Bruno Dey was 17 years old when the German army found him unfit for the front and sent him, in the summer of 1944, to the Stutthof concentration camp east of Danzig. For the next eight months he stood guard in its watchtowers and walked beside its prisoner labor details. He was never accused of killing anyone with his own hands. The charge, when it finally came, was that his presence on the towers had kept the camp sealed while the SS murdered thousands of people inside it.
On July 23, 2020, the juvenile chamber of the Hamburg Regional Court convicted him of aiding and abetting murder in 5,232 cases and attempted murder in one case. He was 93. Because he had been a youth at the time of the crimes, the court sentenced him under juvenile law to two years, suspended. Both sides filed appeals and both withdrew them, and the verdict became final on August 10, 2020. The case was among the last German prosecutions for the crimes of the Nazi camps, and it carried a line of legal reasoning first used against guards of extermination camps into a concentration camp whose purpose had not been killing alone.
Dey grew up outside Danzig and trained as a baker's apprentice. In 1944 he was drafted into the Wehrmacht, the regular German army, and found unfit for combat because of a heart condition. Rather than send him to the front, the army posted him to an SS guard detachment at Stutthof, close to his home district.
By his own account he did not volunteer for the SS and did not choose camp duty. When he learned where he was going, he tried to be reassigned to an army kitchen or bakery, without success. He testified that he was one of about 400 soldiers brought to the camp in June or July of 1944 and that he arrived knowing almost nothing of who was held there beyond rumors of political prisoners and Jews. After a stay in the hospital he had to put on the SS tunic. The indictment placed the start of his service on August 9, 1944, and its end on April 26, 1945.
His duty was to stop prisoners from escaping, rising up or being freed. He stood watch in the towers around the camp and guarded work crews outside the wire. He later told the court that he had never harmed a prisoner.
The camp stood near the town of Stutthof, now Sztutowo, about 22 miles east of Danzig, and had been a regular concentration camp since January 1942. In the summer of 1944, at about the time Dey arrived, tens of thousands of Jews were brought in from the ghettos and labor camps of the Baltic states and from Auschwitz. Most of the deaths in his case took place among them, in the camp's Jewish section, in the last months of the war.
The court found that at least 5,232 prisoners were murdered at Stutthof during the months Dey served there, most of them Jewish men and women. From September 1944, it found, the SS ran the camp so that Jewish prisoners and prisoners from Eastern Europe would die within a short time.
None of these deaths was laid at Dey's door as his own act. The conviction rested on the finding that the killings could not have been carried out without the guards who kept the prisoners in, and that he knew what was happening. The court concluded that he had seen the mass deaths from his post day after day. The indictment had named 5,230 victims; two counts were added during the trial.
German courts changed their approach to camp guards in 2011, and Hamburg prosecutors questioned Dey in 2018. He did not deny that he had served at Stutthof. He confirmed that he had stood watch in the towers, that he had known of the gas chamber and that he had seen emaciated, suffering people. He said he was never a Nazi. Asked why he had not asked to be sent to the front instead, he answered that it would have made no difference, because they would simply have found someone else.
On April 18, 2019, Hamburg prosecutors announced that they had charged him, then 92, with aiding and abetting the murder of 5,230 people at Stutthof between August 1944 and April 1945. The indictment accused him of knowingly supporting the treacherous and cruel killing of mainly Jewish prisoners by guarding the camp and its work details, and of knowing of the killings, in some cases in detail. Because he had been 17 when his service began, the case went to a juvenile chamber.
The trial opened on October 17, 2019, before the juvenile chamber of the Hamburg Regional Court. On the first day a statement was read in his name. It admitted his service as an SS guard, said he had been drafted into the Wehrmacht at 17, found unfit and sent to the camp, and said he had neither joined the SS of his own will nor supported the system. Dey confirmed that the statement was his.
