Byron David Smith was 64 years old and living on the rural edge of Little Falls, a central Minnesota town of about 8,000 people some 100 miles northwest of Minneapolis, when he killed two teenagers on Thanksgiving Day, November 22, 2012. Haile Kifer and Nicholas, a minor, had entered his property unlawfully that afternoon. Smith did not call the authorities that day. The next day a neighbor contacted the Morrison County Sheriff's Office for him, and deputies arrested him.
The case turned on one question, asked first by a grand jury and then by a trial jury: whether a man who had been burglarized repeatedly, and who said he feared for his life, had used the reasonable force Minnesota law allows a person defending his dwelling, or had planned to kill. Prosecutors charged second-degree murder and then took the case to a grand jury, which returned an indictment for first-degree premeditated murder. On April 29, 2014, after about three hours of deliberation, a Morrison County jury found Smith guilty on all four counts it was given, two of first-degree premeditated murder and two of second-degree murder. The court convicted him of the two first-degree counts and sentenced him at once to two concurrent life sentences without the possibility of release.
Seven years of appeals followed, most of them about a few minutes on the first morning of trial, when the judge cleared the courtroom of spectators and the press. The Minnesota Supreme Court affirmed the convictions in 2016. A federal district court and the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit refused habeas relief, and in March 2021 the Supreme Court of the United States declined to hear the case, over one justice's dissent. As of April 2026 Smith was serving his life sentence in Minnesota.
Little Falls sits on the Mississippi River in Morrison County, and in the fall of 2012 Smith's property on the edge of town was burglarized several times. In a burglary on October 27, 2012, valuable items were taken. Smith reported it, and the police investigated, but they could not determine who was responsible. The Minnesota Supreme Court later recorded that in the weeks that followed Smith was having trouble sleeping and was unhappy about the break-ins.
Smith had no history of violent behavior, a background check found after his arrest. His life before 2012 played almost no part in the court proceedings, which centered on a single day and on what he knew and believed on it.
The prosecution's theory, put to the grand jury and then to the trial jury, was that Smith's plan began on the morning of Thanksgiving Day and that everything he did before the afternoon was preparation for it. Prosecutors argued that what he did that morning showed a settled intention to kill whoever came in. Smith gave investigators other reasons for his actions. The jury, after hearing the evidence, accepted the prosecution's account of premeditation.
Early that afternoon the two teenagers entered the residence unlawfully, one after the other, and Smith killed each of them. There was no evidence that Smith knew or suspected the boy before that day. He did not notify law enforcement that day.
On Friday, November 23, Smith telephoned a neighbor and asked him to find a lawyer. He told the neighbor he had solved the break-ins in the area. The neighbor called the Morrison County Sheriff's Office and asked for the sergeant who had investigated the earlier burglaries. Deputies came to the property that day. Smith told them he had been the victim of previous burglaries, the most recent the day before, and then told them what he had done. The deputies arrested him.
Smith was questioned at the sheriff's office after he was advised of his rights. In those interviews he went back over the whole autumn, the burglaries before Thanksgiving and the events of Thanksgiving itself, and described what he had done. Those statements formed part of the evidence at trial.
On Monday, November 26, 2012, the Morrison County Attorney's Office charged Smith by complaint in Morrison County District Court with two counts of second-degree murder. He was released on bail in December 2012.
Prosecutors took the case to a grand jury in the spring of 2013, and on April 24, 2013, the grand jury indicted Smith under seal on two counts of first-degree murder with premeditation. The charges were announced the next day. A conviction on either count carried a mandatory sentence of life without parole.
Smith remained free on bond through the pretrial months. The district court denied his motion to dismiss the indictment, and the appellate courts declined to review that ruling before trial.
The central evidentiary fight before trial concerned the earlier burglaries. Smith wanted the jury to hear about them in detail, and he wanted to call witnesses who would have testified that one of the two teenagers had taken part in them. The trial court held two public hearings on the question, on March 25 and April 17, 2014. On April 4 it filed a public order: the fact that the burglaries had happened was relevant, but the alleged involvement of either teenager was not. The reasonableness of Smith's actions, the court reasoned, had to be judged by his state of mind at the time, and he had no knowledge then of who had committed the earlier burglaries.
Jury selection was finished the week before trial, but the jurors had not yet taken their final oath. When the case was called on the morning of April 21, 2014, the judge immediately cleared every spectator from the courtroom. Smith's lawyers objected, arguing that the public and the press had a right to be there and that closing the room violated his right to a public trial. The judge overruled the objection and, with the courtroom closed, explained the scope of the ruling on the burglary witnesses, saying he was concerned that the press would publish the substance of the pretrial ruling and that it might reach the jury. The courtroom was then reopened, and the judge filed a written order holding that evidence of prior acts by either teenager, of which Smith had not been aware at the time, was inadmissible at trial. The closed session took up about two-tenths of one percent of the trial transcript. It became the main subject of every appeal that followed.
