Rob Andrew died in Oklahoma City on the evening of November 20, 2001, in the week of Thanksgiving. He was separated from his wife, Brenda, and he had come that evening to collect their two children for the holiday. Within days Brenda Andrew had left the country with the children and with James Pavatt, a man from their church with whom she was having an affair. In February 2002 the couple came back across the border and were arrested.
Pavatt was tried first and sentenced to death. In the summer of 2004 an Oklahoma County jury convicted Brenda Andrew of First-Degree (malice) Murder and Conspiracy to Commit First Degree Murder, on the state's theory that she and Pavatt had planned the killing together to collect an $800,000 life insurance policy. The jury chose death. She became the only woman on Oklahoma's death row, and as of November 2026 she remains there.
The case outlived its notoriety because of the way it was tried. Alongside the evidence of the plot, the jury heard a long run of testimony about her past relationships, her appearance and her conduct as a wife and mother. Oklahoma's highest criminal court agreed that much of it was irrelevant but held the error harmless, and federal judges divided over that conclusion for years. In January 2025 the U.S. Supreme Court held that a federal appeals court had applied the wrong law and sent the case back. On remand she lost again, and in the fall of 2026 her lawyers returned to the Supreme Court. Pavatt, convicted in his own trial, was executed on November 12, 2026.
Brenda Evers grew up in Enid, in northern Oklahoma. She married at 21. Her husband's work took the couple to Texas for a time before they came back to Oklahoma, where she stayed at home with their two children and taught Sunday school. She had no criminal record.
By 2001 the Andrews were attending a church in Oklahoma City where they knew Pavatt. He and Brenda Andrew taught a Sunday school class together, and the two began an affair. Pavatt also sold life insurance, and he helped her husband set up a Prudential policy on his own life worth about $800,000. Her husband moved out in late September 2001, and she filed for divorce soon afterward. Control of that policy became one of the points of conflict between them.
What happened over the next two months was reconstructed at trial. Pavatt's adult daughter testified that in late October her father told her Brenda Andrew had asked him to kill her husband. Around the same time someone tampered with the husband's car. He found the damage before he came to any harm, and he went to the police more than once, telling officers he believed someone was trying to kill him for the insurance. The day after the damage, his wife remarked that she had read about it in the newspaper; the state appeals court later noted that no newspaper had carried the story. He asked about taking her off the policy as beneficiary, and he told Pavatt's supervisor at the insurance company that he feared Pavatt and his wife were trying to kill him.
The state also showed that in the months before his death the couple had tried to move ownership of the policy to her without his knowledge, on a change-of-ownership form that carried a forged signature and was backdated to March 2001. Several witnesses testified that she had said she hated her husband or wished he were dead, the last time on the night before he died.
He died that evening in Oklahoma City. Brenda Andrew was injured as well. She called 911 and told police that two masked men had come in and were responsible for both her husband's death and her own injury. Experts for the state later testified that her injury had been staged to make her look like a second victim, and a defense expert agreed on that point. Witnesses described her as calm, even flat, in the hours that followed, and the state appeals court later held that her demeanor was admissible as evidence of consciousness of guilt.
Pavatt's daughter testified that the couple then asked her to help prepare a document permitting the children to travel abroad, again bearing a forged signature of the dead man, and to move money out of his bank account so that she could wire it to them once they had gone. Before the funeral, Brenda Andrew, Pavatt and the children crossed into Mexico. Oklahoma City police issued warrants when neither of them appeared at the funeral, and a federal unlawful-flight warrant followed. In late February 2002 the couple crossed back into the United States at Hidalgo, Texas, where U.S. Customs agents arrested them.
While she awaited trial in the Oklahoma County jail, Brenda Andrew came into contact with a federal prisoner who later testified against her. The prisoner said Andrew had told her that she and Pavatt killed her husband for the money, the children and each other, and that Pavatt had injured her on purpose to make her look like a victim.
Pavatt was tried separately. In 2003 an Oklahoma County jury convicted him of first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit first-degree murder, and he was sentenced to death.
Brenda Andrew's trial opened in Oklahoma County District Court in June 2004 and ran into July. The prosecution presented the case as a conspiracy: two people who wanted the dead man's money and wanted to be together, and who were equally guilty whoever did the killing. Its evidence ran through the policy and the forged ownership form, the damage to his car, her statements about her husband, the injury its experts called staged, physical evidence that tied the couple to the killing, her demeanor afterward and the flight to Mexico. The defense answered that Pavatt had acted alone, to stop the Andrews from reconciling.
A second strand of the state's case became the subject of nearly two decades of appeals. The prosecution put before the jury a large body of evidence about her sexual history, her clothing and appearance, and her character as a wife and mother, much of which the state later conceded was irrelevant, and it returned to those themes in its opening statement and its closing argument. The defense asked the trial court to instruct jurors not to consider evidence of other misconduct, and the court refused.
