Charles Taylor was President of Liberia from August 1997 until August 2003. On April 26, 2012 Trial Chamber II of the Special Court for Sierra Leone, sitting in The Hague, found him guilty on all 11 counts of the indictment against him. The court found that he aided and abetted war crimes and crimes against humanity committed by the Revolutionary United Front and the Armed Forces Revolutionary Council in Sierra Leone, and that he planned some of them. On May 30, 2012 he was sentenced to a single term of 50 years. The Appeals Chamber affirmed both the conviction and the sentence on September 26, 2013, and he is serving the sentence in the United Kingdom.
He was the first former head of state convicted by an international tribunal since the Nuremberg trials after the Second World War. The case was built on a point of principle as much as on the facts: Taylor was never in Sierra Leone while the crimes were committed, and the prosecution did not allege that he carried them out himself. The question for the judges was whether a president in a neighbouring country could be held criminally responsible for what armed groups did across the border because of the support he gave them. The Trial Chamber and the Appeals Chamber both answered yes.
Charles Ghankay Taylor was born in 1948 in Liberia. He studied economics at Bentley College in Waltham, Massachusetts, and graduated in 1977. After Samuel Doe took power in a coup in 1980, Taylor returned to Liberia and became head of the government's General Services Administration. In 1983 Doe accused him of embezzlement. He left for the United States the following year, was held there pending extradition, and escaped. He then went to Libya, where he formed the National Patriotic Front of Liberia.
In December 1989 the National Patriotic Front of Liberia invaded the country from Côte d'Ivoire. The fighting reached the capital in 1990 and became a civil war that lasted about seven years and drew in other armed groups. A peace agreement in 1996 led to elections in July 1997. Taylor won with about 75 percent of the vote and was sworn in on August 2, 1997 for a six-year term.
Sierra Leone's conflict ran for eleven years and was formally declared over on January 18, 2002. Two armed groups figure in the Taylor judgment: the Revolutionary United Front, led in the field by a commander named Sam Bockarie, and the Armed Forces Revolutionary Council. The Special Court's jurisdiction began on November 30, 1996, and the crimes for which Taylor was convicted fall between that date and January 18, 2002.
Taylor's government was accused of supporting the Revolutionary United Front in exchange for diamonds, an accusation he denied. In 2000 he helped secure the release of United Nations peacekeepers held by the group and later acknowledged ties with it. In 2001 the United Nations Security Council demanded that Liberia end its support for the group.
On March 7, 2003 a judge of the Special Court confirmed a sealed indictment against Taylor containing 17 counts. It was unsealed on June 4, 2003, while he was still in office. Taylor stepped down under international pressure after peace talks in Accra and went into asylum in Nigeria, resigning on August 11, 2003 and handing power to his vice president. In December 2003 Interpol issued a notice for him, and in 2004 the United Nations froze his assets. On May 31, 2004 the Appeals Chamber dismissed his motion to quash the indictment.
On March 16, 2006 an amended indictment reduced the charges from 17 counts to 11. Later that month Liberia's government asked Nigeria to surrender him. On March 29, 2006 Nigerian authorities apprehended him near the Cameroon border. He was flown to Monrovia, taken into custody there by the United Nations mission, and transferred to the Special Court in Freetown. He made his first appearance on April 3, 2006 and pleaded not guilty.
The Special Court sat in Freetown. On June 16, 2006 the United Nations Security Council, in Resolution 1688, allowed the trial to be held in The Hague. Taylor was transferred on June 30, 2006. The trial was held first in a courtroom of the International Criminal Court and later in a courtroom at the Special Tribunal for Lebanon, before Trial Chamber II.
The trial opened on June 4, 2007 with the prosecution's opening statement. Taylor did not attend that day and boycotted the start of the proceedings. The prosecution case ran from January 7, 2008 to February 27, 2009. The defense case opened on July 13, 2009, and Taylor gave evidence in his own defense from July 14 to November 10, 2009. The defense closed its case on November 12, 2010. Closing arguments were heard on 9 and March 10, 2011, and the trial phase ended on March 11, 2011.
