.

January 2005: Chérif Kouachi arrested in the Iraq network investigation; Saïd questioned and released.

May 14, 2008: a Paris court convicts Chérif of criminal association with a terrorist enterprise; three years, eighteen months suspended.

2010: Chérif placed under formal investigation over a plan to free Smaïn Aït Ali Belkacem; the case against him ends in a non-lieu.

2011: the DRPP places Saïd under surveillance; one brother travels to Oman, and probably Yemen, and returns weeks later.

2014: Saïd's telephone tapped again; surveillance dropped when he moves to Reims in June; file passed to the DGSI in July, and surveillance ends.

January 7, 2015: twelve people killed at Charlie Hebdo in Paris; warrants issued for Saïd and Chérif.

January 8, 2015: police release the brothers' photographs.

January 9, 2015: both brothers killed by the GIGN at Dammartin-en-Goële.

April 2015: the Senate's commission of inquiry into jihadist networks reports.

September 2, 2020: fourteen people go on trial in Paris before the special assize court, accused of helping the brothers and their associate.

December 16, 2020: the court convicts all fourteen; the principal defendant is found guilty of complicity in the crimes committed by the brothers and their associate.

October 20, 2022: on appeal, the principal defendant's sentence is raised to life imprisonment and a second defendant's cut to thirteen years.