Carl Williams was a Melbourne drug trafficker who stood at the center of the city's gangland war, a cycle of reprisal killings that cost 27 lives between 1998 and 2006. In 2007, in the Supreme Court of Victoria, he pleaded guilty to three murders and to a conspiracy to commit a fourth. A year earlier a jury had convicted him of another murder. He did not carry out the killings himself. The prosecution case, accepted by the court, was that he recruited and directed the men who did. On May 7, 2007, he was sentenced to life imprisonment with a non-parole period of 35 years. He was 39 when he died in custody in April 2010.
Carl Anthony Williams was born on October 13, 1970. He went to Broadmeadows West Technical School, in Melbourne's north, in the 1980s and left in year 11. He began as a minor figure in the city's trade in illegal stimulants and grew by undercutting his rivals on price. Those rivals were a group known in Melbourne as the Carlton Crew, and the fight for the Victorian market between Williams's circle and theirs is the frame of everything that followed.
In October 1999 Williams was himself attacked in a dispute over a debt. He was later charged with the murder of Mark Moran, who died in 2000. He was never convicted of that death.
In 2003 Victoria Police set up the Purana Taskforce to investigate the gangland killings. Its case against Williams rested on four deaths across nine months.
Jason Moran was killed in Melbourne on June 21, 2003. Pasquale Barbaro died in the same incident, but Williams was not convicted over his death. The police case was that the killing had been recruited and directed by Williams, with the help of a second man who later gave evidence.
Mark Mallia died in Melbourne in August 2003. Williams later pleaded guilty to his murder.
Michael Marshall was killed in South Yarra on October 25, 2003. In that case too the prosecution case was that Williams directed the killing and that two other men carried it out.
Lewis Moran was killed in inner Melbourne on March 31, 2004. Williams had ordered the killing.
In June 2004 Williams was arrested, charged and remanded in custody over alleged offending that had nothing to do with the murders. By September 2004 he had also been charged over the killings of June 21, 2003.
The drug case came to an end first. Williams pleaded guilty in the Supreme Court to trafficking offenses committed in 2001, when he supplied illegal drugs to a co-offender who sold them on to an undercover police officer. On October 29, 2004, he was sentenced to seven years' imprisonment, with a non-parole period of five years.
The murder charges followed. A single presentment filed in the Supreme Court in 2005 charged him with murder on several counts, some of them jointly with others. The South Yarra case was decided first, and a jury found him guilty. On May 19, 2006, he was sentenced to 27 years' imprisonment for that murder, with a minimum of 21 years to serve before parole. None of it could be reported. A suppression order kept the conviction and the sentence out of the press until February 2007. His trial over the June 2003 and March 2004 killings was listed to begin in August 2006 before a judge of the Supreme Court.
On February 28, 2007, Williams pleaded guilty in the Supreme Court of Victoria to three counts of murder, for the deaths of June 2003, August 2003 and March 2004, and to one count of conspiracy to murder Mario Condello, a rival in the gangland war. The plea was negotiated with Victoria's Office of Public Prosecutions. Under the arrangement, other drug trafficking and murder charges against him were withdrawn, among them the charge over the death of 2000, which would now never come to trial.
Even then, the public heard only part of it. On the day of the pleas the name of the August 2003 victim could not be published, and the conspiracy plea could not yet be made public. What did come out that day was the South Yarra verdict: the judge lifted the suppression order on it, and the conviction and its sentence could be reported at last.
On May 7, 2007, a judge of the Supreme Court sentenced him to life imprisonment with a non-parole period of 35 years. Only then could the conspiracy plea be reported. From then on the 35-year minimum was the term he was serving for all four murders and the conspiracy.
Williams died in custody on April 19, 2010, in a prison near Geelong, killed by a fellow prisoner.
Williams was charged with the 2000 murder but never convicted of it; the charge was withdrawn when he entered his pleas in February 2007. He was not convicted over the second death of June 21, 2003. The terms of the plea agreement beyond the withdrawn charges were never published.
October 13, 1970: Carl Anthony Williams is born.
2003: Victoria Police set up the Purana Taskforce to investigate the gangland killings.
June 21, 2003: The first of the three murders to which he later pleads guilty takes place in Melbourne.
August 2003: The second of those murders takes place in Melbourne.
October 25, 2003: A murder in South Yarra for which a jury later convicts him.
March 31, 2004: The third of the murders covered by his pleas takes place in inner Melbourne.
June 2004: Williams is arrested and remanded in custody on unrelated charges.
September 2004: By now he has been charged over the killings of June 21, 2003.
October 29, 2004: He is sentenced to seven years, with a five-year minimum, for drug trafficking.
May 19, 2006: He is sentenced to 27 years, with a 21-year minimum, for the South Yarra murder; the conviction is suppressed.
February 28, 2007: He pleads guilty to three murders and one conspiracy to murder; the suppression on the South Yarra conviction is lifted.
May 7, 2007: He is sentenced to life imprisonment with a non-parole period of 35 years.
April 19, 2010: Williams dies in custody near Geelong.