On the afternoon of Tuesday, August 19, 1997, four people died in Colebrook, a town of about 2,300 people in the far north of New Hampshire. Two were New Hampshire state troopers. The third was a part-time judge who had once sat on the board of selectmen in Columbia, the town just to the south. The fourth was the editor of the town's weekly paper. State police and officials attributed all four deaths to Carl Drega, a 62-year-old man from Columbia. Before the day ended he had gone into Vermont, wounded four officers in the town of Bloomfield and been killed by police there.
Drega was never charged with any crime arising from that afternoon, and no court ever weighed the evidence against him. The account of the day that the two towns came to accept rests on what the police established and what witnesses saw, and it was never tested by a trial. What is not in doubt is how long the trouble had been building. For about twenty-five years Drega had been at war with the officials of Columbia over his land, his buildings and his taxes, and one of the four people who died had stood on the other side of that fight for years.
Drega lived alone in Columbia. His quarrel with the town began in the early 1970s, when Columbia took him to court over a zoning violation. He had put up a building and left it unfinished, its outside walls covered only in tar paper, and the town held that this broke its rules. Drega would not finish it, and he never let the matter go.
Over the years the conflict widened. His grievances moved from the walls of one building to zoning, to the way his property was assessed and to his taxes. He insisted on his right to do as he pleased on his own land, and he asserted that right in ways the town's officials took as threats. When an argument went against him he went to court himself, filing lawsuits against the officials he blamed.
In 1991 the dispute came to a head at Columbia's town hall. Drega went there to go through the town's property files and then refused to leave. Vickie Bunnell, then a member of the board of selectmen, called the state police, and he was removed. On another occasion, when she and another town official went to his property on town business, he drove them off with a threat of violence. She came to regard him as a danger and obtained a restraining order against him.
By 1997 she was no longer on the board. She kept her dog with her at the office, and she knew the high, wild country around Columbia and understood its worth.
Scott Phillips, the younger of the two troopers, stopped Drega in Colebrook that afternoon, and Drega killed him. He was a well-liked young officer, known around Colebrook by sight and by name and remembered for a cowlick he never managed to tame.
Leslie Lord, known to everyone as Les, arrived without knowing what had happened, and Drega killed him as well. In the North Country he was remembered as about the most likable man around, with a laugh people recognized from across a room.
Drega then went on into Colebrook and killed the woman who had faced him for so long across the business of the Columbia board. Dennis Joos, who had seen what was happening, tried to stop him and was killed in the attempt. As a young man Joos had trained for a time to become a Franciscan friar, and he remained a pacifist. He lived in Stewartstown and loved rural and small-town life.
Drega went back to Columbia and set fire to his own buildings, then crossed into Vermont. In Bloomfield, the small town on the Vermont side of the Connecticut River, he wounded four officers, all of whom survived, and police officers there killed him before the day was out.
Because Drega died the same day, there was no arrest and no interrogation. He was never charged and never tried, and no court made any finding about the deaths in Colebrook. The four killings are attributed to him by the New Hampshire State Police and by the officials of the state, on the strength of the evidence those agencies gathered and of what witnesses in Colebrook saw. His death in Bloomfield also ended any prospect of a prosecution over the wounding of the four officers in Vermont, and he stands in the record as a man accused by the state's agencies but never tried.
On the Vermont side of the river, the end of that afternoon became an official finding of its own. The Vermont State Police list the confrontation in Bloomfield among the cases in which their troopers used deadly force, dated August 19, 1997, with Drega as the subject, recorded as deceased, and the legal outcome entered as justified. The department states that the use of force in each such case since 1977 was found justified after outside, independent review. Its entry also sets down, in a single line, the Vermont account of the day: that Drega had killed two New Hampshire state troopers and two civilians in Colebrook before crossing into Vermont, where he died in a confrontation with several officers in Bloomfield. That finding concerns the officers who ended the afternoon, not the four deaths that began it.
Because no court heard the case, nothing about the afternoon of August 19, 1997, was tested in the way a trial would test it. The order of events rests on the work of the police and on witnesses, not on sworn testimony subjected to cross-examination. Why he acted on that day, rather than on any other in a quarter century of disputes, was never established.
Early 1970s: The Town of Columbia takes Drega to court over a zoning violation involving an unfinished building on his property.
1991: Drega refuses to leave Columbia's town hall while going through property files and is removed.
August 19, 1997: Four people are killed in Colebrook, New Hampshire.
August 19, 1997: Drega sets fire to his buildings in Columbia and crosses into Vermont.
August 19, 1997: In Bloomfield, Vermont, Drega wounds four officers and is killed by police; the Vermont State Police record the legal outcome of the confrontation as justified.