On January 15, 1989, Betty Jeanne Solomon was killed in Greenburgh, a town in Westchester County, New York. Three years later a jury in White Plains found Carolyn Warmus guilty of her murder. Warmus was a young teacher at the elementary school where the victim's husband also taught, and the two teachers had been involved in an affair for more than a year. She was convicted of murder in the second degree, sentenced to 25 years to life, and held in a New York state prison for 27 years before the state Parole Board released her in June 2019.
The conviction did not come easily. Her first trial ended in 1991 with a jury that could not agree, eight jurors for conviction and four against. The second jury convicted her in May 1992. The case against her was built on circumstance rather than on any witness to the killing, and Warmus has never stopped saying that she did not do it. In May 2021, two years after her release, the Westchester County District Attorney agreed to new testing of three items of evidence from the trial.
Warmus came to Westchester from Michigan. By the fall of 1987 she was teaching at Greenville Elementary School, in the Edgemont section of Greenburgh, near Scarsdale. She was 23. Among her colleagues was a married teacher 17 years her senior, and that fall, the Appellate Division later recorded, she began a relationship with him. The affair lasted into 1989.
What turned suspicion toward her after the death was not a confession or an eyewitness but a chain of testimony and records assembled over the following year. A private investigator became a key prosecution witness, and the state put telephone and store records and physical evidence before the jury. It was a circumstantial case, as Warmus herself would later insist.
She was charged in Westchester County with murder in the second degree and with a further count under the state's weapons law, and tried in Westchester County Court in White Plains. The first trial, in 1991, drew wide attention, which Warmus later blamed for her conviction. The jury deadlocked, eight to four in favor of conviction, and the court declared a mistrial. The district attorney's office chose to try her again before the same court.
The retrial was held in 1992, and the prosecution presented the same core case. On May 27, 1992, the jury found Carolyn Warmus guilty of murder in the second degree. She was also convicted on the weapons-law count, and on June 26, 1992, she was sentenced to 25 years to life on the murder count.
The direct appeal did not reach decision for 14 years. On July 18, 2006, the Supreme Court of New York, Appellate Division, Second Department, affirmed the conviction. Warmus contended that the evidence was legally insufficient to prove her guilt. The panel held that she had not preserved that argument for review, but went on to say that, in any event, the evidence was legally sufficient to establish guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Exercising its own power to review the facts, the court also found that the verdict was not against the weight of the evidence. It held that the trial court had properly admitted an item of evidence over the defense objection, and that the sentence was not excessive.
Her own supplemental brief fared no better. Some of its claims the court held unpreserved and, in any event, without merit; the others it rejected as without merit, among them her challenge to the exclusion of evidence about the private investigator's bankruptcy and employment files. The rest of her arguments depended on matters outside the trial record, which the court said it could not review on a direct appeal. The judgment was affirmed.
Warmus served her sentence in a New York state prison for women and kept insisting she was innocent. In November 2016, in a television interview given from prison, she said she was serving 25 years to life because she had dated a married man. She said she had been framed, asked for the evidence to be examined again with scientific testing that had not existed at the time of her trials, and said a court had refused to order it. She had appealed to the governor for clemency.
She first became eligible for parole in 2017. At that hearing she told the board that the case against her had been "a completely circumstantial case," and that she believed she had been found guilty because of the media attention and the publicity. The board denied parole.
In May 2019 the New York State Parole Board granted her release. Warmus left prison on June 17, 2019, after 27 years. She was 55, and she said she planned to remain in New York. She still maintained her innocence.
After her release, Warmus and her lawyers pressed their request for new testing through the courts, as far as the appellate level. On May 3, 2021, the Westchester County District Attorney consented to testing of three items of physical evidence from the trial. No result of that testing has been reported. As of May 2021 the judgment of 1992, as affirmed in 2006, stood.
Warmus has denied the murder from the start. The prosecution case against her was circumstantial, as she has said: a key part of it came from a private investigator, and the trial court kept out evidence about his bankruptcy and employment files, a ruling the Appellate Division upheld. The first jury divided eight to four. The second jury convicted, and the Appellate Division upheld the verdict in 2006.
Warmus has said she was framed. No court has accepted that claim. The 2021 agreement to new testing was a step toward examining it, not a finding in her favor, and no result of that testing has been reported.
Fall 1987: Warmus, a teacher at Greenville Elementary School in Greenburgh, begins a relationship with a married colleague.
January 15, 1989: The victim dies in Greenburgh, New York.
1991: First trial in Westchester County Court, White Plains, ends in a hung jury, eight to four for conviction; mistrial declared.
May 27, 1992: At the retrial, the jury finds Warmus guilty of murder in the second degree and a weapons-law count.
June 26, 1992: Sentenced to 25 years to life.
July 18, 2006: The Appellate Division, Second Department, affirms the conviction.
November 2016: Warmus gives a television interview from prison maintaining her innocence.
2017: Parole denied at her first eligibility hearing.
May 2019: The state Parole Board grants parole.
June 17, 2019: Warmus is released after 27 years.
May 3, 2021: The Westchester County District Attorney consents to new testing of three items of trial evidence.