Brian Nichols was 33 and in the middle of a retrial in Atlanta when he escaped custody at the Fulton County Courthouse on the morning of March 11, 2005. By the time he surrendered in Duluth, in suburban Gwinnett County, the next day, four people were dead: the Superior Court judge presiding over his trial, two others at the courthouse, and a man in the Atlanta district of Buckhead that night. He never denied the killings. He told the court he was insane when he committed them.
The case that followed took more than three and a half years to reach a verdict and nearly four to reach a sentence. It ran through two trial judges, a collapse in defense funding, a ruling by the Supreme Court of Georgia, an abandoned jury selection and a six-week trial. On November 7, 2008, a Fulton County jury found him guilty on all 54 counts against him. A month later the same jury spent more than 30 hours trying to decide whether he should die, and told the court it was deadlocked 9-3. Georgia law allowed a death sentence only on a unanimous verdict, so on December 13, 2008, the judge imposed multiple life sentences without parole and hundreds of years more. Nichols remains in the Georgia prison system.
Nichols was raised in Baltimore. He came to the attention of the Fulton County courts in 2004, when he was charged with rape. He was tried in Fulton County Superior Court, and the first trial ended with a hung jury. The State brought the case back, and in March 2005 he was on trial again on the same charge, in the courtroom of the judge who had presided over the first trial.
The retrial was in session on the morning of Friday, March 11, 2005. Before the day's proceedings resumed, Nichols escaped custody inside the courthouse in downtown Atlanta. Three people died there that morning, and a fourth man died in Buckhead that night.
For the next day the escape drew in agencies from across the region: the Fulton County Sheriff's Office, the Atlanta Police Department, the Gwinnett County Police, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, the FBI and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Nichols surrendered in Duluth on Saturday, March 12, about 26 hours after the escape, once a woman he had held hostage there overnight was able to reach the police.
Rowland Barnes lived in College Park, on the southern edge of Atlanta. He had gone to Lebanon Valley College in Pennsylvania. He took his seat on the Fulton County Superior Court bench in 1998. He took part in the charity skits staged by the city's bar. He was presiding over the retrial when he died on March 11, 2005.
Julie Ann Brandau was born in Moncks Corner, South Carolina, and had recently moved to Snellville, east of Atlanta. During trials in the judge's courtroom she baked for the jurors, cookies, brownies and other sweets, and the judge once wrote that every day of every trial she made something special for them. She loved cooking, decorating and gardening, and every Easter she climbed Stone Mountain for the sunrise service. She died in the courtroom that morning.
Hoyt Teasley died the same morning.
David Wilhelm had moved to Atlanta from Virginia about six months earlier. He wrote poems. He died in Buckhead on the night of March 11, 2005.
Nichols spent his first days after the surrender in federal hands. On March 12, 2005, the day he gave himself up, federal prosecutors in Atlanta filed a criminal complaint against him, and he was held on that federal charge while the state and federal authorities worked out who would go first. The answer came quickly. On Monday, March 14, the federal charge was dropped so that he could be transferred to the Fulton County authorities, who were expected to prosecute first. Prosecutors said they would likely decide within 30 days which charges to bring.
The same Monday ended the retrial that had brought him to the courthouse. At the request of his defense lawyer, the rape retrial was declared a mistrial.
The Fulton County grand jury returned its indictment in the first week of May 2005. It ran to 54 counts, among them murder and felony murder, aggravated assault, false imprisonment, kidnapping and hijacking a motor vehicle, and the district attorney announced that his office would seek the death penalty. The defense had already moved to take the case out of his hands. Its motion argued that the district attorney could not be impartial, because the crimes had happened in the building where his office worked and members of his staff had known the dead. The case had been assigned to a senior judge brought in from neighboring DeKalb County, who had not yet ruled on the pending motions.
On Tuesday, May 17, 2005, Nichols came before that judge and, through his lawyer, pleaded not guilty to all 54 counts. Motion hearings were set for the following month in DeKalb County. The defense said it would ask for a gag order and press its effort to bar the Fulton County District Attorney's Office from the prosecution.
