Buford Furrow

Victims
1 federal employee killed, 5 people wounded, Los Angeles, 1999. Pleaded guilty January 24, 2001 to all 16 federal counts (murder, hate-crime and arms counts)
Years active
August 10, 1999
Location
Granada Hills and Chatsworth, California; Las Vegas, Nevada; Washington State
Method
Murder of a federal employee; violent interference with federally protected activities because of race or religion; federal arms offenses
Status
Sentenced March 26, 2001: two consecutive life terms without parole plus 110 years and $690,294 restitution; plea gave up appeal; death penalty withdrawn

On August 10, 1999, Buford O'Neal Furrow Jr. wounded five people at a Jewish community center in Granada Hills, in the San Fernando Valley of Los Angeles. Later that day, in neighboring Chatsworth, he killed Joseph Ileto, a Filipino American employee of the federal government who was at work that day. The next morning Furrow walked into the FBI office in Las Vegas and gave himself up. He was 37, a former member of the Aryan Nations from Olympia, Washington, and he had been released from a Washington jail that May.

Federal prosecutors charged him with murder and hate crimes and won permission from the Attorney General to seek his execution. The case never went to trial. On January 24, 2001, in federal court in Los Angeles, Furrow pleaded guilty to every one of the 16 counts against him under an agreement that took the death penalty off the table, and on March 26, 2001, he was sentenced to two consecutive life terms without parole, plus 110 years. The plea left him no appeal. The sentence carries no release date.

Furrow went to Timberline High School in Lacey, Washington. He joined the Army for a short time and left with an honorable discharge because of a bad knee, then studied engineering at a community college. The years that followed were a run of jobs rather than a career: a Northrop Grumman plant near Rosamond, California; a machinery-repair shop in Colville, in northeastern Washington, from 1994 until he was laid off in late 1995; and later a gear company in Everett, Washington, where he worked as a computer-assisted design engineer until he took a leave in late 1998.

In the early 1990s he joined the Aryan Nations, the neo-Nazi group then based at a compound in Hayden Lake, Idaho. By 1994 he was part of the security detail around its founder, and in 1995 he held an official position in the group's security force. He followed Christian Identity, the racist and anti-Semitic theology the group promoted. He had lived in both Washington and California, and by the summer of 1999 he was back in western Washington.

In late October 1998, in Kirkland, outside Seattle, Furrow sought admission for psychiatric care. The visit ended with his arrest by a King County deputy. On November 2, 1998, he was charged with felony assault, and he later pleaded guilty to second-degree assault. He had been held in mental hospitals for about six weeks and had been diagnosed and stabilized on medication.

He served his sentence in the King County Jail and was released in May 1999, early for good behavior, under supervision. Among the conditions, he was to stay on his medication and stay away from alcohol. He was still under that supervision in August.

The center in Granada Hills ran summer day programs. Five people there were wounded: an adult receptionist, a teenage camp counselor and three young boys who were campers. All five survived and recovered. Nobody at the center died.

In Chatsworth he then killed a man he had never met, a federal employee who had come to the United States from the Philippines. The federal case held that Furrow had chosen his victims for their race and their presumed religion: the man in Chatsworth because he was not white and worked for the federal government, the people at the center because Furrow presumed they were Jewish.

Furrow left the Los Angeles area the same day. On the morning of August 11 he surrendered to the FBI in Las Vegas. He was charged before a federal magistrate there and flown to Los Angeles.

Two prosecutors' offices had a claim on him. The killing in Chatsworth was a federal crime because the victim was a federal employee killed while on duty, and a federal murder conviction carried a possible death sentence. The wounding at the center fell first to the Los Angeles County District Attorney, who filed five counts of attempted murder, with a further count and allegations that the crimes were motivated by hatred. The two offices agreed that the federal case would go first. On August 19, 1999, nine days after the crimes, a federal grand jury indicted Furrow on three counts, the murder and two related counts, and the state charges were held in abeyance until the federal case was over.

