Brian Rattigan

Victims
1 man killed in Crumlin, Dublin, 2001; manslaughter plea, 2018. Declan Gavin; a December 2009 murder conviction was quashed by the Supreme Court in 2017, and the plea replaced it.
Years active
August 25, 2001
Location
Crumlin and Drimnagh, Dublin; Walkinstown, Dublin
Method
Manslaughter (plea accepted on a murder indictment)
Status
Nine years for manslaughter (January 2019, from October 1, 2018); 17 years for drug offenses (March 2013, from June 2008); drug appeal dismissed October 2018

In the early hours of August 25, 2001, a young man named Declan Gavin died in Crumlin, on the south side of Dublin. He was from Drimnagh, the neighboring district, and he had once been a friend of Brian Rattigan, who lived in Drimnagh too. More than seventeen years later, after two murder trials, a conviction, a life sentence, four appeals and an order for a third trial, Rattigan stood up in the Central Criminal Court and pleaded guilty to his manslaughter. He was sentenced to nine years in January 2019.

The death in Crumlin was the first in what became known as the Crumlin-Drimnagh feud, a conflict between two rival factions of south Dublin criminals that lasted more than ten years. Rattigan led one of the factions. He spent nearly all of that decade in custody, and while he was there the State built against him a second case of its own: in 2013 the Special Criminal Court found that he had directed a drug operation worth about one million euros from inside an Irish prison, the first conviction of its kind in the State. His legal history runs from the Central Criminal Court through the Court of Criminal Appeal, the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court, and it turned on two questions: whether a statute that let a jury hear earlier statements from reluctant witnesses could reach statements made before the statute existed, and how far a trial judge may go in commenting on the defense case before the comment becomes advocacy.

Rattigan lived in Drimnagh, a district of Dublin 12 beside Crumlin. In 2000 the group around him split into two hostile camps. The man who died in Crumlin the following year belonged to the other side of that divide.

August 25, 2001

The Gardaí linked Rattigan to the death by evidence. The investigation depended on witnesses, and several of them were reluctant to help. Some had to be arrested before they would give evidence at all. In 2003 Rattigan was charged with murder.

He did not stand trial for years. He was taken into custody in 2003 and was held from then on for a series of other offenses, and the murder charge brought that year did not come to trial until 2009. Before it did, he went to the High Court to have the prosecution stopped, and when that failed he took the same application to the Supreme Court. Neither court would halt the trial. In the years between, the feud that had started in Crumlin spread across the two districts, and members of both factions died. Those killings were attributed to others, and none of them formed part of any charge against him.

The first trial, February 2009

Rattigan pleaded not guilty to murder at the Central Criminal Court, and the case went before a jury of six men and six women early in 2009. He was 28. The jury deliberated for about eleven hours over four days. On February 16, 2009, it returned to tell the judge that it could not agree on a verdict. The case was put back into the list.

Whether to try him a second time was settled at a meeting in the office of the Director of Public Prosecutions. The Director went ahead.

The second trial, December 2009

The retrial came on in the same court before a different judge at the end of the year. Two of the State's witnesses were uncooperative at trial, and the prosecution relied on a provision that had not existed when those statements were taken: section 16 of the Criminal Justice Act 2006, which allows a jury in defined circumstances to receive a witness's earlier out-of-court statement as evidence of the truth of its contents. The two Garda statements went before the jury under that section.

By the time the jury retired in mid-December, it was down to eleven members, seven men and four women. On December 15 the judge told them that at that stage he could accept only a unanimous verdict. They had deliberated for four hours by that evening and were sent to a hotel for the night. When deliberations ran on, the court accepted a majority verdict. On Thursday, December 17, 2009, after more than eleven hours over three days, the jury found Rattigan guilty of murder by ten votes to one. The judge imposed the sentence the law requires for murder in Ireland, life imprisonment.

The Court of Criminal Appeal

Rattigan's papers reached the Court of Criminal Appeal a week late. On March 2, 2010, the court extended his time, the State raising no objection, and gave him leave to appeal. The appeal was heard over two days beginning on June 20, 2012. Its central ground was section 16: his lawyers argued that the statements of the two reluctant witnesses should never have gone before the jury. In 2013 the Court of Criminal Appeal dismissed the appeal and upheld the conviction. It rejected the argument on the witness statements, and it rejected a second complaint as well: that the trial judge, in his closing remarks, had misdescribed the case the defense was making. In the view of the appeal court he had not.

