Alan Berg died in Denver on the night of June 18, 1984. He was Jewish, he was one of the most recognizable voices in the city, and he had challenged hate groups on the air. Bruce Carroll Pierce, a member of a small, secret white supremacist group that called itself The Order, was later found by a federal jury to have taken part in his killing. The jury did not convict him of murder, because no one ever charged him with it. Denver's district attorney decided there was not enough evidence for a homicide case, and the United States instead prosecuted the killing as a crime against the broadcaster's civil rights. In November 1987 a jury in the federal court in Denver found Pierce guilty of willfully injuring and interfering with him, by force, because he was Jewish and because he was enjoying his employment, and found that the offense resulted in his death.
By then Pierce was already serving a hundred years. A federal jury in Seattle had convicted him in December 1985 of racketeering and racketeering conspiracy in the main prosecution of The Order, in which the Denver killing was one of the crimes the government laid out as part of a pattern. The Denver court added 150 years. Two federal courts of appeals upheld the two convictions, and a jury in Arkansas acquitted him in 1988 of conspiring to overthrow the government. He spent the rest of his life in federal custody and died in Pennsylvania in August 2010, at 56, still holding the beliefs that had brought him there.
The group that Pierce joined was small and short-lived. The Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals, reviewing the Denver case, described a covert organization founded at a September 1983 meeting on its leader's property at Metaline Falls, Washington. The Ninth Circuit, reviewing the Seattle convictions, called it a radical right-wing, white supremacist group formed in 1983 with the aim of overthrowing the government. Its members also used the name the Silent Brotherhood.
Pierce was there from the start. The Southern Poverty Law Center called him a founding member, and a timeline published by the Spokane newspaper in 2000 places him among the four men who carried out the group's first robbery, in Spokane in October 1983. The Ninth Circuit traced the group's money in the months that followed. Its members first tried counterfeiting, the court wrote, and gave the idea up when Pierce was arrested for passing fake bills. They turned to robbery instead, and in 1984 they took millions of dollars from an armored car near Ukiah, California. The same opinion said the group committed two killings, one of them the killing in Denver.
The counterfeiting arrest put Pierce into the federal system months before the Denver killing. He pleaded guilty in Spokane to counterfeiting charges and was due to be sentenced in April 1984. He did not appear. From that spring until March 1985 he was a federal fugitive.
He had been a lawyer in Chicago, among the youngest people to pass the Illinois bar examination, before he became one of Denver's most recognized public figures. He was outspoken and confrontational, and liberal in his politics. The federal courts later described him plainly: a Jewish man, a radio talk-show host, a man whose broadcasts attacked the beliefs of the people who were tried for his death. He called out hate groups by name on the air, and several weeks before his death he argued on the air with the man later convicted alongside Pierce.
His religion became a question at trial. He was born to Jewish parents but did not practice the faith, and he had said on the air that he doubted the existence of God. The defense argued that he could not therefore be considered Jewish under the civil rights law. The jury rejected that argument, and so did the Tenth Circuit, which found the evidence sufficient for a rational jury to conclude that Pierce acted because of his religion.
The break in the case came in the Pacific Northwest. On December 7, 1984, four members of The Order were arrested on Whidbey Island, Washington, and the group's founder died there during a siege by federal agents. Other members became fugitives, and several who were later caught chose to cooperate with prosecutors.
Pierce was still at large. In late March 1985 FBI agents took him into custody in Rossville, in north Georgia. He was held at first on federal charges that had nothing directly to do with the Denver killing: failing to appear for sentencing on the counterfeiting case, a federal arms-law offense, and the robbery of an armored car in Washington State. He was sent to the federal penitentiary in Atlanta to begin a two-year term for counterfeiting, still facing questions in murder and armed-robbery cases.
The case over the Denver killing rested on two kinds of evidence. One was the word of former members. Several of them, facing long sentences of their own, agreed to testify, and two later told juries that Pierce had spoken to them about the killing. The other was physical evidence, which FBI agents later told the Seattle jury linked the killing to a property Pierce had rented in Montana. Neither kind amounted to an eyewitness, and that gap shaped everything that came after.
On April 15, 1985, a federal grand jury in Seattle indicted 23 members of The Order under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, on racketeering and racketeering conspiracy counts, with further counts covering a conspiracy to rob an armored car and other federal offenses. Each defendant was charged with taking part in at least two crimes from a list of 67 alleged acts of the enterprise, and the list included both killings the government attributed to the group. The Denver killing was one of the acts charged against Pierce. Twelve of the 23 defendants pleaded guilty before trial. Pierce did not.
The trial in the United States District Court for the Western District of Washington ended on December 30, 1985. Former members described the group's plans to the jury, and FBI agents testified that evidence from the Denver case matched material recovered from the Montana property. The jury found all ten remaining defendants guilty of racketeering. Pierce was convicted on the substantive racketeering count, on the racketeering conspiracy count and on the count of conspiracy to rob an armored car. The jury did not have to say which two of the 67 acts it had relied on for each defendant, and it never said whether the Denver killing was among them.
In February 1986 the trial judge sentenced the ten. Pierce, then 31 and listed as living in Hayden Lake, Idaho, received 100 years, the longest term in the case, shared with one other defendant. The court imposed the maximum 20 years on each racketeering count, to run consecutively, and a consecutive 20 years on the armored-car conspiracy count. Federal law then in force required at least ten years to be served before parole could be considered.