The grand jury kept working, and on December 2, 1999, it returned a 16-count superseding indictment that added 13 counts and brought the wounding of the five people into the federal case. Six of the new counts were civil-rights counts under Section 245 of the federal criminal code, which punishes violent interference, because of race, color, religion or national origin, with rights that the Civil Rights Act of 1964 protects. For the people at the center, the right at stake was the use of a place that serves the public; for the man in Chatsworth, it was the right to hold federal employment. The other seven new counts were federal arms counts. The indictment treated the North Valley Jewish Community Center as a place serving the public: it took day-care children of every faith and let the public use its pool and meeting rooms for a fee. The counts tied to the center carried a possible life sentence. In February 2000 the Attorney General authorized prosecutors to seek death on the counts tied to the killing in Chatsworth.

The defense then attacked the indictment from two directions, and on September 19, 2000, the federal judge rejected both.

The first challenge went to the grand jury. The defense argued that once Furrow had been indicted, prosecutors had kept the grand jury sitting chiefly to gather evidence for a penalty phase, a use the law forbids. The court found no abuse. After the first indictment, it held, the government had gone on investigating whether anyone else was involved and preparing added charges, both proper purposes, and whatever help the testimony gave on sentencing questions was incidental. The defense had not overcome the presumption that grand jury proceedings are regular, and its motion for sanctions was denied.

The second challenge went to the power of Congress. The defense moved to dismiss counts 2 through 16, arguing that the Constitution gave Congress no authority to pass the laws behind them. It leaned on two recent Supreme Court decisions, United States v. Lopez and United States v. Morrison, which had struck down federal criminal statutes as reaching beyond the commerce power. The court distinguished both. Section 245 did not reach violent crime in general, it held, only bias-motivated violence that interferes with a federally protected right. Violence that keeps people from places serving the public or from federal employment, taken in the aggregate, has a substantial effect on interstate commerce, and the statute was an integral part of the body of civil-rights law built on the 1964 Act. The requirement that a defendant intend to interfere with such a right did the work of a jurisdictional limit, separating what was national from what was local. The arms counts stood on earlier Ninth Circuit rulings and, for one of them, on Congress's taxing power. The motion was denied in full.

The trial never took place. Furrow's defense had been preparing to put his mental condition before a jury, with a possible insanity defense. On January 24, 2001, he pleaded guilty to all 16 counts, admitting the murder in Chatsworth and the wounding of the five people at the center, and under the agreement he accepted life in prison without the possibility of parole and gave up any appeal. The government withdrew the death penalty because of the evidence of his mental illness and severe psychiatric problems in the years before the crimes; it did not concede that he was mentally ill on August 10, 1999.

On March 26, 2001, the judge imposed two consecutive life sentences without the possibility of parole, plus 110 years, and ordered him to pay $690,294 in restitution. Before sentence was passed, Furrow read a statement of apology and blamed his mental illness. He was then 39.

Furrow's mental state on August 10, 1999, was never decided by a court. His defense had been ready to argue insanity; the government accepted that he had a history of mental illness and severe psychiatric problems, and dropped the death penalty on that basis, but did not agree that he was mentally ill at the time of the crimes. Because he pleaded guilty, no jury or judge ever ruled on an insanity defense.

Timeline

Early 1990s: Furrow joins the Aryan Nations; by 1994 he is on its security detail.

1994 to late 1995: Works at a machinery-repair shop in Colville, Washington.

Late October 1998: Arrested after a visit to a psychiatric hospital in Kirkland, Washington.

November 2, 1998: Charged with felony assault in King County; later pleads guilty to second-degree assault.

May 1999: Released early from the King County Jail under supervision.

August 10, 1999: Five people wounded in Granada Hills; a federal employee killed in Chatsworth.

August 11, 1999: Surrenders to the FBI in Las Vegas.

August 19, 1999: Federal grand jury indicts him on three counts, including the murder; state charges held in abeyance.

December 2, 1999: Sixteen-count superseding indictment adds 13 counts, six of them federal civil-rights counts.

February 2000: The Attorney General authorizes prosecutors to seek the death penalty.

September 19, 2000: The court rejects the defense challenges to the grand jury and to the constitutionality of counts 2 through 16.

January 24, 2001: Pleads guilty to all 16 counts; the death penalty is withdrawn.

March 26, 2001: Sentenced to two consecutive life terms without parole, plus 110 years, and $690,294 in restitution.