Brian Meehan is the only person whose conviction for the murder of Veronica Guerin has stood. On June 26, 1996, she was killed while waiting in traffic near Clondalkin, on the western edge of Dublin. Three years later, on July 29, 1999, the three judges of the Special Criminal Court found Meehan guilty of her murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment. The court found that he had taken part in the killing as the driver for the man who carried it out. It also convicted him on fourteen drugs and arms-law charges arising from the work of the criminal gang to which, the courts later held, he plainly belonged.
The verdict rested on the word of an accomplice. Meehan denied any part in the murder, at trial and afterward, and his lawyers spent the next seventeen years arguing that the evidence against him could not carry the weight the court had put on it. Two other prosecutions for the same death came apart. A second man convicted of the murder in 1998 had that conviction quashed in 2002, and the man the prosecution described as the head of the gang was acquitted of the murder in 2001 after a trial that depended on the same accomplice. Meehan's own appeal failed in 2006, and an application to have his conviction declared a miscarriage of justice failed in 2016. As of June 2026 he was still serving his life sentence and was due to come before Ireland's Parole Board.
Meehan came from Crumlin, a district on the south side of Dublin, and at the time of his trial he was living in Kimmage, next to it. He was in his early thirties when the case against him was heard. Little of his life before 1996 came out in open court beyond what the prosecution needed to prove the drugs and arms-law charges, and the courts' attention fell on his place in the gang rather than on his background.
That place was central to everything that followed. When the Court of Criminal Appeal reviewed his case in 2006, it described the evidence that Meehan was a member of the gang as "abundant." The gang, the court accepted, imported drugs and arms into Ireland. At his 1999 trial a Garda inspector told the court that the group had imported and distributed drugs worth about £180 million between 1994 and 1996.
Two of the men who had worked inside that operation became the prosecution's most important witnesses. One acted as the gang's money man, carrying payments to suppliers in Amsterdam. The other worked as a courier, delivering to wholesalers and handling cash. Both were themselves convicted and sent to prison on money-laundering, drugs and arms-law charges, both entered the state's witness protection program, and both gave evidence against the men they had worked beside.
The killing took place on Wednesday, June 26, 1996, near Clondalkin. The man who carried out the killing was never tried for it. The prosecution's case was that Meehan had played his part at the direction of the gang.
By the end of 1996 Meehan was in the Netherlands, and the Irish authorities moved to bring him back. On December 9, 1997, judges of the Amsterdam district court approved his extradition to Ireland to face trial for the murder. Meehan contested the ruling. One argument his Dutch lawyer advanced was that the Dutch court should not decide the matter until the Special Criminal Court in Dublin had ruled on a case built on the evidence of one of the accomplice witnesses. The Dutch court rejected that argument, and Meehan was eventually returned to Ireland to stand trial.
While he was fighting extradition, the first trial for the murder went ahead in Dublin. In November 1998 the Special Criminal Court convicted a second man, an associate of Meehan's, of the murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment. The court's finding on his part concerned events after the killing. That conviction rested chiefly on the evidence of the courier who had become a protected witness.
Meehan's trial opened before the Special Criminal Court on Wednesday, June 2, 1999. He faced seventeen charges in all, among them the murder count and a series of drugs and arms-law charges, and he pleaded not guilty to every one of them. That same morning he had failed in an attempt to stop the trial from going ahead; his counsel had accused the state of interfering with witnesses.
The prosecution set out its case on the first day. It alleged that Meehan had been the driver on the day of the killing, and that he had earlier offered to carry out the killing himself, only to be told that someone else had been chosen.
The heart of the case was accomplice evidence. The money man, the second protected witness, gave the account on which the conviction would turn. He told the court that he had been in Naas on the day of the murder, that he had been in contact with Meehan throughout that day, and that he had witnessed the killing.
The defense attacked the reliability of both men. Its position was that the case rested on the suspect evidence of a group of accomplices who had every reason to tell the state what it wanted to hear. On July 14, near the end of the evidence, Meehan's counsel applied again to have the trial stopped, arguing that the court should not take the risk of continuing on the evidence of protected witnesses. The court let the trial run to its end. In all it lasted thirty-one days.
The three judges gave their decision on Thursday, July 29, 1999. They did not accept everything the prosecution had offered. The court rejected the evidence of the courier as unreliable. It accepted the evidence of the money man, and that evidence, together with the material the court treated as supporting it, placed Meehan at the scene in the role the prosecution had described.
The court found Meehan guilty of murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment. It also found him guilty on fourteen drugs and arms-law charges and passed sentences ranging from five to twenty years on those counts. All the sentences were to run concurrently. The court did not set a minimum number of years for the life sentence. Meehan maintained that he had no part in the killing.
He lodged an appeal against all his convictions in November 1999.
Over the next three years the other prosecutions for the murder ended in ways that sharpened the questions about Meehan's own.