He did not stop there. Late in 2013 he asked the court to certify that his case raised points of law of exceptional public importance. His lawyers also complained that the trial judge had made unfair and unbalanced remarks in summing up the case. The application was argued before three judges in early 2014, and one of them fell ill before a decision was given, which delayed the outcome. A question was in the end certified for the Supreme Court: whether section 16 of the Criminal Justice Act 2006 applies to statements of evidence made before the Act came into force.

A second conviction, 2013

While the murder appeal was moving through the courts, Rattigan was tried on a second indictment. The charges arose from events of May 2008, when he was already a prisoner, and concerned drugs worth about one million euros in Walkinstown, Dublin 12. He was charged with possession of a controlled drug and with two counts of possession of the drug for sale or supply, all in Walkinstown on May 21, 2008, and with two further counts relating to items held in prison on May 22. He pleaded not guilty.

The case was tried at the Special Criminal Court, the three-judge court that sits without a jury. It went there because the Director of Public Prosecutions directed that it should, on the ground that the ordinary courts were inadequate to deal with it. On February 12, 2013, the court found him guilty of the possession and supply counts. It held that the evidence, read together, amounted to his directing drug dealing from inside the prison, and it found that he was the director of the group behind a deal worth about one million euros. He was cleared of the two counts concerning items held in prison. He was 32. No one had been convicted in the State on such a basis before.

On March 20, 2013, the presiding judge sentenced him to 17 years' imprisonment, backdated to June 2008. The term was to run concurrently with the life sentence he was then serving for murder. It was due to expire in May 2025, and with remission his release date on that sentence fell in November 2019.

The Supreme Court, December 2017

The Supreme Court heard the murder appeal on two grounds: the certified question on section 16, and the complaint about the trial judge's closing remarks to the jury. Five judges sat. On December 12, 2017, they delivered judgment.

On section 16 Rattigan lost. He argued that the procedure touched his right to a fair trial so deeply that it could not be treated as a simple change in the rules of evidence and should not apply to statements taken before 2006. He argued too that the prosecution should not profit from its own delay in bringing him to trial. The majority judgment rejected both arguments. It held that section 16 infringed no constitutional right, that it changed rules of evidence only for trials held after the Act took effect, and that the delay had not made a fair trial impossible.

The second ground was harder, and it decided the case. Trial counsel had described the judge's charge to the jury as a model charge, and the majority found its summary of the law and the facts otherwise flawless. The complaint was confined to a passage at the end, which the defense had asked the trial judge to cure by discharging the jury, an application he refused. In that passage the judge attributed to the defense an argument of unusual coincidence that the defense had not in fact made, and then dealt with it in terms the majority described as "sustained sarcasm." The majority held that a judge must respect the independence of the jury and must not seek, or appear to seek, to influence its verdict by his own views. It concluded that the comments "went further than were desirable," that there was a real possibility the jury had taken them as the judge's personal opinion, and that they might have influenced the jurors in their view of the defense case. The majority went further. The judge, it found, had unintentionally engaged in what could be seen as advocacy for the prosecution. The passage came at the end of what the leading judgment called a "devastating critique" of the defense case, delivered without any mention of a weakness on the prosecution side, and taken as a whole it amounted to an invitation to the jury to reject the defense outright. By three votes to two, the court allowed the appeal and quashed the conviction. The leading judgment was written by one member of the court, and the Chief Justice and a third judge agreed with it.

The two dissenting judges would have dismissed the appeal. The line between permissible and impermissible comment in a charge, the dissent observed, is a narrow one, and in their view the comments "remained within the dividing line of permissible comment," and they could not see how the reference to coincidence made the charge as a whole unsatisfactory.

Rattigan did not leave custody. He was still serving the 17-year drug sentence, and the court adjourned the case into the new year to hear the Director of Public Prosecutions on whether there should be a retrial.

The retrial order, April 2018

The Director sought a retrial. The prosecution's position was that murder is a serious offense, that the Director had genuinely reviewed the case, that a retrial was in the public interest, and that questions of publicity were for the trial judge to manage with the law of contempt behind him. Rattigan opposed it on two grounds: the time that had passed since 2001, and the publicity the case had attracted over seventeen years. His counsel argued that social media had outpaced the law, whose procedures for protecting a trial from prejudice dated back to the 1970s.

The Supreme Court gave its ruling on April 11, 2018. It held that the test is whether a retrial is in the interests of justice. The most common reason for refusing one, that the prosecution is trying to repair a weak case, did not arise, and a retrial should be refused only where there is a clear case that a fair trial cannot be had, for reasons such as delay or prejudicial pretrial publicity. The court found no such case. The Chief Justice delivered the ruling. On the question of social media, a member of the court said that the concern was not a reason not to act, and that it could be met by the directions a trial judge gives when a jury is sworn. The court ordered a retrial and sent the matter back to the Criminal Courts of Justice. Rattigan still denied murder.

