On the night of October 23, 1989, Carol DiMaiti Stuart, of the Boston suburb of Reading, died in the Mission Hill district of the city. Her husband, Charles Stuart, was badly hurt, and he told police that a Black stranger was to blame. Their son was delivered that night and died seventeen days later. For ten weeks the city believed the husband's account, and the police search that followed fell on the young Black men of Mission Hill.
The Boston police and the Suffolk County District Attorney later concluded that the account was false. In early January 1990 Stuart's younger brother went to the authorities, admitted his own part in the events of that night and named Charles as the man responsible. On January 4, 1990, as police sought to arrest him, Charles Stuart died by suicide. He was never arrested, never charged and never tried. The deaths of his wife and son were attributed to him by the police and the prosecutor's office, and no court ever tested that attribution. Two Black men who had been drawn into the case during those ten weeks were cleared.
Stuart grew up in Revere, a working-class city just north of Boston. He went to a parochial school and then to Northeastern Metropolitan Regional Vocational School in Wakefield, where he played basketball and baseball and joined the gourmet club. He graduated in 1977.
His first jobs were in restaurant kitchens. He worked as a cook at Reardon's and then at the Driftwood restaurant, and it was at the Driftwood that he met the woman he would marry.
He did not stay in kitchens. When he applied for work at Kakas, a Boston furrier, he claimed an athletic scholarship to Brown University, a university that awards none. The claim was false, and the company hired him anyway. He rose to general manager, earning about $100,000 a year, and he came to manage a fashionable fur store in the city.
The couple married on October 13, 1985, at a church in Medford. They settled in Reading, a prosperous suburb north of Boston, and to their neighbors they seemed devoted to each other. He tended the rhododendrons, the two of them went jogging together, and in winter he shoveled the snow for an elderly neighbor. About ten days before the night of October 23, 1989, they marked their fourth wedding anniversary at an inn in Connecticut.
Behind that picture, Stuart wanted a different life. He wanted to run a business of his own rather than work for other people, and he pictured himself as a fashionable restaurateur and chef. He had also taken out large life insurance policies on his wife.
The couple were in Mission Hill that night. That night Stuart was on the telephone to a police dispatcher, saying that both of them had been hurt, and he told the officers who reached him that the man responsible was Black. Recordings of the call were broadcast, and they gave his account a force that few people thought to question.
His wife did not survive the night. Their son, delivered two months early, died seventeen days later. Stuart, then 30, was seriously hurt and spent six weeks in a Boston hospital. Investigators later concluded that he had inflicted his own injury. The story of the suburban couple drew sympathy across Massachusetts and far beyond it.
The mayor ordered every available detective onto the case. The police concentrated on the Mission Hill housing development and the surrounding blocks, with stops, arrests and summonses for minor offenses, and hundreds of young Black men in the neighborhood were stopped and frisked. Black residents later said that the police had harassed Black men during those weeks and had pressed witnesses into implicating a Black man with a criminal record.
The scale of that search held the police in the wrong neighborhood for weeks. The insurance policies on his wife's life drew little attention while it went on.
During those weeks two Black men from the neighborhood came under suspicion. Once Stuart was well enough to leave the hospital, one of them was placed in a lineup, and Stuart picked him out as resembling the man he had described. That choice closed off, for the time being, any serious look at the gaps in the husband's own story. Neither man was ever convicted of the killing, and both were cleared after the brother came forward.
Days after Stuart left the hospital, he collected an insurance check for $82,000. He bought a pair of diamond earrings. He went on living the life of a widower who had lost his wife and son to a stranger, and the city went on treating him as one.
In early January 1990, ten weeks after the night in Mission Hill, his younger brother went to the authorities. The brother admitted his own part in the events of October 23 and named Charles as the man responsible. He told the police that he had believed he was helping with a scheme to defraud insurers and that he understood what his brother had done only afterward.
The Suffolk County District Attorney announced that the inquiry had turned to the husband, and police prepared to arrest him. On January 4, 1990, Charles Stuart died by suicide.
In Mission Hill, Black residents who had believed the husband's story as readily as anyone else in the city protested the way the police had handled the case, and they were angered by news coverage that had seemed to cast suspicion on the whole Black community. In 1992, according to the Associated Press, the brother pleaded guilty to conspiracy, possession of a firearm and three other charges.
Charles Stuart was never charged with any crime, and no jury ever heard evidence against him. The attribution of his wife's death and his son's death to him rests on his brother's account, on what investigators found after the brother came forward, and on the conclusions the police and the Suffolk County District Attorney drew from both. Those conclusions were never tested by cross-examination.
The motive was never established in court. Investigators and the press of the time pointed to the insurance policies on his wife's life and to his wish to open a restaurant. He was said to have told his lawyer, before his death, that he had acted to collect the insurance, but that statement is known only secondhand.
Parts of the brother's own account were questioned at the time, including how a seriously hurt man could have done what the brother described in the minutes after the event. The full nature of the arrangement between the two brothers was not understood in January 1990, and with Charles dead it was never set out in a trial.
October 13, 1985: Charles Stuart marries in Medford, Massachusetts; the couple later settle in Reading.
October 23, 1989: his wife dies in the Mission Hill district of Boston; he tells police a Black stranger was to blame.
Seventeen days later: the couple's infant son dies.
Late 1989: police search Mission Hill; two Black men from the neighborhood come under suspicion.
Late 1989: after six weeks in the hospital, Stuart picks one of them from a lineup as resembling the man he described.
Early January 1990: his younger brother goes to the authorities and names him as responsible.
January 4, 1990: police prepare to arrest him; Charles Stuart dies by suicide.
1992: his brother pleads guilty to conspiracy, possession of a firearm and three other charges.