Nichols was declared indigent, and his defense was handled by lawyers paid through the state's public defender system, with one of them working without pay. By the end of the summer the shape of that defense was beginning to show. In motions made public on September 1, 2005, his lawyers asked prosecutors to turn over any records bearing on mental or emotional disturbance. A hearing on the motions was set for the following week. No trial date had been fixed.
The case moved slowly from the start. In November 2006 the defense asked the court to dismiss the 54-count indictment, arguing that the county's grand jury had been improperly selected, and to suspend the proceedings until the selection process was corrected. It also renewed a request to delay the trial, then set for January 11, 2007. The prosecution opposed any delay. In the same month the trial judge denied a defense motion to keep cameras out of the courtroom, ruling that broadcast and still cameras could cover the trial, subject to conditions he might add later.
The larger problem was money. In a hearing on who would pay the growing costs of the defense, the trial court ordered Fulton County to pay for transcribing jail telephone conversations made by or to Nichols and for presenting demonstrative evidence in the courtroom in digital form, and ordered the Georgia Public Defender Standards Council to pay the other costs, including attorney, expert and consultant fees. The county appealed. On September 24, 2007, in Fulton County v. State, the Supreme Court of Georgia held unanimously that the county could appeal the order directly, even though the murder case was still pending, and reversed it. The two items, the court held, were unusual expenses not ordinarily incurred in a superior court trial, and no statute expressly authorized a court to charge them to the county.
The ruling did not settle the wider dispute. The public defender council said it had no money left to pay the defense lawyers, and the defense said it could not keep paying the costs of trial with no realistic end in sight. On October 17, 2007, the trial judge granted a defense motion and halted jury selection until the funding was resolved. He ordered the council to show why it should not be held in contempt. The week before, he had ordered Fulton County to cover the fees of one of the defense lawyers. Jurors who had been summoned that fall were left on call.
The halt set the prosecution against the trial judge. In early November 2007 the district attorney asked the Supreme Court of Georgia to remove the judge from the case. The filing contended that he had exceeded his authority in the funding dispute by requiring the State to pay defense fees above a funding cap, and that he had broken the state's statutory scheme for indigent defense by letting a private lawyer replace a staff lawyer who could not take the case for health reasons. The district attorney also asked that the state-paid private lawyers be dismissed and replaced with staff lawyers from the public defender council. The judge, who had recused himself from the contempt hearing he had ordered against the council, answered with a one-page letter to the Supreme Court. He declined to contest the filing, writing that a public dispute with the prosecution would not be appropriate while the trial was pending.
During the same year the defense offered a guilty plea to the murder charges if the State would withdraw the death penalty. Prosecutors refused, and the case went on toward a capital trial.
On January 30, 2008, the senior judge who had handled the case since 2005 recused himself, citing the appearance of bias that followed a magazine article that quoted him. Another Superior Court judge took the case over, and in 2008 jury selection began again at the Fulton County courthouse. The day before the new selection opened, the defense formally entered the plea of not guilty by reason of insanity.
The defense made two last attempts to postpone the trial on the eve of that jury selection. One asked for a new trial location; the other was a pending motion to disqualify the Fulton County prosecutors from the case. The judge rejected both, ruling that neither would delay the start, and promised a trial schedule of six days a week.
The trial opened on September 22, 2008, in the Atlanta Municipal Court building, a short distance from the courthouse where the escape had begun. Nichols pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity. His lawyers did not dispute that he had caused the four deaths. They argued that he had been in the grip of a delusion, and a psychologist testified for the defense that he had been delusional at the time. The prosecution called a psychiatrist in reply and argued that the delusion had been invented to escape the death penalty. Among the State's witnesses were deputies from the sheriff's office and the woman he had held in Duluth, who testified in October 2008.
The trial lasted six weeks. Across the trial and the penalty phase that followed, the two sides put more than 1,000 pieces of evidence before the jury, and more than 140 witnesses testified. The jury deliberated for about 12 hours over two days. On Friday, November 7, 2008, it rejected the insanity defense and found Nichols guilty on all 54 counts.
The penalty phase followed in the same courtroom. Prosecutors asked for death. The defense presented testimony about his mental health and asked for a life sentence. During the penalty phase the defense filed a brief alleging prosecutorial misconduct. Closing arguments were heard on Monday, December 8, 2008.
