Callixte Kalimanzira was the second most senior official in Rwanda's Ministry of the Interior when the genocide against the Tutsi began in April 1994, and for nearly two months he was the man running the ministry's daily business while its minister stayed out of the country. He was also a son of Butare prefecture, an agronomist who had spent years trying to drain the marshes of his native district and grow rice and fish there, and one of very few people from his part of the country with a university degree. People in Butare knew him, respected him and, in the words of the court that later convicted him, loved him.
The International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda found that he used that standing for murder. On Saturday, April 23, 1994, thousands of Tutsi refugees who had gathered at the Gisagara marketplace were told to move to Kabuye hill, where they were promised protection. Kalimanzira stood beside the official giving that assurance and said nothing. Later the same day he came to the hill with soldiers and policemen, and the refugees there were killed in the thousands. In June 2009 the tribunal's Trial Chamber III found him guilty of genocide and of direct and public incitement to commit genocide and sentenced him to 30 years. In October 2010 the Appeals Chamber threw out every conviction but one. The finding that survived was aiding and abetting genocide in relation to the massacre at Kabuye hill. His sentence was cut to 25 years, and he died while still serving it.
Kalimanzira was born in 1953 in Nyaguhuru secteur, in Muganza commune of Butare prefecture, in the south of Rwanda. His parents and his five brothers and sisters were farmers, and none of them went beyond primary school. He was the only member of his family to go to university, and one of only three people of his generation from his area who did. He trained as a teacher in secondary school and then won a scholarship to the National University of Rwanda. Instead of continuing in education, he switched to agronomy, with the stated aim of improving farming and development in the district where he had grown up.
He graduated in 1981 and went back to the Kirarambogo area as an agronomical engineer. The swampy ground there was poor and hunger was a problem, and he taught local people to farm the marshland with rice, fish and other crops. He found money for the work, including the founding of cooperatives, from local benefactors and from a development organization, the Institut africain pour le développement économique et social, known as INADES. Rwanda's university graduates were automatically appointed to the civil service, so the arrangement needed government approval: on December 30, 1981, he was appointed to the Ministry of Agriculture and seconded to INADES by Presidential Order. He worked with the organization in Gisenyi prefecture for five years.
It was the period of his life the tribunal later described with something close to warmth. The Trial Chamber recorded that he was loved and appreciated in Butare for his efforts to develop the agriculture of his native region, and that his work as an agronomist was long remembered there.
In July 1986 the government made him a sous-préfet of Butare. By his own account at trial he had not wanted the job. He had been in line to lead INADES, he felt ill-suited to administration, and the post paid less, but he said refusing a government appointment would have brought punishment. He and his wife moved back to Butare, where he served as sous-préfet until May 1987 and then as acting préfet until November 1987.
The next years took him around the country. He was sent to Byumba prefecture as sous-préfet of Ngarama, on the border with Uganda, a post he held until August 1989. He testified that he and the préfet of Byumba tried to stop cattle smuggling there, ran into resistance from high levels of government and were both moved out of the region. With that préfet's help he joined the Ministry of Agriculture and Livestock at Ruhango in Gitarama prefecture in September 1989, became Coordinator of Agricultural Services for Kigali prefecture in May 1990, and in April 1991 was transferred to the Presidency as Director of Rural Development, a move he told the court he disliked.
His former préfet, meanwhile, had become Minister of the Interior and Communal Development. In January 1992 the minister made Kalimanzira Secretary General of the ministry, and in September 1992 its directeur de cabinet. Kalimanzira still held that post in April 1994. Rwanda's Official Journal of November 22, 1992, set out the duties: the directeur de cabinet coordinated and supervised the ministry's day-to-day work, was the most senior official after the minister, and stood in for the minister in current affairs when he was absent.