On Thursday, March 15, 2001, the Special Criminal Court gave its verdict in the trial of the man the prosecution named as the head of the gang. The court acquitted him of the murder and of four charges under the arms law. It convicted him on eleven counts of importing and possessing drugs for supply and sentenced him to twenty-eight years, a sentence later reduced to twenty years on appeal. On the murder charge, the presiding judge said the court had grave suspicions about the defendant's complicity but was not persuaded beyond reasonable doubt. The key evidence on that count came from the same money man whose account had convicted Meehan. The court in 2001 found him a self-serving liar whose evidence could not be relied on without corroboration, and it found no corroboration. It noted too that parts of his account conflicted with what other eyewitnesses had said.
A year later the accomplice evidence failed again. On Friday, March 22, 2002, the Court of Criminal Appeal quashed the 1998 murder conviction of Meehan's associate and set aside his life sentence. The three appeal judges were not satisfied that the trial court could have ruled out the courier's motives to lie, and they held that his evidence could not be relied on beyond reasonable doubt. The associate was not released; he was returned to custody to serve a separate sentence imposed on him for an unrelated offense.
That left Meehan as the only person still serving a sentence for the murder, with his own appeal outstanding and resting on the same class of witness.
The Court of Criminal Appeal heard Meehan's appeal over two days and delivered its judgment on Monday, July 24, 2006. The judgment ran to sixty-two pages, and the three judges dismissed the appeal against every one of his convictions.
The central argument for the defense was that the money man's evidence had not been corroborated in the way Irish law requires, and that the material the trial court had treated as corroboration should not have been admitted or relied on for that purpose. The appeal court rejected both points. It held that corroboration was not itself a precondition of a conviction on accomplice evidence; what the law required was that the trial court warn itself of the danger of convicting without it. The Special Criminal Court had given itself the required warnings about suspect witnesses.
The court went further. It held that the trial judges had been entitled to treat the supporting material as corroboration of the accomplice's account. That material could not confirm every detail of his evidence beyond reasonable doubt, the court said, but it was "an independent body of strong supporting evidence tending to connect" Meehan with the killing in many critical respects. It also described the pattern of contact among the accomplice, the alleged head of the gang and Meehan on the day of the murder as "striking." On the gang itself, the court found abundant evidence that Meehan was a member. On the drugs and arms-law charges it was satisfied that the evidence had been adequate to convict.
The court addressed the witness protection program directly. Evidence from a witness in the program, it said, is not to be discounted automatically because of that status. The difference between Meehan's case and the two that had collapsed lay in the supporting evidence: the 2001 court had found none for the money man's account of the gang leader's role, while the courts in Meehan's case found strong support for his account of Meehan's role.
Meehan did not stop there. He later applied to have his conviction declared a miscarriage of justice on the ground of a new or newly discovered fact. The fact he relied on had emerged during the 2001 trial of the alleged head of the gang.
It concerned a woman who told both trials that she had seen a man matching the money man's description near the courthouse in Naas on the day of the murder. Her account supported his evidence that he had been there. At the 2001 trial it came out that a few months after the killing she had taken part in an identification parade and had failed to pick him out. Meehan's lawyers argued that this was critical evidence, that it had not been disclosed to them before his own trial, and that it was a new fact for the purposes of the application.
The Director of Public Prosecutions moved to strike the application out. On Monday, November 26, 2012, the Court of Criminal Appeal heard the state's argument that there were no newly discovered facts to justify the case going forward and that the proceedings were an abuse of process, and it reserved judgment.
The state lost that round. On Thursday, January 23, 2014, the three judges of the Court of Criminal Appeal refused the Director's application. The Director had asked the court to strike the case out, or at least to decide a set of preliminary legal issues first, including whether the application was an abuse of process. The court found that those preliminary issues covered nearly every point in dispute and went to the core of Meehan's case, so that deciding them in advance would amount to hearing and determining the application on its merits by another route. The application went forward to a full hearing.
That hearing took place over two days, Thursday and Friday, November 19 and 20, 2015, before three judges. The defense put the identification parade at the center of its case. Its position was that the parade had been unknown to both sides at Meehan's trial: under the disclosure practice of the time, the parties inspected the investigation papers at a Garda station, and if anyone had seen the parade record there, its significance had been missed by everyone, the trial judges included. The defense argued that the prosecution had been obliged to disclose the material, that the timing of the application was beside the point, and that several eyewitnesses to the killing had not been disclosed to Meehan before his trial and had surfaced only at the 2001 trial.
The Director's lawyers answered that there was nothing new in any of it. All the statements, along with a list of witnesses, had been made available to the defense before the trial, and copies had been made. If the defense had failed to use the parade evidence, that might have been a poor decision, but it was not a ground for this kind of application, and the point could have been raised at the 2006 appeal. They argued too that Meehan could not rely on transcripts from the 2001 trial, and that the identification witness had not been the only support for the conviction, which also rested on independent evidence of contact between Meehan and the alleged head of the gang and on other circumstantial evidence. The court reserved judgment.
