On the morning of Monday, March 5, 2001, Charles Andrew Williams, known to everyone as Andy, killed two young people and injured 13 others in Santee, a suburb east of San Diego. He was 15. Eleven of the injured were teenagers like the two who died; the other two were adults on the school staff. He was in the custody of San Diego County sheriff's deputies within minutes, and he did not resist. By that afternoon the county's District Attorney had announced that the boy would be tried as an adult, under a ballot measure California voters had approved almost exactly a year before.
There was never a trial. In June 2002, at a hearing that had been set aside for routine scheduling, Williams pleaded guilty to two counts of first-degree murder and 13 counts of attempted murder, and that August he was sentenced to 50 years to life. The killings were over in minutes, but the legal life of the case has run for a quarter of a century. The youth offender parole system gave him a first hearing in September 2024 and turned him down. A resentencing law then led a San Diego judge, in January 2026, to recall his sentence altogether and send the case to juvenile court, where release would follow. Prosecutors appealed the same day. As of June 2026 he was still in prison while an appellate court weighed whether a sentence of 50 years to life, imposed on a 15-year-old, is in law the same as life without parole. The case remains the deadliest of its kind in San Diego County.
Williams had arrived in Santee only recently.
Bryan was the younger of the two who died. He skateboarded and played basketball, and he wanted to be a stuntman in the movies. Randy was a long-distance runner. Both died in Santee on March 5, 2001.
Thirteen people survived their injuries that morning: 11 teenagers and two members of the school staff. The San Diego County Sheriff's Department took charge of the investigation, and the District Attorney's office was involved from the first hours. At a news conference that afternoon the District Attorney said the 15-year-old would face murder and related counts in adult court, listing murder, assault and further counts under the arms law as the likely charges.
The choice of court was not left to a judge. Under Proposition 21, the prosecutors' office explained, anyone 14 or older charged with murder with special circumstances had to be tried as an adult. Two deaths supplied a special circumstance. Prosecutors also alleged that Williams had lain in wait, a second allegation that sent the case to adult court on its own.
Williams was arraigned in adult court in San Diego County on Wednesday, March 7, 2001, two days after the killings. His lawyers did not enter a plea. They were preparing their own challenge to Proposition 21, arguing that the provisions that put juveniles into adult court were unconstitutional, and if he was convicted on every count he faced more than 500 years in an adult prison.
The charging document filed in San Diego County Superior Court that day ran to 28 counts: two of murder, 13 of attempted premeditated murder and 13 of assault, one for each person hurt. It alleged two special circumstances, multiple murder and lying in wait, and a third allegation drawn from the new law: that he was 14 or older and had personally killed. That last allegation was the one that made adult court mandatory for the murder counts. The 13 attempted murder counts went to adult court under a separate, discretionary provision for offenders 14 and older, and every count carried sentence-enhancement allegations.
The defense attack came in two forms. At a hearing on Friday, April 20, 2001, his public defenders asked the judge not to try him as an adult at all, arguing that adult punishment for a 15-year-old under the new law would be cruel and unusual. They also filed a demurrer to the Proposition 21 allegation, contending that the measure broke the state constitution's rule that an initiative may embrace only one subject, violated the separation of powers, and imposed cruel and unusual punishment.
The challenge failed. In ruling that Williams would be tried as an adult, the court rejected the defense attack on the law that requires prosecutors to charge certain juveniles as adults for serious crimes. The trial court overruled the demurrer in an order filed on April 27, 2001. The defense took the question to the state Court of Appeal on a petition for a writ of prohibition, and on November 28, 2001, a panel of that court denied the petition, with one justice dissenting. The ruling did not become final until the California Supreme Court had decided a separate case, Manduley v. Superior Court, on February 28, 2002, and upheld Proposition 21. The appellate court's remittitur in Williams's case issued on May 23, 2002. The case went forward in the adult system.
The case was set for a readiness hearing on Thursday, June 20, 2002. Instead of moving toward trial, Williams, by then 16, pleaded guilty to every count against him: two counts of first-degree murder and 13 counts of attempted murder. Prosecutors dropped the assault counts.
There was no plea agreement. At the readiness hearing the parties told the court that the charging document would be amended and that Williams meant to plead guilty to the first 15 counts, on the understanding that the 13 assault counts would fall away as lesser included offenses of the attempted murders. The amendment added allegations that the murders were willful, deliberate and premeditated and struck the lying-in-wait special circumstance. The judge told him that the maximum he faced was 425 years to life and the minimum 50 years to life, and that after the Manduley decision a commitment to the California Youth Authority was not an option, although he would not be housed with adults before his 18th birthday. Williams was placed under oath, advised of his rights and waived them, and signed and initialed a change-of-plea form. He entered an unconditional plea to the 15 counts, admitted the special-circumstance and enhancement allegations attached to them, and agreed that the police reports would supply the factual basis for the plea.
The plea left the sentence to the judge. Under the counts he had admitted, Williams faced at least 50 years before he could be considered for release. Sentencing was set for August 15.