Kalimanzira presented himself at trial as a technocrat with no interest in politics. The Trial Chamber did not accept that picture. It noted that on May 31, 1993, he ran for and won a seat on the MRND party's Butare Prefectural Committee, in a prefecture where the MRND was unpopular, and it found that he was an active and prominent MRND member. It rejected a prosecution allegation that he had a close alliance with the interim President and Prime Minister, finding that his loyalty ran to his own minister.
President Juvénal Habyarimana's plane crashed on April 6, 1994. Kalimanzira and his wife were in Kigali. The tribunal later took judicial notice that between April 6 and July 17, 1994, genocide against the Tutsi ethnic group took place in Rwanda alongside a non-international armed conflict.
The Minister of the Interior was in Tanzania on an official mission when the killing began, and he did not come back. He was never sworn in as a minister of the interim government after April 9, and the post stayed empty until a new minister was appointed on May 25, 1994. For that whole period, the Trial Chamber found, Kalimanzira was the most senior official in the ministry and was running its daily affairs. He signed documents on the absent minister's behalf, including papers proposing candidates for public office, and he prepared the appointment of préfets and bourgmestres. The prosecution charged that he had in effect acted as Minister of the Interior. The Trial Chamber held that this was not proven beyond reasonable doubt: his formal authority was limited to the ministry's routine business, and the minister's political powers would have been exercised by others in the interim government. It found nonetheless that he held real authority over local officials while he was in charge of the ministry, and enormous influence in Butare, where his rise to a senior national post was known and admired.
His own account of those weeks was an alibi. He testified that he stayed in Kigali from April 6 to 14, then worked with the interim government at Murambi in Gitarama prefecture until May 30, and spent the rest of June in Butare prefecture. The Trial Chamber disbelieved it, and the Appeals Chamber later rejected his challenge to that finding.
In April 1994 Tutsi civilians from across the communes of southern Butare were fleeing killing, looting and burning in their own districts. Many of them gathered at the Gisagara marketplace. Others had already reached Kabuye hill in Ndora commune, where, the Trial Chamber found, they spent a few days of relative quiet before the killings there began in earnest.
On the morning of Saturday, April 23, the Trial Chamber found, Kalimanzira stopped at the Mukabuga roadblock and questioned the local cellule official in charge there about the Tutsis. When one of the men at the roadblock told him that the Tutsis had held off their attackers, Kalimanzira was enraged. The Trial Chamber treated that exchange as direct evidence that he knew the Tutsis on Kabuye hill were being targeted and that he wanted them dead.
That afternoon he was at the Gisagara marketplace, where thousands of refugees had gathered. The sub-prefect told the refugees to move to Kabuye hill and promised them protection there. Kalimanzira stood next to him and said nothing. The Trial Chamber found that his silence was itself a message: by standing beside the sub-prefect, the senior Interior Ministry official from their own prefecture lent credibility and authority to the promise of safety. The refugees were moved to the hill at once.
Later that day Kalimanzira came to Kabuye hill with soldiers and policemen. Until then the refugees had driven back every effort to overwhelm them. That Saturday, with far more attackers on the ground and the reinforcements that had arrived, they could not hold out, and they were killed in the thousands. The Trial Chamber found that Kalimanzira's part in sending the Tutsis to the hill and his later help in bringing reinforcements substantially contributed to the killings, that he knew and intended that the refugees would be killed, and that he was guilty beyond reasonable doubt of aiding and abetting genocide on April 23, 1994, at Kabuye hill.
Several of the prosecution witnesses who described the day were survivors of it, testifying under protective measures that kept their identities from the public. The Trial Chamber described them as people who had lived through great trauma, many of them with little schooling, and it found that the core of what they said held together across years of statements and cross-examination. A survivor who escaped on the day of the heaviest killing told the court he had known Kalimanzira since 1990 and saw him arrive at the hill.