The prosecution relied on two provisions of the Special Court's Statute: Article 6(1), which covers individual responsibility for planning, instigating, ordering, committing or otherwise aiding and abetting a crime, and Article 6(3), which covers the responsibility of a superior. The central difficulty for the prosecution was the link between Taylor in Liberia and the crimes committed in Sierra Leone by other men. The Chamber took more than a year after the close of the trial to deliver its judgment.
The Trial Chamber found Taylor guilty on all 11 counts. The counts, as the court framed them, were these. As war crimes: acts of terrorism (count 1); murder (count 3); outrages upon personal dignity (count 6); violence to life, health and physical or mental well-being of persons, in particular cruel treatment (count 7); and pillage (count 11). As crimes against humanity: murder (count 2); rape (count 4); sexual slavery (count 5); other inhumane acts (count 8); and enslavement (count 10). Count 9, conscripting or enlisting children under the age of 15 years, was charged as an other serious violation of international humanitarian law.
The Chamber found that Taylor aided and abetted the crimes charged in all 11 counts. It found that he provided the rebel forces with material, military personnel, and operational and moral support, and that he received diamonds in exchange. It also found that he planned two sets of operations: the attacks on Kono and Makeni in December 1998, and the invasion of and retreat from Freetown between December 1998 and February 1999. The planning finding was made together with Sam Bockarie.
The judges did not find everything the prosecution had alleged. They did not find that Taylor ordered or instigated the crimes. They did not find that he took part in a joint criminal enterprise, and they did not find that he had effective command and control over the rebel forces. The presiding judge described the guidance he gave the Revolutionary United Front as "generally of an advisory nature." Taylor, then 64, had pleaded not guilty to every count and denied the charges. The written judgment was issued on May 18, 2012.
Sentencing submissions were heard on May 16, 2012. On May 30, 2012 the Trial Chamber imposed one global sentence of 50 years' imprisonment covering all 11 counts. Only a term of years was available to the court, since neither life imprisonment nor the death penalty was open to it.
The judges treated his position as the central aggravating factor. They found that he had abused his office as President of Liberia and his membership of the Economic Community of West African States Committee of Five, later Six, a body the international community relied upon to bring peace to Sierra Leone. They called that abuse "an aggravating factor of great weight." The presiding judge said his leadership role "puts him in a class of his own" and that "this betrayal outweighs the distinctions that might otherwise pertain to the modes of liability." Other aggravating factors were the extraterritorial nature of his acts and his exploitation of the conflict for financial gain. The Chamber credited his good conduct in detention but rejected most of the other mitigating factors the defense proposed. It also stated that aiding and abetting generally warrants a lesser sentence than more direct forms of participation, a statement that was later corrected on appeal.
Notices of appeal were filed on July 19, 2012, and both sides filed their briefs on October 1, 2012. The prosecution put forward four grounds. It asked for findings that Taylor ordered and instigated the crimes, for liability for crimes in further locations, and for a heavier sentence than the single term of 50 years; it had argued for 80 years at the sentencing stage. The defense put forward 42 grounds. They included challenges to the planning findings on Kono, Makeni and Freetown, to the findings that medical help and accommodation in Liberia counted as assistance to the rebels, to the length of the sentence, and to the participation of one judge after her election to the International Court of Justice. The defense also argued that aiding and abetting requires proof that the assistance was "specifically directed" at the crimes, following a ruling of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia.
The Appeals Chamber gave judgment on September 26, 2013 in Leidschendam, near The Hague. It was unanimous. It affirmed the conviction on all 11 counts and the sentence of 50 years. It rejected the specific-direction requirement and held that the test for aiding and abetting is whether the assistance had a substantial effect on the crimes. It held that "aiding and abetting fully captures Taylor's interventions over a period of five years." It deleted Kono District from the planning finding, leaving the planning liability to rest on Makeni and Freetown. It also held that the Trial Chamber had been wrong to state that aiding and abetting generally warrants a lesser sentence than other forms of liability, but it left the 50-year term unchanged. The presiding judge of the Appeals Chamber ordered that Taylor remain in the custody of the Special Court pending final arrangements for his transfer.
