Carlos Castaño

Victims
Killings in Colombia, 1990-1999; convicted in absentia. Aggravated homicide in several cases: Mapiripán (40 years, 2003), El Aro, 15 dead (40 years, 2003), Jaime Garzón (38 years, 2004)
Years active
1990 to 1999 (killings in the cases that ended in conviction)
Location
Bogotá; Mapiripán (Meta); Ituango (Antioquia); San Pedro de Urabá (Antioquia)
Method
Aggravated homicide as instigator (determinador); terrorism, aggravated kidnapping and conspiracy to commit crimes (Mapiripán); conspiracy and aggravated theft (El Aro)
Status
Sentences totaling more than 100 years, none served; Mapiripán conviction upheld on appeal in 2005; died April 16, 2004; death confirmed by the authorities in 2006

Carlos Castaño Gil founded and commanded the United Self-Defense Forces of Colombia, the Autodefensas Unidas de Colombia or AUC, a paramilitary federation he formed in 1997 by bringing 18 regional blocs under a single command. Colombian courts convicted him again and again while he lived in hiding. He was never arrested. Every verdict was reached in his absence, with a court-appointed lawyer acting for him, and he never served a day of any sentence.

Colombia's highest court later set down how the federation came together. Ruling in 2015 on the convictions of commanders of the AUC's Catatumbo Bloc, the Criminal Cassation Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice described the Peasant Self-Defense Forces of Córdoba and Urabá, the ACCU, as the most solid paramilitary structure in the country, one that had spread its operations across the national territory. Castaño, "como su máximo líder," as its top leader, began unifying the country's self-defense groups, and under his command, the court found, they consolidated in 1997 as the Autodefensas Unidas de Colombia. The judges in his own cases used the same name. The Bogotá court that tried him for Mapiripán identified him as the chief of staff of the AUC and treated the federation as the organization he represented as its highest leader.

The heaviest judgment came on June 18, 2003. The Second Specialized Criminal Court of the Bogotá Circuit issued what it called a "sentencia condenatoria" against him in the case of the killings at Mapiripán, a town in the department of Meta, in July 1997. He had been charged as the instigator, the autor determinador, of aggravated homicide, aggravated kidnapping, terrorism and conspiracy to commit crimes, and the court convicted him as a coauthor of the conduct of which he stood formally accused. It recorded that an as yet undetermined number of townspeople had been killed and ordered damages to the families of seven people it named: Sinaí Blanco Santamaría, José Rolan Valencia, Antonio María Barrera, Álvaro Tovar Morales, Jaime Pinzón, Raúl Morales and a man it identified only as Agustín. The sentence was 40 years in prison, with a further 20 years' disqualification from public rights and office.

The reasoning ran on command. In the body of the judgment the court found him guilty as the autor determinador of the conduct charged, the man who set it in motion, and it rested that finding on his place at the head of the organization: as its top commander, the court held, he had "el dominio final del hecho," final control over what was done. It found that he had planned the operation from that position and relied on his own public statements as the AUC's commander, together with the group's communiqué, which it read as the organization claiming the operation as its own. The operative part, the passage that actually imposed the sentence, called him a coauthor. The judgment did not reconcile the two labels.

The conviction was appealed in July 2003. On February 15, 2005, the Criminal Chamber of the Superior Tribunal of the Judicial District of Bogotá upheld it and reiterated the warrant for Castaño's arrest. By then he was already dead, although no authority had yet confirmed it.

The case went on to an international court. On September 15, 2005, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights ruled in the case of the Mapiripán Massacre that Colombia had violated the rights to life, humane treatment and personal liberty of the victims, whom the State itself put at about 49. The court counted the in-absentia conviction of the AUC's leader among the marks of impunity in the case: he and other paramilitary commanders had been tried and convicted, it found, but the punishment had never been carried out. The State told the court that the warrant for his arrest had been suspended. Among the measures it ordered, the court required Colombia to execute the arrest warrants already issued, "including that of paramilitary leader Carlos Castaño."

El Aro came first in the calendar of his sentences. The Office of the Attorney General began a formal investigation into the killings at El Aro, a village in the municipality of Ituango, in northern Antioquia, in March 1998 and named him as a suspect from the start. In June 1999 he was declared an absent defendant, and in September 2001 the prosecutor charged him as a coauthor of conspiracy to commit crimes together with aggravated homicide and aggravated theft. On April 22, 2003, the Second Specialized Criminal Court of the Antioquia Circuit convicted him and another AUC commander, sentencing each to 40 years, for the homicide of 15 people, conspiracy to commit crimes and aggravated theft. A third defendant, the only one in custody, received 33 years. The other two had been tried and convicted in their absence, and the warrants against them were never executed. The State later told the Inter-American Court that the judgment was final and in the stage of enforcement. The Justice and Peace chamber of the Superior Tribunal of Medellín later put the dead at El Aro at 16.