The Ninth Circuit affirmed every conviction and sentence on July 6, 1988, in United States v. Yarbrough. It rejected Pierce's argument that the government should not have been allowed to plead the two killings as racketeering acts, his challenge to the evidence on the armored-car count, and his claim that the consecutive term on that count was cruel and unusual punishment.
The racketeering verdict left the Denver killing unresolved in law. The Seattle jury had never said whether it found that Pierce took part, and Colorado authorities were still weighing murder charges in early 1986. Later that year Denver's district attorney announced that he would not file homicide charges. There was no direct evidence and no eyewitness tying the suspects to the killing, and a state homicide case would have had to be built on the testimony of former members who had made deals of their own.
The federal government then turned to the civil rights law. A federal grand jury in Colorado indicted Pierce, David Lane and two others under the 1968 federal civil rights statute, 18 U.S.C. § 245(b)(2)(C), and the aiding-and-abetting statute. The indictment charged that they had willfully injured and interfered with the broadcaster by force or threat of force because he was Jewish and because he was enjoying employment with a private employer, and that the offense had resulted in his death. All four were already serving racketeering sentences from Seattle, and all four faced possible life terms.
Jury selection began in the United States District Court in Denver at the end of October 1987. To convict, the government had to prove that each defendant used force, injured the victim, acted because of his religion, acted willfully and caused his death. Its case, built mostly on the testimony of former members of the group, was that Pierce had carried out the killing with Lane's help, as part of a wider plot to overthrow the United States government through counterfeiting, robbery and killings.
In November 1987 the jury found Pierce and Lane guilty and acquitted the two other defendants. In December 1987 the court sentenced Pierce, then 33, and Lane each to 150 years in prison, with no parole eligibility for at least 50 years. Pierce's sentences across the federal cases came to 252 years.
Pierce faced one more trial. In 1987 a federal grand jury in Arkansas indicted fourteen men, among them several imprisoned members of The Order, on charges centered on seditious conspiracy, an alleged conspiracy to overthrow the government of the United States between July 1983 and April 1985. Pierce was one of ten defendants charged with that conspiracy. The trial opened in Fort Smith in February 1988, and on April 7, 1988, the jury acquitted all thirteen remaining defendants on every count. For Pierce the verdict changed nothing in practice; he was already serving the Seattle and Denver sentences.
Pierce and Lane appealed the Denver convictions, and on August 25, 1989, the Tenth Circuit affirmed both in United States v. Lane. The court held that Congress had ample power under the Commerce Clause to make the employment provision of § 245 a federal crime, and that it had not been required to make specific findings for each provision.
The two men also argued that the Seattle racketeering convictions, in which the Denver killing had been charged as a predicate act, barred a second prosecution for the same killing. The court disagreed. There were clearly separate offenses, it wrote: the racketeering charge required proof of a pattern of racketeering activity, while the civil rights charge required proof that the defendants acted because of the victim's religion and because of his employment.
The court found the evidence sufficient against Pierce on every element. It pointed to his attendance at the group's meetings, physical evidence linked to a property he had rented, and statements he made to two people that he had killed the broadcaster. It held that a rational jury could find that he acted because his victim was Jewish, and because of the way the broadcaster used his employment, his radio show, to attack the group's beliefs. It rejected his remaining challenges, among them his claim that he should have been tried separately from Lane.
Pierce served his sentences in the federal prison system for more than two decades. He died in August 2010 at the Allenwood Federal Correctional Complex in Pennsylvania, at 56. His death was attributed to natural causes. He was never tried in any court for murder.
Pierce was never convicted of murder. The Seattle jury convicted him of racketeering offenses without saying whether the Denver killing was among the acts it relied on. The Denver jury's verdict, under the civil rights statute, is the only judicial finding that he took part in the killing, and that verdict rests largely on the testimony of former members who had received reduced sentences, on statements attributed to him and on physical evidence. No state homicide case was ever brought.
The others accused in the Denver case also stand unequally in law. Lane was convicted alongside Pierce, and the two other Denver defendants were acquitted. The group's founder, whom witnesses linked to the killing, died in December 1984 without being tried.
September to October 1983: The Order is formed at a meeting at Metaline Falls, Washington; Pierce is a founding member.
October 1983: Pierce is among four members who carry out the group's first robbery, in Spokane, Washington.
April 1984: Pierce, having pleaded guilty to federal counterfeiting charges in Spokane, fails to appear for sentencing and becomes a fugitive.
June 18, 1984: The radio host is killed in Denver, Colorado.
December 1984: The group's founder dies during a standoff with federal agents on Whidbey Island, Washington.
March 1985: FBI agents take Pierce into custody in Rossville, Georgia.
April 15, 1985: A federal grand jury in Seattle indicts 23 members of The Order under RICO.
December 30, 1985: A jury in the Western District of Washington convicts Pierce of racketeering, racketeering conspiracy and conspiracy to rob an armored car.
February 1986: Pierce is sentenced to 100 years.
1986: Denver's district attorney declines to file homicide charges.
November 1987: A federal jury in Denver convicts Pierce and David Lane of a civil rights violation resulting in death and acquits two co-defendants.
December 1987: Pierce is sentenced to 150 years, with no parole eligibility for at least 50 years.
April 7, 1988: The Fort Smith jury acquits Pierce and twelve other defendants of seditious conspiracy.
July 6, 1988: The Ninth Circuit affirms the Seattle convictions and sentences in United States v. Yarbrough.
August 25, 1989: The Tenth Circuit affirms the Denver convictions in United States v. Lane.
August 2010: Pierce dies at the Allenwood Federal Correctional Complex in Pennsylvania, aged 56.