The drug appeal

Meanwhile his appeal against the 2013 conviction reached the Court of Appeal. Three judges heard it on July 6, 2018, and reserved judgment. The grounds were eight in all. His counsel argued that the evidence was consistent with a lesser role than control of the drugs, and that knowing what was happening from prison was not the same as directing it; that the drugs had never been tested for purity, so their quantity and value could not be proved; that the Garda evidence explaining drug terms was a novel kind of expertise whose basis had never been established; and that warrants used in the investigation were defective in form. One, the defense said, had been issued by a peace commissioner yet bore the title of a court district and looked like a court warrant, and no notes had been kept of how it was granted; on another the signature could not be read, and the garda who obtained it could not recall which judge had signed it. The prosecution answered that the evidence placed him at the center of the operation and that the trial court was entitled to draw that inference. On the expert evidence, prosecution counsel pointed to the witness's eighteen years in the force, fifteen of them in drugs work, and to his advisory involvement with Europol. The peace commissioner, he said, had signed the disputed warrant with his own name and title, and anyone reading it would know who had issued it.

On October 10, 2018, the Court of Appeal rejected every ground. In a 44-page judgment, it held that the trial court's ruling on one warrant had been open to it, that there was no basis to criticize its ruling on another, that a complaint about an illegible signature on a third could have been settled by a simple inquiry and caused no prejudice, that the expert evidence had been properly admitted, and that street value depends on weight rather than purity. The court said it was satisfied that the trial had been satisfactory and the conviction safe. The 17-year sentence stood.

The new murder trial was due to start in January 2019. It never did. On October 22, 2018, Rattigan was arraigned at the Central Criminal Court on the murder charge. He pleaded not guilty to murder and guilty of manslaughter. Prosecution counsel told the court that the plea was acceptable, and the Director of Public Prosecutions accepted it in place of the murder charge. It was the first time he had admitted the killing in any form. The judge fixed a sentence hearing for December 20.

Sentence, January 2019

The sentence hearing took place in December 2018. The court heard that Rattigan had spent most of his adult life in prison and had been in custody continuously since 2003.

On January 24, 2019, he was sentenced to nine years' imprisonment for manslaughter, backdated to October 1, 2018. He was 38. Without the new sentence he would have been due for release in November 2019 on the drug term; the manslaughter term ran from October 2018 and carried his custody beyond that date.

Disputed and unproven points

Rattigan always denied murder. The only finding against him for the death in Crumlin that stands today is his own plea of guilty to manslaughter, which the State accepted. The murder conviction of December 2009 was quashed and is of no legal effect, and no jury ever reached a lawful verdict of murder that survived appeal.

The other deaths of the Crumlin-Drimnagh feud were not charged against him. The 2013 conviction concerned the possession and supply of drugs; it did not concern any death.

Timeline

2000: Rattigan's group in Dublin divides into two hostile factions.

August 25, 2001: The victim dies in Crumlin, Dublin; the death is the first of the Crumlin-Drimnagh feud.

2003: Rattigan enters continuous custody; a murder charge is brought.

May 21, 2008: Date of the drug offenses charged in Walkinstown, Dublin 12.

February 16, 2009: The first murder jury at the Central Criminal Court cannot agree on a verdict.

December 17, 2009: A second jury convicts him of murder by a majority of ten to one; mandatory life imprisonment.

March 2, 2010: The Court of Criminal Appeal extends his time and grants leave to appeal.

June 20, 2012: The Court of Criminal Appeal hears the appeal on section 16.

February 12, 2013: The Special Criminal Court convicts him of possession of drugs and possession for sale or supply; he is cleared of two counts.

March 20, 2013: Sentenced to 17 years for the drug offenses, backdated to June 2008, concurrent with the life term.

2013: The Court of Criminal Appeal dismisses the murder appeal.

Late 2013 to 2014: He seeks a Supreme Court appeal; a question on section 16 is certified.

December 12, 2017: The Supreme Court, by three to two, allows the appeal and quashes the murder conviction.

April 11, 2018: The Supreme Court orders a retrial.

July 6, 2018: The Court of Appeal hears the drug appeal and reserves judgment.

October 10, 2018: The Court of Appeal dismisses the drug appeal on all grounds.

October 22, 2018: Arraigned on the murder charge, he pleads not guilty to murder and guilty of manslaughter at the Central Criminal Court; the plea is accepted.

December 20, 2018: Sentence hearing at the Central Criminal Court.

January 24, 2019: Sentenced to nine years for manslaughter, backdated to October 1, 2018.