The Inter-American Court took up El Aro, together with the killings at La Granja, another village of Ituango, in the case of the Ituango Massacres, and gave judgment on July 1, 2006. Colombia acknowledged its international responsibility. It told the court that its own authorities had found the incursions of the AUC at La Granja on June 11, 1996, and at El Aro between October 22 and 26, 1997, to have been planned and directed by recognized leaders of that illegal armed organization and carried out by men under their supervision, and that agents of the State had taken part in some of the criminal acts. The court accepted the acknowledgment and found the State in breach of the American Convention. Of El Aro it recorded that eight years after the events only three civilians had been convicted, Castaño among them, and only one of the three was in prison.

The earliest killings for which he was convicted came in the presidential campaign of 1990. He was convicted in the killings of two presidential candidates: Bernardo Jaramillo Ossa, killed in Bogotá on March 22, 1990, and Carlos Pizarro, killed on April 26, 1990. One of the two cases brought a 22-year sentence in 2001; accounts differ on which.

On March 10, 2004, the Seventh Specialized Criminal Court of Bogotá convicted him in absentia of aggravated homicide as the man who ordered the murder of Jaime Garzón, killed in Bogotá on August 13, 1999, and sentenced him to 38 years. In the court's words he was convicted "como coautor responsable del delito de homicidio agravado," as coauthor responsible for the crime of aggravated homicide.

By January 2003 the Office of the Attorney General had opened at least 35 criminal cases against him. By April 2005 he stood convicted in seven of them, six for homicide and one for kidnapping, with sentences that added up to 148 years.

American prosecutors charged him too. On September 24, 2002, the Justice Department unsealed an indictment returned in the federal court in Washington that charged him and two other AUC figures with cocaine trafficking. He never surrendered and was never extradited.

In July 2003 Castaño was among the nine paramilitary leaders who signed the agreement at Santa Fe de Ralito committing the AUC to demobilize. He was killed on April 16, 2004, in San Pedro de Urabá, Antioquia, by fighters of his own organization, and the authorities confirmed his death in 2006. The Office of the Attorney General established April 16, 2004, as the date of the killing, and in March 2011 a specialized criminal judge in Antioquia sentenced nine former members of the AUC to 40 years each for aggravated homicide, conspiracy to commit crimes and forced disappearance in his death.

Senator Manuel Cepeda Vargas was killed in Bogotá on August 9, 1994. Castaño was charged as the instigator of what the investigation classified as aggravated homicide with terrorist aims. On December 16, 1999, the Third Specialized Criminal Court of Santafé de Bogotá acquitted him, finding the evidence insufficient to show that he had ordered the killing. The acquittal stood and was never replaced by a conviction.

The 2004 conviction in the Bogotá murder of 1999 was a first-instance judgment, open to appeal, and his appeal had not reached the second instance when he died. The investigations still open against him in April 2005 ended with his death, without a verdict.

La Granja was one of them. After the killings in that village of Ituango on June 11, 1996, the National Human Rights Unit of the Office of the Attorney General began a formal investigation on June 17, 1999, joined Castaño to it and ordered his capture. The order was never carried out. When the Inter-American Court gave judgment in the Ituango case in July 2006, four people had been convicted for La Granja, none of them Castaño, and the investigation against him was still open. He was never tried for it.

Timeline

1990: Two presidential candidates are killed; Castaño is later convicted in both cases.

August 9, 1994: A senator is killed in Bogotá; Castaño is later acquitted in the case.

June 11, 1996: Killings at La Granja, Ituango; Castaño is investigated from 1999 but never tried.

1997: Under Castaño's command the regional self-defense groups consolidate as the AUC.

July 1997: Townspeople are killed at Mapiripán, Meta.

October 1997: Sixteen people are killed at El Aro, Ituango.

August 13, 1999: A man is killed in Bogotá; Castaño is later convicted of ordering the murder.

December 16, 1999: Acquitted in the 1994 killing of the senator.

2001: Sentenced to 22 years for one of the 1990 killings.

September 24, 2002: A U.S. federal indictment on cocaine charges is unsealed in Washington.

April 22, 2003: Sentenced in absentia to 40 years in the El Aro case.

June 18, 2003: Sentenced to 40 years in the Mapiripán case.

July 2003: Signs the Santa Fe de Ralito demobilization agreement.

March 10, 2004: Sentenced in absentia to 38 years for the 1999 killing in Bogotá.

April 16, 2004: Killed by fighters of his own organization in San Pedro de Urabá, Antioquia.

February 15, 2005: The Superior Tribunal of Bogotá upholds the Mapiripán conviction and reiterates the warrant for his arrest.

September 15, 2005: The Inter-American Court of Human Rights rules against Colombia in the Mapiripán case and orders the warrant for Castaño's arrest executed.

2006: The authorities confirm his death.

July 1, 2006: The Inter-American Court rules in the case of the Ituango Massacres, La Granja and El Aro.

March 2011: Nine former AUC members are sentenced to 40 years each for his killing.