On August 9, 2002, the defense filed a sentencing memorandum. It asked the court to strike the Proposition 21 allegation so that Williams could be sent back to juvenile court for sentencing, or, failing that, to impose 35 years to life. It also asked the judge to rule that 50 years to life would be cruel and unusual, because it put parole out of reach until he was 66 and so amounted in effect to life without parole. The memorandum attached the report of a psychiatrist retained by the defense, who had examined Williams in four meetings in March and August 2001.
On Thursday, August 15, 2002, after a lengthy hearing, Williams was sentenced to 50 years to life in state prison. The judge declined to strike the Proposition 21 allegation, finding that a return to juvenile court, which would have meant his release from custody by the age of 25, was too short a term for the crimes. On the murder counts he imposed two concurrent terms of 25 years to life, consecutive to a further 25 years to life on the sentence enhancements, for a total of 50 years to life. The attempted murder counts drew 13 concurrent life terms with concurrent enhancement terms, and an additional 39-year term on the remaining enhancements was stayed. Prosecutors had asked for the maximum, 425 years. The judge imposed the shorter term, the lowest sentence the law allowed on the counts he had admitted.
Because he was a minor, Williams was not placed among adult inmates at once. He was held in a youth offender program until he turned 18 and was then moved into the adult prison system, where he spent the next two decades.
Williams appealed. His lawyer argued that the judge had broken state law by refusing to return the case to juvenile court without first ordering a fitness study, that the Proposition 21 allegation had to be struck as a matter of state law, that the refusal to strike it was an abuse of discretion, and that the sentence was cruel and unusual. On January 30, 2004, the Court of Appeal affirmed on every point in an unpublished opinion. It held that the 25-years-to-life enhancement was not cruel or unusual punishment as applied to him, and noted that under the law at the time of the crimes his age barred both the death penalty and a sentence of life without parole. As long as any of the convictions or enhancement findings stood, the court explained, he could not be committed to the Youth Authority. A petition for rehearing was summarily denied, and on April 14, 2004, the California Supreme Court denied review in a one-line order.
Williams then went back to court on his own. On February 16, 2005, without a lawyer, he filed a motion in the trial court to vacate the sentence, claiming that his plea had not been knowing and intelligent because of his age and immaturity, and that but for his appointed counsel he would have pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity. The trial court denied the motion as untimely on March 14, 2005, without reaching the merits. A petition for a writ of coram vobis in the Court of Appeal, which added an argument built on Roper v. Simmons, the 2005 Supreme Court decision barring the execution of juvenile offenders, was summarily denied, and the state Supreme Court denied review on June 22, 2005.
While that last petition was pending, on April 11, 2005, Williams filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus in the United States District Court for the Southern District of California. After he retained counsel, the federal court stayed the case in May 2007 so that he could exhaust his state remedies, and the California Supreme Court denied a counseled habeas petition on March 12, 2008. His amended federal petition argued that his trial lawyers had been ineffective for letting him plead guilty before a psychiatric examination, for not moving to suppress his statement to detectives, and for not exploring defenses based on his youth and mental state; that his appellate lawyer had been ineffective; and that the sentence violated the Eighth Amendment.
On September 21, 2010, the district court denied the petition and refused an evidentiary hearing. It found that the defense had in fact had him evaluated by a psychiatrist well before the plea, that nothing in the record supported an insanity defense, and that he had been advised of his rights before his statement to detectives and had chosen to plead guilty rather than contest it. On the Eighth Amendment claim it held that no Supreme Court decision barred a 50-years-to-life term for a juvenile convicted of two murders and 13 attempted murders, and noted that he would be eligible for parole at 66. It issued a certificate of appealability on every claim. The Ninth Circuit heard argument in Pasadena on February 15, 2012, and on March 16, 2012, affirmed in an unpublished memorandum, holding that the California Supreme Court had not been objectively unreasonable in rejecting the claims of ineffective counsel or in finding that the sentence did not violate the Eighth Amendment.
In prison Williams earned two associate's degrees and trained as a journeyman mason. He became a state-licensed drug and alcohol counselor and worked as a mentor to other inmates and to staff. He completed victim impact and victim awareness programs and denial management groups, wrote a relapse prevention plan, and wrote personal letters of apology to the families of the two young people he killed and to the people he injured.
The sentence imposed in 2002 put any parole hearing decades away. The youth offender parole law brought it forward, and on Tuesday, September 10, 2024, at the age of 38, Williams came before the state Board of Parole Hearings for the first time.
Two commissioners heard the case by video in a hearing that lasted about eight hours, and 22 people gave statements as victims. At the end of the day the board found him unsuitable for parole. It found that he posed an unreasonable risk to public safety, that he had not adequately addressed his risk factors or absorbed the programming he had done on criminal thinking, and that it was unclear whether he understood why he had committed the crimes. The denial carried a three-year wait before his next hearing, unless he succeeded in petitioning for an earlier one.