On Monday, April 18, 2016, the Court of Appeal, which had by then taken over the criminal appeals of the old Court of Criminal Appeal, dismissed the application. The three judges held that no new or newly discovered fact had been established. Every fact Meehan's lawyers relied on, the court found, had been known at the time of his earlier appeal. The material had been available by the 2001 trial at the latest, and the arguments built on it had been formulated in detail by 2003, set aside, and then revived years later as though they were new. No reasonable explanation had been given for that course. The court held that the choices Meehan had made about how to run his appeal had consequences, and that the application amounted to an abuse of process. It also ruled that reliance on the transcript of the 2001 trial was not permissible in his case, describing the circumstances in which such material could be used as exceptional. The court noted that it had access to records showing that the money man had taken part in an identification parade.
The court also found that the character of the application had shifted as it went along. It had begun as a complaint that material had been withheld and had turned into a criticism of the lawyers who had represented Meehan before. Meehan's own account was that his former legal team had dropped a motion to admit evidence from the transcripts of the 2001 trial against his instructions; no affidavit was put before the court from the solicitor who had acted for him on the appeal. The court was satisfied that the material had been disclosed to Meehan and his lawyers and that they had fully understood its significance by the time the grounds of his appeal were drawn up.
Meehan was returned to custody the same day.
Meehan served most of his sentence in one prison before he was moved, in 2019, to a different prison in Ireland as part of a pre-release program. In June 2021, twenty-five years after the murder, he was seeking a transfer to an open prison, a move that would make him eligible for day release. The move went ahead. By September 2022 he had spent more than a year in an open prison in Ireland and had been allowed out on day release, but the Parole Board had not given him a release date.
By June 2026 he had served twenty-seven years and was approaching eligibility for parole. As of June 26, 2026, the thirtieth anniversary of the murder, Meehan was still serving his life sentence and was due to appear before the Parole Board. He had not admitted any role in the killing.
Meehan was tried in a court without a jury. The Special Criminal Court is provided for by the Offences Against the State Act 1939, and the court that heard his case was established by government order in 1972. It sits in Dublin. Each case is heard by three judges, drawn by the government from a panel of judges of the High Court, the Circuit Court and the District Court, and the three hear the evidence and decide guilt together.
Certain listed offenses, known as scheduled offenses, go to the court as a matter of course unless the Director of Public Prosecutions directs otherwise. Other offenses, murder among them, are sent there when the Director certifies that the ordinary courts are inadequate to secure the effective administration of justice and the preservation of public peace and order, for example where there is a risk that a jury could be intimidated. All three murder trials arising from the 1996 killing were heard in this court.
Convictions and sentences from the Special Criminal Court are appealed. In 1999 the route lay to the Court of Criminal Appeal, which heard Meehan's appeal in 2006; that court's criminal work later passed to the Court of Appeal, which decided his miscarriage-of-justice application in 2016.
Meehan has always denied taking part in the murder. His conviction rests on the evidence of an accomplice who was himself convicted of serious offenses and who gave evidence under the protection of the state, and the same witness's account was rejected as uncorroborated when the alleged head of the gang was tried in 2001. The appeal court in 2006 found that, in Meehan's case, independent evidence supported that witness in critical respects, and the Court of Appeal in 2016 found no new fact that undermined the verdict. The conviction is final.
The man who carried out the killing was never tried for the murder. The associate convicted in 1998 had his conviction quashed in 2002, and the alleged head of the gang was acquitted of the murder in 2001. In law, Meehan is the only person convicted of the murder whose conviction stands.
June 26, 1996: The murder near Clondalkin, Dublin.
December 9, 1997: The Amsterdam district court approves Meehan's extradition to Ireland.
November 1998: The Special Criminal Court convicts an associate of Meehan's of the murder and jails him for life.
June 2, 1999: Meehan's trial opens before the Special Criminal Court; he pleads not guilty to all seventeen charges.
July 14, 1999: The court refuses to halt the trial on the defense application over protected witnesses.
July 29, 1999: Convicted of murder and on fourteen drugs and arms-law charges; sentenced to life imprisonment with concurrent terms of five to twenty years.
November 1999: Meehan lodges his appeal.
March 15, 2001: The gang's leader is acquitted of the murder and convicted on drugs charges.
March 22, 2002: The Court of Criminal Appeal quashes the associate's 1998 murder conviction.
July 24, 2006: The Court of Criminal Appeal dismisses Meehan's appeal against all convictions.
November 26, 2012: The Court of Criminal Appeal reserves judgment on the state's bid to strike out his miscarriage-of-justice application.
January 23, 2014: The Court of Criminal Appeal refuses the state's bid to strike out the application.
November 19 and 20, 2015: Full hearing of the application.
April 18, 2016: The Court of Appeal dismisses the application as an abuse of process.
2019: Moved to another prison in Ireland in a pre-release program.
June 2021: Seeking transfer to an open prison.
September 2022: In an open prison with day release; no release date set by the Parole Board.
June 26, 2026: Still serving his life sentence and due to come before the Parole Board.