Charles Carl Roberts IV

Victims
5 Amish girls killed in Nickel Mines, 2006; never tried. State police named him as the man who killed five Amish girls and wounded five more on October 2, 2006; he died by suicide.
Years active
October 2, 2006
Location
Nickel Mines and Georgetown, Bart Township, Lancaster County, Pennsylvania
Method
Deaths attributed by the state police to one man in a single morning; no court finding, since he died the same day.
Status
Died by suicide, October 2, 2006. The deaths were investigated by the Pennsylvania State Police; no court ever heard the case.

On Monday, October 2, 2006, five Amish girls from the farms around Nickel Mines, a small village in the southeast corner of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, were killed and five more were wounded. The Pennsylvania State Police named the man responsible as Charles Carl Roberts IV, a 32-year-old milk truck driver who lived a mile or two away in Bart Township. He was not Amish. His pickup route took him to many of the Amish dairy farms in the country around the village, and he was well known there because of it. He died by suicide that morning as state troopers closed in, and because he died the same day, he was never arrested, charged or tried.

The girls belonged to Old Order Amish families, part of a community of about 20,000 Old Order Amish in Lancaster County. Word reached the county's emergency dispatchers in the middle of the morning, and state troopers were sent to the village. The end came soon after they arrived. Three of the girls were dead, and seven more were critically hurt. Two of the seven died before dawn the next day, and by Wednesday, October 4, the count was settled at five girls dead and five wounded.

The Pennsylvania State Police took charge of the inquiry from the first day. Investigators found letters he had left, written, they said, in the manner of suicide notes, in which he described an anger he had carried since the death of his infant daughter in 1997. They found nothing to suggest that he held anything against the Amish.

Because Roberts died at Nickel Mines on the morning of October 2, there was no arrest, no charge, no preliminary hearing and no trial. No court tested the evidence, heard a defense or returned a verdict. The public record holds instead the account of the Pennsylvania State Police and the Lancaster County coroner: five girls dead, five wounded, and one man named as responsible and dead by his own hand that same morning.

Within hours, Amish neighbors went to his family and offered their forgiveness.

His stated motive was never tested. The anger he described in his letters is known only from his own words as the state police relayed them.

No court ever weighed the state police account that he alone was responsible for the deaths; his full intentions died with him.

Timeline

October 2, 2006: Five Amish girls at Nickel Mines are killed or fatally hurt and five more are wounded; Roberts dies by suicide as state troopers close in.

October 3, 2006: Two more girls die overnight, bringing the number of dead to five.

October 4, 2006: The count is settled at five girls dead and five wounded.