Seven defense witnesses, survivors and attackers alike, said they had not seen Kalimanzira at Kabuye hill or heard of his involvement. The Trial Chamber pointed out that several prosecution witnesses had not seen him there either. Thousands of refugees, an uncounted number of attackers and a wide stretch of hills and valleys were involved over several days, and no one witness could have seen everything. It found that the defense evidence did nothing to cast reasonable doubt on the eyewitnesses who placed him on the hill.
After the genocide Kalimanzira went into exile. He did not hide. He lived openly in Kenya with his family and worked for a non-governmental organization helping refugees.
The tribunal's prosecutor indicted him in July 2005 on three counts: genocide; complicity in genocide, pleaded in the alternative; and direct and public incitement to commit genocide. When tribunal investigators came looking for him in Nairobi, he did not try to escape. He kept several appointments with them over several days and then surrendered, on November 8, 2005, and was taken to the United Nations Detention Facility in Arusha, Tanzania, the same day. He pleaded not guilty to all three counts.
The trial opened in Arusha on May 5, 2008, before Trial Chamber III, and the evidence closed on February 11, 2009, when Kalimanzira himself finished testifying as the last witness for the defense. Most witnesses on both sides testified under protective measures, and the court took care in its judgment not to reveal who they were. The defense asked for acquittal on every count. Its central argument was that Kalimanzira had no decision-making power in his ministry in April and May 1994 and had dealt only with routine affairs while his minister was abroad.
The Trial Chamber delivered its judgment on June 22, 2009. It found Callixte Kalimanzira guilty of genocide under Count 1 and guilty of direct and public incitement to commit genocide under Count 3, and it dismissed Count 2, complicity in genocide, which had been pleaded only as an alternative.
Kabuye hill was not the only event behind those verdicts. The Trial Chamber made six further findings of guilt against him: genocide at a roadblock on the Butare-Gisagara road around April 22, 1994, and at the inauguration of a new bourgmestre of Muganza commune on or around June 22, 1994; and direct and public incitement to commit genocide at four places in Butare prefecture, the Jaguar and Kajyanama roadblocks in April, the Nyabisagara football field in late May or early June, and the Gisagara marketplace at the end of May. Every one of those six findings was later reversed on appeal, and he stands convicted of none of them.
In fixing the sentence, the Trial Chamber counted against him his prominence in Butare society, as a former sous-préfet and one of the few university-educated people of his generation from his area, together with his status at the ministry, which made it likely that others would follow his example. Above all, it found, by encouraging Tutsi refugees to gather at Kabuye hill where he knew they would be killed in the thousands, he abused the public's trust that officials like him would protect them. It observed that his crimes were committed in his own prefecture and were essentially unrelated to his official duties at the national level, even though his post lent him the credibility and influence that some of his acts required. On the other side of the scale, it found that his actions showed no particular zeal or sadism, that he did not personally kill anyone, and that he stayed at the sites only briefly. It accepted that he had surrendered voluntarily and counted that in his favor, along with his public service and his open life in exile, though it said his good character before and after the conflict offered little in the way of mitigation. He was 55.
The Trial Chamber sentenced him to a single term of 30 years' imprisonment, with credit for the time he had already spent in custody since November 8, 2005.
Both sides appealed. Kalimanzira asked to be released. The prosecution wanted his responsibility for Kabuye hill and the Butare-Gisagara roadblock changed from aiding and abetting to ordering and committing, and it asked for life imprisonment. The Appeals Chamber gave judgment on October 20, 2010.
It took apart most of the trial judgment. It reversed the Butare-Gisagara roadblock conviction because the indictment had been defective on that event and Kalimanzira had not had a fair chance to answer the charge. It reversed the Jaguar and Kajyanama roadblock convictions because words addressed only to the men manning a roadblock might amount to incitement, but not to public incitement, and nothing showed that anyone else had been the audience. It reversed the Nyabisagara football field conviction, finding that no reasonable court could have relied on the accomplice witness who placed Kalimanzira at the rally. The May conviction at the Gisagara marketplace fell because the only witness's identification of him had not been established beyond reasonable doubt, and the inauguration conviction fell because the evidence of killings after the ceremony was vague and devoid of detail.
