Dr. Carl Weiss

Victims
1 senator's death in Baton Rouge, 1935; attribution disputed. Named as responsible for Senator Huey Long's death by the 1935 investigation and a 1992 State Police report; never tried
Years active
September 8, 1935
Location
Baton Rouge, Louisiana
Method
Attributed homicide of a sitting United States senator; never tried in any court
Status
Died September 8, 1935, before any charge. The 1992 State Police report reaffirmed the original finding; the attribution remains contested

On the night of Sunday, September 8, 1935, in Baton Rouge, Huey P. Long, the junior United States senator from Louisiana and the dominant figure in the state's politics since his election as governor in 1928, was fatally injured while in the city for a special session of the legislature. He died two days later, on September 10. The man named as responsible was Dr. Carl Austin Weiss, a 29-year-old ear, nose and throat specialist who practiced in the same city. Weiss never left the scene. Members of the senator's bodyguard killed him there within moments, and so he was never arrested, never charged and never tried.

The case against him rests on the testimony of people who were present that night, on a coroner's inquest that opened while the senator still lay dying, and on a reinvestigation by the Louisiana State Police that ended in June 1992 by reaffirming the original conclusion. No court ever weighed the evidence. Whether Weiss caused the senator's death has been argued for more than ninety years and has never been put before a jury.

Carl Austin Weiss was born in Baton Rouge in December 1905, and he moved through his schooling quickly. He finished Catholic High School in Baton Rouge at 15, took the premedical course at Louisiana State University, and went on to the medical school of Tulane University in New Orleans. He studied straight through the summers between regular sessions, earned a Bachelor of Science degree after his second year of medical school, and qualified as a Doctor of Medicine at 21.

His training then carried him a long way from Louisiana. After two years as an intern at Touro Infirmary in New Orleans, he took an appointment at the American Hospital in Paris, where he completed his internship, and he spent a year in Vienna studying under the leading specialists in his field. He came back across the Atlantic to serve two years at Bellevue Hospital in New York, and for the last six months of that appointment he was chief intern at its ear, nose and throat clinic. Along the way he became fluent in German and French. He was also an accomplished pianist.

In 1932 Weiss returned to Baton Rouge and went into private practice as an ear, nose and throat specialist. He had no history of violence and no part in public life.

The senator was born in 1893. He won election to the Louisiana Railroad Commission in 1918, was elected governor in 1928, and in January 1932 resigned that office to take his seat in the United States Senate, where he served until his death. In Washington he built a national following around his Share Our Wealth movement, which proposed to cap individual incomes at one million dollars a year, and he was expected to run strongly against President Franklin D. Roosevelt for the 1936 Democratic nomination. In September 1935 he came back to Louisiana for the special session.

Witnesses who were there that Sunday evening, many of them members of the senator's bodyguard, later testified that Weiss was the man responsible for the senator's injury. Within moments the bodyguards had killed Weiss where he stood. The senator survived for about thirty hours and died on September 10, 1935.

The coroner of East Baton Rouge Parish opened an inquest on September 9, 1935, while the senator was still alive, and resumed it on September 16, after his death. Because the senator had not yet died when the hearing began, it was framed as an inquiry into the death of Weiss. Its witnesses included bystanders, capitol staff, state legislators and members of the bodyguard. The 1935 investigation named Weiss as responsible.

The inquest could not lead to a trial. The man at its center was already dead, no charge was ever filed in his name, and no court ever ruled on what he did or did not do that night.

For half a century the state police file on the case was out of official hands. The records of the 1935 investigation disappeared from state custody in 1940 and surfaced again in private hands in 1991. Among them was a report of about 600 pages. When the Louisiana State Police learned that the file still existed, the agency said it would look at the case again.

A private forensic reexamination began in October 1991, and in February 1992 its findings, presented to a national meeting of forensic scientists, raised doubts about the traditional account without settling the question.

The State Police issued its final report on June 5, 1992. It reaffirmed the original conclusion that Weiss was responsible for the senator's death and found that the physical evidence it examined was consistent with the testimony given at the 1935 inquest. With no living person to charge, the review could not lead to an indictment, a trial or a verdict, and Weiss remains a man named by two official inquiries, fifty-seven years apart, and judged by none.

Accounts have differed since that night over whether Weiss caused the senator's death, as the 1935 investigation and the 1992 State Police report held, or whether the fatal injury came from members of the senator's own guard. The 1992 State Police report found the evidence it reviewed consistent with the inquest testimony. Against it stand the facts that the inquest drew heavily on members of the bodyguard and that the state police file was out of official hands from 1940 to 1991. What Weiss intended that night has never been established, and no court will now decide it.

Timeline

1905, December: Carl Austin Weiss is born in Baton Rouge.

1932: Weiss returns to Baton Rouge and enters private practice.

1935, September 8: The senator is fatally injured in Baton Rouge, and Weiss is killed at the scene by members of the bodyguard.

1935, September 9: The East Baton Rouge Parish coroner opens an inquest.

1935, September 10: The senator dies.

1935, September 16: The inquest resumes.

1940: The state police records of the case leave official custody.

1991: The lost file surfaces and the Louisiana State Police reopen the investigation; in October a private reexamination begins.

1992, February: The reexamination's findings are presented to a national meeting of forensic scientists.

1992, June 5: The State Police issue their final report, reaffirming the original conclusion.