Carlos Carrascosa spent years at the center of one of Argentina's most closely watched criminal cases, and he came out of it acquitted. His wife, María Marta García Belsunce, died on October 27, 2002, in Pilar, northwest of Buenos Aires. Her death was first certified as an accident. Weeks later a second autopsy, ordered by the prosecutor, established that she had been murdered, and the inquiry turned at once on the people closest to her.
Carrascosa was tried in 2007 and acquitted of the killing, but convicted of aggravated cover-up, a conviction later set aside. In June 2009 the Buenos Aires provincial Court of Criminal Cassation convicted him of aggravated homicide and sentenced him to life imprisonment, a conviction that was also later overturned. In 2014 the Supreme Court of Argentina ruled that a conviction imposed for the first time on appeal had to be reviewed in full, and on December 20, 2016, a review panel of the Cassation court acquitted him of both the homicide and the cover-up, finding that his authorship of the killing was not proven. The provincial Supreme Court upheld the acquittal in October 2018, and on December 10, 2020, the national Supreme Court rejected the last prosecution appeal. By then he had spent more than seven years in custody. In March 2024 a court of appeal convicted a former neighbor of the couple of the murder; that conviction was not final as of April 2026.
Carrascosa, a former stockbroker, married her in 1971, and the couple made their home in Pilar, in Buenos Aires province. When the review panel weighed the case years later, it found that the evidence described a good marriage and that no quarrel between husband and wife had been proven.
On January 16, 2003, the prosecutor charged nine people with "encubrimiento agravado," aggravated cover-up: Carrascosa, relatives of his wife, the first physician who saw her after her death, a masseuse who had been present that evening and two neighbors. Carrascosa alone was treated as the suspected killer. He was detained on April 11, 2003, and released on bail on May 23.
The pretrial years were unsettled. In April 2004, after the prosecutor had sent the case to trial, a judge of guarantees in San Isidro removed him from the investigation and annulled the committal. A new judge committed the case to an oral trial on September 6, 2005, with Carrascosa as the only person accused of the homicide. The relatives and friends were left to be tried separately for the cover-up.
The trial opened on February 20, 2007, before Criminal Oral Court No. 6 in San Isidro, on an accusation framed in the alternative: aggravated homicide or aggravated cover-up. On July 12, 2007, the court acquitted Carrascosa of the homicide, finding that his presence at the time of the killing had not been established. By majority it convicted him of aggravated cover-up and sentenced him to five years and six months, a conviction set aside in 2016. He spent only a few days in custody before he was again allowed to wait at liberty while the appeals ran.
Both sides appealed. On June 18, 2009, the First Chamber of the provincial Court of Criminal Cassation reversed the acquittal, convicted him of "homicidio agravado por el vínculo," homicide aggravated by the relationship between killer and victim, and sentenced him to life imprisonment in place of the cover-up term. It was the first court to find him guilty of homicide, and its ruling did not survive review. He was detained on June 19, 2009, in Escobar and on June 25 moved to a medium-security prison in Buenos Aires province.
In a separate trial that ended on November 4, 2011, five of the relatives and friends were convicted of cover-up and the masseuse was acquitted.
On September 10, 2012, the Supreme Court of Buenos Aires province rejected his appeal on procedural grounds and left the life sentence standing. The national Supreme Court took a different view. On November 28, 2014, it set that ruling aside, holding that the state had to guarantee a broad review of any conviction, including one handed down for the first time by an appeal court after an acquittal at trial, and it sent the case back for the conviction to be reviewed in full. On February 5, 2015, after more than five years in prison, he was moved to house arrest under electronic monitoring in Escobar.
The review fell to a transitional panel of the provincial Court of Criminal Cassation. On December 20, 2016, its three judges annulled the conviction and acquitted Carrascosa of both the homicide and the cover-up, holding that "no se encuentra acreditada la autoría del encartado en el hecho principal": the accused's authorship of the principal act was not proven.
