Sandeela Kanwal died in Jonesboro, Georgia, on July 6, 2008. She had gone to a lawyer that summer to end a marriage her father, Chaudhry Rashid, had arranged for her, and she had refused to reconsider. Clayton County police arrested Rashid the same morning and charged him with her murder.
The case turned less on what happened that night than on what Rashid said afterward. His formal police interview was ruled inadmissible under Miranda, and none of it reached the jury. What reached the jury instead was a conversation he had asked to have with his family, recorded in the same interview room. A Clayton County jury convicted him in May 2011 of malice murder, felony murder and aggravated assault, and he was sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole. On January 22, 2013, the Supreme Court of Georgia unanimously affirmed the conviction.
When the police questioning ended, Rashid asked to see his relatives. The meeting took place in the interview room where he had been questioned, while he was in handcuffs, and the recording equipment kept running. Police did nothing to suggest the room was private, and no officer questioned him about the death during the meeting. In that conversation, the Supreme Court of Georgia found, he admitted killing his daughter and gave her defiance in seeking a divorce as his reason.
Before trial, the court drew a line between the two recordings. The interrogation by detectives fell under Miranda and was suppressed. The family conversation, which Rashid himself had requested, did not, and the State was allowed to use it. The recording, a translated transcript offered as an aid to the jury, and the testimony of a linguist who had translated it formed the center of the trial in May 2011. His sons testified after the court granted them immunity following opening statements.
Rashid challenged the verdict on five grounds: the sufficiency of the evidence, the mid-trial immunity grants, the admission of the family recording, the use of the transcript, and the refusal of two jury instructions he had requested. The Supreme Court of Georgia rejected each of them.
The evidence, the court held, allowed a rational jury to find him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. On the immunity grants, it found that he had shown no prejudice, since he had known before trial that immunity was likely and the defense already had the earlier statements of the witnesses.
The recording was the heart of the appeal. A defendant who claims an illegal search must show that he expected privacy and that the expectation was reasonable. Rashid was in a police interview room, in handcuffs, facing prosecution, and he was the one who had asked for the meeting. He had no reasonable expectation of privacy there. Nor was the conversation the product of the suppressed interrogation: his own request to see his family broke any link to the earlier questioning, and Miranda governs questioning by the police, not a prisoner's conversation with his relatives. There was no coercion.
The court found no error in the use of the transcript, which the jury had been told was only an aid and in which no substantive inaccuracy had been shown. The defense had asked for an instruction on assisted suicide; the court did not decide whether Georgia recognizes such a defense, holding that the record contained no evidence that she had taken her own life and that the evidence instead suggested she had feared for it. The refusal of an instruction on corroborating confessions was harmless, because his statements were amply corroborated by his conduct when police arrived, by witness testimony and by the physical evidence. The judgment was affirmed.
Rashid did not contest at trial that he caused his daughter's death; what was contested was his state of mind, with the defense arguing that the killing was unplanned. The jury convicted him of malice murder. The assisted-suicide theory the defense raised was never a finding of fact, and the Supreme Court of Georgia held that no evidence supported it.
2008: Rashid's daughter seeks a divorce from the marriage her father arranged.
July 6, 2008: Clayton County police arrest Rashid in Jonesboro and charge him with murder.
Before trial: The trial court suppresses Rashid's formal police interview under Miranda and admits the recording of his conversation with his family.
May 2011: A Clayton County jury convicts Rashid of malice murder, felony murder and aggravated assault; he is sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole.
January 22, 2013: The Supreme Court of Georgia unanimously affirms the conviction in Rashid v. State.