The trial began on April 21, 2014, before a jury of six men and six women. The prosecution's case was that the killings were premeditated and that Smith had made a choice each time he acted. The defense case was that Smith was a frightened man who had been burglarized repeatedly, who had asked the authorities for a more thorough investigation, and who had used reasonable force in defense of himself and his dwelling. Smith did not testify.
The trial court allowed the jury to hear that Smith's property had been burglarized before Thanksgiving Day, including the October 27 burglary and the items taken in it. It kept out the evidence that one of the teenagers had been involved in the earlier break-ins, an item taken in one of them, a deputy's testimony about that item's condition when it was recovered, and the testimony of an expert witness who would have told the jury that Smith was suffering from critical-incident stress during the second of the two killings. The court instructed the jury that Smith was claiming reasonable force in defense of himself and his dwelling, and that the State had the burden of proving beyond a reasonable doubt that he did not use reasonable force.
Closing arguments were heard on Tuesday, April 29, 2014. During the prosecution's closing, the prosecutor invited the jurors to consider for themselves what could be made out in one ambiguous passage of the evidence. The defense objected and moved for a mistrial. The court denied the mistrial but said a cautionary instruction was required; none was given, and the defense did not object to its absence at the time.
The jury retired that afternoon and returned its verdicts after about three hours. It found Smith guilty of two counts of second-degree murder and two counts of first-degree premeditated murder. The district court entered convictions on the two counts of first-degree premeditated murder and sentenced Smith the same day to two concurrent life sentences without the possibility of release, the only sentence the law allowed. Judgment was entered on April 29, 2014.
Because the convictions were for first-degree murder, the appeal went straight to the Minnesota Supreme Court, bypassing the Court of Appeals. A separate dispute over restitution was held over for a later hearing, and the Supreme Court later consolidated that issue with the main appeal.
The Minnesota Supreme Court decided the consolidated appeals, State of Minnesota v. Byron David Smith, on March 9, 2016. Smith raised four kinds of error, and the State raised one of its own on restitution. The court rejected all of Smith's arguments and agreed with the State.
The first group of claims went back to the grand jury. Smith argued that the indictment was issued without the jurors' true deliberation and vote, because the formal indictment differed from the proposed version read to them before they deliberated; that he was prejudiced when the prosecution tried to impeach a witness; that the grand jurors were improperly told he had already been charged with second-degree murder; that the instruction on premeditation blurred the line between first- and second-degree murder; and that there was one further error in the presentation. The court held that the district court did not err in refusing to dismiss the indictment on any of the five grounds taken one at a time. It held too that their combined effect had not deprived Smith of a fair grand-jury proceeding: even assuming every alleged error was real, the prosecution had put more than enough evidence before the grand jury to establish probable cause, and the court had reminded the jurors of their independence.
The second claim was the courtroom closure. The court held that the nonpublic proceeding on April 21, 2014, did not violate Smith's Sixth Amendment right to a public trial. It said plainly that the trial court should not have closed the courtroom, but it treated the brief session as an administrative proceeding about the scope of a ruling already made in public, held before the jury was sworn, and concluded that any error in closing it was not of constitutional magnitude. Smith, the court said, had received a public trial. One justice concurred only in the result. He rejected the majority's description of the closure as trivial or administrative and said the reason given for it was unacceptable in light of the purposes of the public-trial right, but agreed that there was no Sixth Amendment violation, because in his view the closure did not happen during a stage of the trial to which the right attached.
The third claim was that the trial court had violated Smith's right to present a complete defense by excluding four pieces of evidence. The court rejected it point by point. Excluding the testimony that one teenager had taken part in the earlier burglaries was within the trial court's discretion under Minnesota Rule of Evidence 403, because at the time of the killings Smith did not know who had committed those burglaries and the evidence could have confused the jury about what he knew. Keeping the item taken in an earlier burglary out of the courtroom was also within the court's discretion, since a photograph and a description were enough; excluding the deputy's testimony about its condition was an error, but the court held that the error was not prejudicial. On the expert evidence about critical-incident stress, the court assumed without deciding that the exclusion was an abuse of discretion and held it harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. And excluding evidence said to link one of the teenagers to the October 27 burglary was within the trial court's discretion, because Smith had no accurate knowledge at the time of who had committed it.
The fourth claim concerned the closing argument. The court held that the prosecutor had not committed misconduct by inviting the jurors to consider what an ambiguous piece of evidence contained: the material was open to debate, and both sides were free to argue their reasonable readings of it. Because there was no misconduct, the trial court did not err by failing to give a curative instruction.
On the State's cross-appeal, the court held that the district court had erred in treating Smith's affidavit challenging a restitution request as timely under the Minnesota restitution statute, and it reversed on that issue. The disposition was "affirmed in part and reversed in part." The convictions and the life sentences stood, and judgment was entered on May 3, 2016.