The panel went through the prosecution's case point by point. The physicians who had carried out the autopsy, testifying at the relatives' trial, had given a time of death at which, the court found, he could not have been present; they had never been called on that point in his own case. Witness accounts of his movements that evening conflicted, and the judges applied the constitutional rule that doubt favors the accused. The physical evidence had not been linked to him. The alleged payments to the physician and the masseuse for their silence had not been proven, and neither had the alleged link to laundered money. His own early suggestion of an accident, the court found, was not enough by itself to establish a crime; the steps attributed to him after the death had not been proven, and he had given the investigators access. Carrascosa was freed after more than seven years in custody, in prison and then under house arrest.
The prosecution kept appealing. On October 3, 2018, the provincial Supreme Court rejected the appeal, confirmed the acquittal for aggravated homicide and declared the alternative cover-up charge extinguished by prescription. On December 10, 2020, the national Supreme Court dismissed the last appeal, and the acquittal became final.
On December 22, 2016, the chief prosecutor in San Isidro formed a new team to reinvestigate the killing. In September 2018 the team asked that a former neighbor of the couple be sent to trial with two former security employees. The trial opened in San Isidro on July 13, 2022, with Carrascosa taking part as a private complainant, and on December 2, 2022, the court acquitted the former neighbor of the homicide by majority. On March 27, 2024, a chamber of the provincial Court of Criminal Cassation reversed that acquittal and sentenced him to life imprisonment, and on February 19, 2025, another chamber of the same court dismissed his appeals. On April 7, 2026, the trial court denied him parole. His appeal to the provincial Supreme Court was pending, and the conviction was not final.
The prosecution case against Carrascosa rested on circumstantial indications, a disputed time of death and an alleged financial motive. The trial court in 2007 found his presence at the killing not established; the Cassation court in 2009 found it established; the review panel in 2016 found that the autopsy physicians' timing ruled it out, and the higher courts let that ruling stand. The 2016 panel also found unproven the alleged quarrel, the alleged payments and the steps attributed to him after the death, on which the 2007 cover-up conviction had rested. Both of his convictions were overturned, and his acquittal has been final since December 10, 2020.
The cover-up convictions of five relatives and friends in 2011 never became final: the brother-in-law died in 2014, and the case against three other defendants was closed by prescription in 2020. The former neighbor's 2024 conviction for the murder was not final as of April 2026.
1971: Carlos Carrascosa and his future wife marry.
October 27, 2002: His wife dies in Pilar; the death is first certified as an accident.
December 2, 2002: A new autopsy ordered by the prosecutor establishes that she was murdered.
January 16, 2003: Carrascosa and eight others are charged with aggravated cover-up.
April 11, 2003: Carrascosa is detained.
May 23, 2003: He is released on bail.
April 23, 2004: A judge removes the prosecutor from the investigation and annuls the committal to trial.
September 6, 2005: The case is committed to trial with Carrascosa as the only homicide defendant.
February 20, 2007: Trial opens before Criminal Oral Court No. 6, San Isidro.
July 12, 2007: Acquitted of homicide; convicted by majority of aggravated cover-up (set aside in 2016).
June 18, 2009: The provincial Court of Criminal Cassation convicts him of aggravated homicide and imposes life imprisonment (later overturned).
June 19, 2009: He is taken into custody in Escobar.
November 4, 2011: Five relatives and friends are convicted of cover-up in a separate trial; one defendant is acquitted.
September 10, 2012: The provincial Supreme Court leaves the life sentence standing.
November 28, 2014: The national Supreme Court orders a full review of the conviction.
February 5, 2015: He is moved to house arrest under electronic monitoring.
December 20, 2016: A review panel of the Cassation court acquits him of homicide and cover-up; he is freed.
October 3, 2018: The provincial Supreme Court confirms the acquittal.
May 26, 2020: The relatives' cover-up case is closed by prescription for three defendants.
December 10, 2020: The national Supreme Court rejects the last appeal; the acquittal is final.
December 2, 2022: The former neighbor is acquitted of the murder at trial.
March 27, 2024: The Cassation court convicts the former neighbor on appeal and imposes life imprisonment.
February 19, 2025: The Cassation court dismisses the former neighbor's appeals.
April 7, 2026: The trial court denies the former neighbor parole; his conviction is not final.