The Kabuye hill conviction stood. The Appeals Chamber accepted that the trial judges had erred in finding several waves of expulsions from the Gisagara marketplace, and it held unsafe the trial findings about 13 refugees on the Gisagara-Kabuye road, but it found that neither error touched the core of the case. The evidence about the marketplace and the hill showed that Kalimanzira intended to aid and abet the acts of genocide on Kabuye hill and substantially contributed to them. It also dismissed his complaints about the fairness of the trial, his authority and influence in Butare, and the rejection of his alibi, and it dismissed the prosecution's appeal in all respects.
The disposition affirmed "Kalimanzira's conviction for aiding and abetting genocide in relation to the massacre at Kabuye hill." Reversing almost all of his convictions, the Appeals Chamber said, significantly reduced his culpability, though he remained convicted of an extremely serious crime. It cut the 30-year term to 25 years of imprisonment, with credit for the time he had spent in detention since November 8, 2005.
On June 29, 2012, the tribunal transferred him and three other convicted men to the Republic of Benin to serve their sentences. Kalimanzira did not live to finish his term. The tribunal's case record states that he died while serving his sentence.
Press coverage of the trial often described Kalimanzira as Rwanda's acting or deputy interior minister. The Trial Chamber found that he was the most senior official in the ministry from April 6 to May 25, 1994, and ran its daily affairs, but held that the prosecution had not proved he acted as Minister of the Interior.
The prosecution's claim that he was a close ally of the interim President and Prime Minister was not proved. The Trial Chamber found only that he was an active and prominent member of the MRND.
Kalimanzira denied the charges throughout and offered an alibi placing him away from Butare for most of April and May 1994. Both chambers rejected the alibi.
Six of his seven findings of guilt at trial were reversed on appeal: genocide at the Butare-Gisagara roadblock and at the Ndayambaje inauguration, and direct and public incitement at the Jaguar and Kajyanama roadblocks, the Nyabisagara football field and the Gisagara marketplace in May. He stands convicted of none of those events. The Appeals Chamber also held unsafe the trial findings about the 13 refugees on the Gisagara-Kabuye road. His final conviction rests on his conduct at the Gisagara marketplace and Kabuye hill on April 23, 1994, and the Trial Chamber's finding that he did not personally kill anyone was never disturbed.
1953: Born in Nyaguhuru secteur, Muganza commune, Butare prefecture.
1981: Graduates in agronomy from the National University of Rwanda; seconded to INADES on December 30.
July 1986: Appointed sous-préfet of Butare; acting préfet from May to November 1987.
1987 to August 1989: Sous-préfet of Ngarama, Byumba prefecture.
September 1989 to December 1991: Posts at the Ministry of Agriculture and Livestock and, from April 1991, at the Presidency.
January 1992: Secretary General of the Ministry of the Interior.
September 1992: Directeur de cabinet of the Ministry of the Interior.
May 31, 1993: Elected to the MRND Butare Prefectural Committee.
April 6, 1994: President Habyarimana's plane crashes; genocide against the Tutsi begins.
April 6 to May 25, 1994: Most senior official at the Interior Ministry while the minister is absent.
April 23, 1994: At the Gisagara marketplace as refugees are sent to Kabuye hill; at the hill later that day as thousands are killed.
July 21, 2005: ICTR indictment filed.
November 8, 2005: Surrenders in Nairobi, Kenya; taken to Arusha.
May 5, 2008: Trial opens.
June 22, 2009: Found guilty of genocide and of direct and public incitement to commit genocide; sentenced to 30 years.
October 20, 2010: Appeals Chamber affirms the Kabuye hill conviction, reverses the rest and reduces the sentence to 25 years.
June 29, 2012: Transferred to Benin to serve his sentence.
After June 29, 2012: Dies while serving his sentence.