Carl Austin Hall and Bonnie Heady

Victims
1 child kidnaped for ransom and killed, Kansas City, 1953. Both pleaded guilty to federal kidnaping; a jury recommended death; sentenced November 19, 1953; executed December 18, 1953
Years active
September 28, 1953 (kidnaping); ransom paid early October 1953
Location
Kansas City, Missouri; Kansas; St. Joseph, Missouri; St. Louis, Missouri; Jefferson City, Missouri
Method
Kidnaping for ransom across a state line, the child not liberated unharmed (federal offense); a $600,000 ransom was paid.
Status
Sentenced to death November 19, 1953; both executed in Jefferson City, Missouri, December 18, 1953.

On September 28, 1953, Carl Austin Hall and Bonnie Heady kidnaped a young boy in Kansas City, Missouri, and carried him across the state line into Kansas, where Hall killed him that same day. A ransom of $600,000 was paid for a child who was already dead, the largest sum handed over in any American kidnaping up to that time. Within days of the payment both kidnappers were in custody in St. Louis, and both confessed. In federal court in Kansas City they pleaded guilty to kidnaping, and a jury recommended death. On December 18, 1953, eighty-one days after the kidnaping, Hall and Heady were executed in Jefferson City. The speed of the case set it apart.

Hall was 34 in 1953. He had grown up around Pleasanton, Kansas, been sent to Kemper Military School in Boonville, Missouri, and served in the Marine Corps. He had once come into an inheritance of about $200,000, and he did not keep it long. The money went into the stock market, a liquor store and a crop-dusting business, and all three failed. By the early 1950s it was gone. He passed bad checks, then turned to robbing cab drivers, and in 1952 a robbery conviction sent him to the Missouri State Penitentiary in Jefferson City on a five-year term. He served fourteen months of it. In April 1953 he was paroled. A job selling cars did not last, and he told his parole office that he was working for an insurance company when he was not.

Heady was 41. She had grown up on a farm in Nodaway County, in northwest Missouri, and had lived for about twenty years in St. Joseph. In July 1953 she met Hall in a St. Joseph tavern, and he moved into her house. She would later tell investigators that she had gone along with his plan because she was infatuated with him. The plan was his, and so was the price of $600,000.

Everything that followed the kidnaping happened after the boy was dead. The demand, the payment and the week of waiting all belonged to a hope that had ended on the first day.

With the money in hand, Hall and Heady left St. Joseph for St. Louis, on the far side of the state, afraid the local police would trace them. The partnership did not survive the move. In St. Louis Hall left Heady with $2,500 of the ransom and struck out on his own. He spent freely, the spending drew notice, and a cab driver went to the police. Hall was arrested on October 6, 1953. After his arrest he admitted the kidnaping and told the police where Heady could be found, and she was taken into custody the same night. The next day investigators confirmed the boy's death.

Neither of them told the truth at first. Heady claimed she had known nothing of a kidnaping or a killing, and Hall backed her up. Hall denied killing the boy himself and put the blame on another man, and a nationwide alarm went out for him. Six days after the arrests, both gave up those stories and confessed. In his confession Hall cleared the man he had accused of any part in the crime.

Because the crime had crossed a state line, the case went to the United States District Court in Kansas City. Hall and Heady both pleaded guilty to kidnaping. The pleas settled the question of guilt but not the sentence: under the federal kidnaping statute as it then read, death could be imposed only on a jury's recommendation, and only where the kidnaped person had not been freed unharmed. In November 1953 a jury was sworn to decide that one question, imprisonment or death. Over more than one day the jurors heard the prosecution's witnesses and then the two confessions, Heady's first and Hall's the next day. Guilt was never in question before them; the history of the crime was. They recommended death for both.

On November 19, 1953, the judge sentenced Carl Austin Hall and Bonnie Brown Heady to death and set the executions for December 18. In the weeks that remained, the two asked to be allowed to marry. The request was refused.

Hall and Heady were executed in Jefferson City, Missouri, on December 18, 1953, under federal sentence. Of the forty people executed at the Missouri State Penitentiary between 1937 and 1989, Heady was the only woman. She was also, for close to seventy years, the last woman executed by the United States government; the next was not until January 2021.

Hall and Heady were sentenced to death for kidnaping and murder on pleas of guilty to kidnaping; the child's death was what opened the way to a death sentence under the kidnaping statute, and no separate murder trial was ever held in Missouri or Kansas.

Neither first account survived. Hall's placed the killing on another man, and Heady's denied any knowledge of a kidnaping; both were false and both were abandoned, and the confessions that followed named only Hall and Heady.

About half of the ransom was never recovered, and in 1954 the two St. Louis officers who made the arrest were convicted of perjury over their accounts of how the money was handled.

Timeline

1952: Carl Austin Hall is sent to the Missouri State Penitentiary on a five-year robbery term.

April 1953: Hall is paroled after fourteen months.

July 1953: Hall meets Bonnie Heady in St. Joseph and moves into her house.

September 28, 1953: Hall and Heady kidnap the boy in Kansas City; he is killed in Kansas the same day.

Early October 1953: The $600,000 ransom is paid.

October 6, 1953: Hall is arrested in St. Louis; Heady is taken into custody the same night.

October 7, 1953: Investigators confirm the boy's death.

October 1953: Six days after the arrests, both abandon their first stories and confess.

Autumn 1953: Both plead guilty in federal court in Kansas City to kidnaping.

November 1953: A jury hears the case on punishment alone and recommends death.

November 19, 1953: Both are sentenced to death, the executions set for December 18.

December 18, 1953: Hall and Heady are executed in Jefferson City, Missouri.