His lawyer then filed a petition in San Diego Superior Court asking for the sentence to be recalled and for Williams to be resentenced, under the law that lets some juvenile offenders serving life without parole ask for a fresh sentence. Williams had not been sentenced to life without parole, and his petition depended on appellate decisions treating very long terms as the same thing.
On Tuesday, January 6, 2026, a judge of the San Diego Superior Court granted the petition. The court noted that the Courts of Appeal were divided and followed the decisions of the Fourth District, Division One, the appellate court that hears appeals from San Diego, which had held that a 50-years-to-life term imposed on a 15-year-old was equal to life without parole.
The ruling sent the case to juvenile court for a disposition hearing, and a first status conference there was set for February 9.
The District Attorney's office appealed the same day to the Fourth District Court of Appeal, Division One. In April 2026 it filed its opening brief, arguing that the trial court had erred in finding Williams eligible under the law on juvenile sentences of life without parole. The appeal froze the case. A judge put any release on hold until the appellate court had ruled, and at a short hearing on Monday, June 22, 2026, Williams remained in state prison, with a further status hearing set for mid-December and an earlier date to be found if the appellate decision came first.
As of that June hearing he was 39 and held in a California state prison. If the Court of Appeal upholds the January ruling and the case stays in juvenile court, he is expected to be released. If it reverses, the sentence of 2002 stands, and his next route out is another parole hearing.
Proposition 21, the Gang Violence and Juvenile Crime Prevention Act, passed in March 2000 with 62 percent of the vote. It moved the power to decide whether some juveniles would be tried as adults from judges to prosecutors, and made the adult filing mandatory for a case like this one. Under the law it replaced, a 15-year-old accused of special-circumstances murder would have been presumed unfit for juvenile court, and the burden would have fallen on him to persuade a juvenile judge otherwise, weighing such factors as his record, the circumstances of the crime and his prospects for rehabilitation.
The youth offender parole law, which reached Williams in 2024, requires that a person convicted as an adult of a crime committed as a juvenile, and given a life sentence, be given a parole hearing no later than 25 years into the term. It is the reason a man sentenced to 50 years to life in 2002 came before the board 23 years later.
The resentencing law dates from 2011. It allows a person who committed a crime before the age of 18, was sentenced to life without the possibility of parole and has served at least 15 years to petition for recall of the sentence. In 2022, in People v. Heard, the Court of Appeal extended that process to juvenile offenders serving the "functional equivalent" of life without parole. Because Williams was under 16 at the time of the crimes, the finding that he was eligible sent his case straight to juvenile court; under the law in force in 2026, an offender who had been 16 or 17 would first have faced a hearing on whether to transfer the case there. If a case returns to juvenile court on that footing, the adult convictions of a person who was a minor at the time are redesignated as juvenile "true findings." The juvenile court cannot order more time in custody; the person is released and may be placed on up to two years of juvenile probation; and under the law in force in January 2026 the court does not weigh aggravating or mitigating factors or decide whether release poses a risk to public safety.
His defense said that Williams had been bullied after arriving in Santee and that this explained what he did. Prosecutors found no evidence of it, and at sentencing they rejected it as a motive. No court made a finding on the point.
Whether his sentence is, in law, the functional equivalent of life without parole is the open question of the case. The Superior Court held that it is, following the Fourth District's own earlier decisions; the District Attorney's appeal asks that court to hold that it is not.
March 2000: California voters approve Proposition 21, the Gang Violence and Juvenile Crime Prevention Act.
March 5, 2001: Two young people are killed and 13 others injured in Santee; Williams is taken into custody without resistance, and the District Attorney announces an adult prosecution.
March 7, 2001: Williams is arraigned in adult court; no plea is entered.
April 20, 2001: The defense asks the judge not to try Williams as an adult.
April 27, 2001: The trial court overrules the defense demurrer to the Proposition 21 allegation.
November 28, 2001: The Court of Appeal denies a writ of prohibition, with one justice dissenting.
February 28, 2002: The California Supreme Court upholds Proposition 21 in Manduley v. Superior Court.
June 20, 2002: At a readiness hearing, Williams pleads guilty to two counts of first-degree murder and 13 counts of attempted murder; the assault counts are dismissed.
August 15, 2002: Sentenced to 50 years to life in state prison.
January 30, 2004: The Court of Appeal affirms the judgment; the California Supreme Court denies review on April 14, 2004.
2005: Motions and petitions filed without a lawyer are denied in the trial court, the Court of Appeal and the state Supreme Court.
April 11, 2005: Federal habeas petition filed in the Southern District of California.
March 12, 2008: The California Supreme Court denies a habeas petition.
September 21, 2010: The federal district court denies the petition.
March 16, 2012: The Ninth Circuit affirms.
September 10, 2024: First youth offender parole hearing; parole denied with a three-year wait.
January 6, 2026: San Diego Superior Court grants his petition for recall of sentence and sends the case to juvenile court; the District Attorney appeals to the Fourth District Court of Appeal, Division One.
April 2026: The District Attorney files its opening brief.
June 22, 2026: Status hearing; Williams remains in prison pending the appeal, with a further hearing set for mid-December.