The jury began deliberating that week. On Thursday, December 11, it told the judge it was "deadlocked 9-3, with nine in favor of death and three in favor of life without parole." The judge did not ask the jurors which way the majority leaned. He told them to try again and sent them back. At the end of the next day, Friday, December 12, the jurors reported that they had "reached a stage where further deliberations will not change an opinion." The judge had them deliberate two more hours, and then declared that they had failed to reach a sentence. By then they had deliberated for more than 30 hours over four days.
Under Georgia law that ended the possibility of a death sentence. The choice passed to the judge, and the only question left was whether the life sentence would carry the possibility of parole. At a hearing on the morning of Saturday, December 13, 2008, Nichols told the court that he was sorry for the pain he had caused. The judge then imposed the maximum sentence on every count, to run consecutively: multiple terms of life without parole and hundreds of years more on more than 50 counts.
The state sentence did not close every door. In the days after the sentencing the Fulton County district attorney said he would meet the United States Attorney in Atlanta to discuss a federal death penalty case over the death in Buckhead, the only one of the four that a federal case could reach. The United States Attorney's office said its prosecutors would weigh the evidence, federal law and Justice Department policy in deciding whether and how to proceed.
The obstacles were plain from the start. A federal capital prosecution required a long approval process within the Justice Department, and federal prosecutors would face higher legal standards than the State had. They would also have to consider whether to ask a jury for death on a single murder when a state jury had been unable to agree on death for four, and any federal jury would be drawn largely from the same Atlanta-area pool. A separate kidnapping case in Gwinnett County also remained open.
Nichols is serving his sentences of life without parole in a Georgia state prison. In March 2025, 20 years after the escape, he remained in custody on the sentences imposed in December 2008, with no possibility of parole.
Nichols's mental state was the only real contest at trial. He admitted the killings, and his defense was that a delusion had left him legally insane; the State's case was that the delusion was invented. The jury rejected the insanity defense on every count.
The case for death divided the jury, and the division was never resolved. Nine jurors favored death and three favored life without parole, and after more than 30 hours of deliberation they reported that further talk would not change any opinion.
2004: Charged with rape in Fulton County, Georgia.
Early 2005: The first rape trial ends with a hung jury; the retrial begins in Fulton County Superior Court.
March 11, 2005: Escapes custody at the Fulton County Courthouse in Atlanta during the retrial; three people die at the courthouse and a fourth in Buckhead that night.
March 12, 2005: Surrenders in Duluth, Gwinnett County; federal prosecutors file a criminal complaint.
March 14, 2005: The federal charge is dropped and he is transferred to Fulton County; the rape retrial is declared a mistrial at the defense's request.
Early May 2005: A Fulton County grand jury returns a 54-count indictment; the district attorney announces he will seek the death penalty.
May 17, 2005: Pleads not guilty to all 54 counts before a senior judge from DeKalb County.
September 1, 2005: Defense motions seeking mental-health records are made public.
November 2006: Defense moves to dismiss the indictment over grand jury selection; cameras are allowed at trial.
September 24, 2007: The Supreme Court of Georgia, in Fulton County v. State, reverses an order making Fulton County pay two kinds of defense costs.
2007: Prosecutors refuse a defense offer of guilty pleas to the murder charges in exchange for withdrawal of the death penalty.
October 17, 2007: Jury selection is halted over defense funding.
Early November 2007: The district attorney asks the Supreme Court of Georgia to remove the trial judge; the judge declines to contest the filing.
January 30, 2008: The first trial judge recuses himself; another Superior Court judge takes over the case.
2008: The judge rejects final defense bids to move the trial and to disqualify the Fulton County prosecutors.
September 22, 2008: Opening statements in Atlanta; Nichols pleads not guilty by reason of insanity.
November 7, 2008: Found guilty on all 54 counts.
December 11, 2008: The jury reports it is deadlocked 9-3 on sentence.
December 12, 2008: The jury reports that further deliberations will not change an opinion; the judge declares it deadlocked.
December 13, 2008: Sentenced to multiple terms of life without parole plus hundreds of years.
December 2008: The Fulton County district attorney seeks talks with the United States Attorney on a federal death penalty case limited to the Buckhead death.
March 2025: Remains in custody in Georgia on the 2008 sentences.