The prosecutor welcomed the decision as a final affirmation of Taylor's criminal responsibility for grave crimes and said that no person, however powerful, is above the law.
Convicted persons of the Special Court serve their sentences outside Sierra Leone. Taylor had asked to serve his term in Rwanda, where other men convicted by the Special Court were held. The United Kingdom had offered in 2007 to take him and bear the cost if he were convicted. On October 4, 2013 the President of the Special Court signed an order designating the United Kingdom as the state of enforcement. The order was unsealed on October 10, 2013, when a British justice minister told Parliament that Taylor would be transferred to the United Kingdom to serve the sentence. He was transferred on October 15, 2013.
The Special Court closed in December 2013 and the Residual Special Court for Sierra Leone took over its remaining functions, including supervision of the sentences. In a statement of November 12, 2020 the Residual Special Court said that Taylor and four others had not yet served two thirds of their sentences and were therefore not yet eligible to apply for conditional early release, which becomes possible after two thirds of a term. It added that release or transfer is a judicial decision for its President, that neither the United Nations nor the Government of Sierra Leone has a role in it, and that conditions of detention are monitored by international bodies including the International Committee of the Red Cross.
The Special Court was created by an agreement signed on January 16, 2002 between the United Nations and the Government of Sierra Leone, two days before the war was formally declared over. It was described as the first hybrid tribunal, with international and Sierra Leonean judges and a mandate to try those bearing the greatest responsibility for serious violations of international humanitarian law and Sierra Leonean law committed after November 30, 1996. Each trial chamber had a majority of international judges.
The tribunal completed its mandate and closed in December 2013, the first international or hybrid tribunal to finish its trials and wind down. The Residual Special Court continues to handle matters that outlast the Special Court, including the enforcement of sentences, the protection of witnesses and requests for early release.
The appeal judgment also marked a difference between two tribunals. The International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia had held in a 2013 appeal ruling that aid must be specifically directed at the crimes before a person can be liable for aiding and abetting. The Special Court's Appeals Chamber declined to follow that approach and applied a test of substantial effect instead.
Taylor pleaded not guilty and denied the charges throughout. He denied the accusation that his government supported the Revolutionary United Front in exchange for diamonds, although he later acknowledged ties with the group. The Trial Chamber did not accept the prosecution's case that he commanded the rebel forces, that he ordered or instigated the crimes, or that he took part in a joint criminal enterprise, and the Appeals Chamber did not disturb those findings. The prosecution's appeal for a sentence above 50 years did not succeed. The defense's challenges to the factual findings, to the standard for aiding and abetting and to the length of the sentence were rejected, apart from the correction on the principle that aiding and abetting warrants a lesser sentence, and the removal of Kono District from the planning finding. The convictions are final.
1948: Charles Ghankay Taylor is born in Liberia.
December 1989: The National Patriotic Front of Liberia begins its invasion of Liberia.
November 30, 1996: Start of the Special Court's jurisdiction.
August 2, 1997: Taylor is sworn in as President of Liberia.
January 16, 2002: The United Nations and Sierra Leone sign the agreement creating the Special Court.
January 18, 2002: The war in Sierra Leone is formally declared over.
March 7, 2003: A 17-count indictment is confirmed under seal; it is unsealed on June 4, 2003.
August 11, 2003: Taylor resigns the presidency and goes to Nigeria.
March 16, 2006: The indictment is amended to 11 counts.
March 29, 2006: Taylor is apprehended in Nigeria and transferred to the Special Court.
April 3, 2006: He pleads not guilty at his first appearance.
June 30, 2006: He is transferred to The Hague.
June 4, 2007: The trial opens.
9 to March 11, 2011: Closing arguments are heard and the trial phase ends.
April 26, 2012: Trial Chamber II finds him guilty on all 11 counts.
May 30, 2012: He is sentenced to 50 years.
July 19, 2012: Notices of appeal are filed.
September 26, 2013: The Appeals Chamber affirms the conviction and the sentence.
October 15, 2013: He is transferred to the United Kingdom to serve the sentence.
December 2013: The Special Court closes; the Residual Special Court takes over.
November 12, 2020: The Residual Special Court states that he is not yet eligible for conditional early release.