In December 2019 he told the court that his job had been to watch the perimeter fence to prevent escapes, that he had been a conscript and that he did not see himself as guilty. Later in the trial he accepted that he had seen many dead, that he had known of the gas chamber and crematorium and that he had heard comrades talk about the extermination of the Jews. He denied that this made him part of the machinery of murder and said a simple guard could have done nothing about it. He wanted to forget that time, he said; he bore no guilt for what had happened and had only stood guard because he was ordered to.
The prosecution asked on July 6, 2020, for a juvenile sentence of three years. The defense asked on July 20 for an acquittal. Dey then gave his final word. He apologized to everyone who had gone through what he called the hell of this madness, and to their relatives, and said that such a thing must never be repeated. He said he had never volunteered for the towers, still less for a concentration camp, and that only through the trial had he come to understand the full extent of what was done at Stutthof.
On July 23, 2020, the court convicted him of aiding and abetting murder in 5,232 cases and attempted murder in one case, and imposed a sentence of two years under juvenile law, suspended.
The court accepted that he had acted under orders and held that this did not excuse him. It found that he could and should have tried to withdraw from his post, and it pointed to Paragraph 47 of the German Military Criminal Code, which even under the law of the time forbade obedience to criminal orders.
In setting the sentence it weighed his youth, his upbringing in the Nazi state and the danger to his life that a transfer to the front would have carried. Juvenile law required a penalty that matched the guilt of a 17- and 18-year-old, and the court held that two years, suspended, did so.
Within the one-week deadline, appeals on points of law were filed for two co-plaintiffs and for Dey. The co-plaintiff appeals were withdrawn first, and on August 10, 2020, Dey's appeal was withdrawn as well. The verdict became final that day. Under its terms he did not go to prison. No later court proceeding against him has been reported.
After the war he spent a short time as a prisoner of war. He went on to work as a baker, then as a truck driver and in building maintenance, and he was living in Hamburg when the case came to court.
Until 2011, German courts generally required proof that a camp guard had joined in a specific killing. From that year they convicted guards of extermination camps as accessories to murder without evidence tying them to any single death, and the Federal Court of Justice upheld a conviction on that reasoning. The Hamburg prosecution argued that the reasoning reached Stutthof as well, a concentration camp rather than an extermination camp, because tens of thousands were killed there and because forced labor had become a means of killing. The court accepted that argument and convicted him for every murder committed during his months of service, not for any act of his own. Because he was 17 when his service began and 18 when it ended, the sentence was measured by juvenile law: the penalty had to fit the guilt of the young man he had been, not the old man in the dock.
Dey never admitted guilt. He accepted that he had served at Stutthof, that he had known of the gas chamber and that he had heard of the extermination of the Jews, but he maintained that a guard on a tower did not share in the murders and that he could not have refused the post. The court rejected that position. It found that he had seen the killings and could have tried to leave.
No specific death was attributed to him personally. His statement that he never harmed a prisoner was his own account, and the court's judgment did not depend on it.
His claim that he could not have avoided Stutthof was contested. He said his heart condition, not his choice, put him in the SS. The prosecution argued that he could have sought a transfer. The court accepted that a transfer would have endangered his life and counted that in his favor at sentencing, while holding that it did not excuse him.
1944: Drafted into the Wehrmacht at 17, found unfit for the front with a heart condition and posted to an SS guard detachment at Stutthof.
August 9, 1944: Start of his service as a guard, as charged.
April 26, 1945: End of his service, as charged.
2018: Questioned by Hamburg prosecutors.
April 18, 2019: Charge of aiding and abetting murder in 5,230 cases announced.
October 17, 2019: Trial opens before the juvenile chamber of the Hamburg Regional Court.
July 6, 2020: Prosecution asks for three years.
July 20, 2020: Defense asks for acquittal; he gives his final word.
July 23, 2020: Convicted of aiding and abetting murder in 5,232 cases and attempted murder in one case; two years under juvenile law, suspended.
August 10, 2020: Appeals withdrawn; the verdict becomes final.