In early March 2017 Smith's lawyers filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus in the United States District Court for the District of Minnesota, arguing that his life sentence was unconstitutional because the closed session had denied him a public trial.
On August 3, 2018, the district court denied the petition and granted a certificate of appealability. The court denied relief under the highly deferential federal standard while expressing serious concern about the state decision and finding that the closure did not satisfy the test the Supreme Court had set out in Waller v. Georgia.
The Eighth Circuit affirmed on May 5, 2020. The panel held that the holdings of the two governing Supreme Court cases, Waller v. Georgia and Presley v. Georgia, were limited to suppression hearings and jury selection, and that neither decided whether the public-trial right covers a brief nonpublic proceeding of the kind held in Smith's case. The Minnesota decision was therefore not contrary to clearly established federal law. Nor was it an unreasonable application of that law: whether the right reaches a judge's explanation of an evidentiary ruling was an open question on which fairminded jurists could disagree, and it was not objectively unreasonable for the state court to find no violation in a short closed session, held before the jury was sworn, that explained the limits of an order already issued in public. The Eighth Circuit denied rehearing and rehearing en banc on June 8, 2020.
Smith then petitioned the Supreme Court of the United States, asking whether the public-trial guarantee, within the federal habeas framework, applies to every stage of a criminal trial or only to suppression hearings and jury selection. The Court denied the petition on March 22, 2021. One justice dissented from the denial. She would have summarily reversed or, at the least, heard the case in full, writing that the Minnesota court's exception for administrative proceedings had no basis in the Court's precedent and that the Eighth Circuit had wrongly treated the reasoning of Waller and Presley as mere dicta. The denial ended Smith's challenge to the closure.
Smith is in the custody of the Minnesota Department of Corrections under his two life sentences without the possibility of release. As of April 2026 he was serving those sentences in Minnesota.
The defense at trial rested on Minnesota's statute on the justifiable taking of life, section 609.065. It provides that the intentional taking of another person's life is not authorized by the general rule on reasonable force except in two situations: when it is necessary to resist or prevent an offense the actor reasonably believes exposes the actor or another person to great bodily harm or death, and when it is necessary to prevent the commission of a felony in the place where the actor lives. Either exception requires that the force used be reasonable in the circumstances. In Smith's case the trial court put the issue to the jury as a question of reasonable force in defense of himself and his dwelling and told the jurors that the burden was on the State to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he did not use reasonable force.
The claim that one of the two teenagers had taken part in the earlier burglaries of Smith's property was never tested before the jury. The trial court excluded it as irrelevant to Smith's state of mind, the Minnesota Supreme Court upheld that ruling, and no court made any finding on whether the claim was true.
The expert evidence that Smith was suffering from critical-incident stress during the second killing, and that it affected what he could perceive, was also never heard. The Minnesota Supreme Court did not decide whether excluding it was an error, holding only that any error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt.
Smith has maintained throughout that he acted in self-defense and in defense of his dwelling. The jury rejected that defense, and no court has disturbed the verdict.
The constitutional question about the closed session on April 21, 2014, divided the judges who considered it. The Minnesota Supreme Court's majority found no violation because it treated the session as administrative; a concurring justice found no violation for a different reason; the federal district court found that the closure failed the Waller test while still denying relief under the deferential federal standard; the Eighth Circuit found the state decision reasonable; and one justice of the Supreme Court of the United States would have reversed. The convictions stand.
October 27, 2012: Smith's property in Little Falls, Minnesota, is burglarized; police investigate but cannot determine who was responsible.
November 22, 2012: On Thanksgiving Day Smith kills two teenagers who had entered his property unlawfully.
November 23, 2012: A neighbor contacts the Morrison County Sheriff's Office for Smith; deputies arrest him.
November 26, 2012: Smith is charged in Morrison County District Court with two counts of second-degree murder.
December 2012: Smith is released on bail.
April 24, 2013: A grand jury indicts Smith on two counts of first-degree premeditated murder; the indictment is announced the next day.
April 4, 2014: The trial court rules that the earlier burglaries are admissible but the alleged involvement of either teenager is not.
April 21, 2014: The judge briefly closes the courtroom before the jury is sworn; the trial begins.
April 29, 2014: After about three hours of deliberation the jury finds Smith guilty on all four counts; he is convicted of two counts of first-degree premeditated murder and sentenced to two concurrent life terms without the possibility of release.
March 9, 2016: The Minnesota Supreme Court affirms the convictions and reverses on restitution.
August 3, 2018: The federal district court denies habeas relief.
May 5, 2020: The Eighth Circuit affirms; rehearing en banc is denied on June 8.
March 22, 2021: The Supreme Court of the United States denies certiorari, with one justice dissenting.
April 2026: Smith is serving his life sentences in Minnesota.