The jury convicted her on both counts in July 2004 and returned a verdict of death. It found two aggravating circumstances: that the murder was committed for remuneration or the promise of remuneration, and that it was especially atrocious or cruel. It did not find that she posed a continuing threat to society. In the penalty phase the defense had presented her as a devoted mother, and the state disputed that picture. On September 22, 2004, the district court formally imposed death for the murder, and 10 years and a $5,000 fine for the conspiracy.
On June 21, 2007, the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed both convictions and the death sentence in Andrew v. State, 2007 OK CR 23. It held that the evidence of her earlier affairs was relevant to motive and intent, and that her demeanor showed consciousness of guilt. Elsewhere it found error and called it harmless. Some hearsay should not have come in, two defense witnesses had been wrongly kept off the stand, the court could find little relevance in much of the remaining evidence about her clothing and conduct, and the limiting instruction should have been given. The court also rejected a new-trial claim based on the jailhouse witness's later sentence reduction. Two of the five judges disagreed in part: one would have ordered a new trial, and the other would have set aside the death sentence.
Federal review turned on a narrow question. Under the federal habeas statute, a federal court could grant relief only if the Oklahoma decision was contrary to, or an unreasonable application of, clearly established law as set out by the U.S. Supreme Court. Her petition, filed in the Western District of Oklahoma in 2008, was denied in 2015. In March 2023 a divided panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit affirmed. She had relied on a passage in the Supreme Court's 1991 decision in Payne v. Tennessee stating that the Due Process Clause provides a remedy when evidence is so unduly prejudicial that it renders a trial fundamentally unfair. The majority held that the passage was not a holding of the Court, so there was no clearly established law for the Oklahoma court to have misapplied. One judge dissented.
On January 21, 2025, in Andrew v. White, 604 U.S. 86, the Supreme Court granted her petition and, in an unsigned per curiam opinion, vacated the Tenth Circuit's judgment and remanded the case. The Court held that the Payne statement was a holding, and that when the Oklahoma court ruled, clearly established law provided that the Due Process Clause forbids the introduction of evidence so unduly prejudicial as to render a criminal trial fundamentally unfair. The Tenth Circuit had therefore erred in refusing to ask whether the state court unreasonably applied that principle. The Court did not decide whether she should win. It directed the appeals court to consider, separately for the guilt and sentencing phases, whether a fair-minded jurist could disagree that the evidence made her trial fundamentally unfair, weighing the relevance of the evidence, the prejudice she suffered and any instructions that might have limited it. One justice concurred in the judgment, and two dissented.
On remand she lost again. On January 13, 2026, in Andrew v. Tinsley, a Tenth Circuit panel affirmed the denial of relief. It assumed, without deciding, that her earlier affairs and the clothing from her luggage had no proper bearing on whether she plotted the killing, and weighed that evidence against what it held was overwhelming properly admitted evidence of guilt. It concluded that the stereotyping she challenged did not coincide with the central question before the jury, whether she had conspired with Pavatt, and that the challenged evidence did not undercut either aggravating circumstance. In August 2026 the court denied rehearing, with one judge dissenting.
On September 25, 2026, she filed a second petition for certiorari, Andrew v. Fisher, No. 26-5711. It asks whether a federal court judging the fairness of a capital trial may review the same record the state court reviewed, and whether prejudice from evidence and argument grounded in sex-based stereotyping must be measured against the whole trial record and, for the sentence, by its effect on the jury's choice between life and death. As of November 2026 the petition has been distributed for the justices' conference of December 4, 2026, and no execution date has been set for her.
Brenda Andrew has never admitted taking part in her husband's death. Her defense at trial was that Pavatt acted alone, and Pavatt later admitted the killing and maintained that she had not been involved. At a clemency hearing in October 2026 he gave a different account, denying that he had carried out the killing and saying she had manipulated him. No court has tested that last account, which conflicts with both of his earlier positions.
The testimony that she confessed in jail came from a federal prisoner whose own sentence was later reduced. The Oklahoma court considered the reduction and held that it would not likely have changed the verdict.
The central legal question remains open. Two judges of the state appeals court, the dissenting federal appeals judge in 2023 and the judge who dissented from the 2026 rehearing denial concluded that the evidence about her sex life, clothing and parenting was improper enough to matter, at least to her sentence. Every majority that has ruled on the merits has held that the evidence of guilt made the errors harmless or the trial fair. The Supreme Court decided only which legal standard applied, not the result.
2001 (by fall): Brenda Andrew and James Pavatt, who teach a Sunday school class together, are having an affair; Pavatt has helped set up an $800,000 life insurance policy on her husband.
Late September 2001: Her husband moves out; Brenda Andrew files for divorce soon after.
Late October 2001: His car is tampered with; he reports it to police.
November 20, 2001: Her husband dies in Oklahoma City.
Late November 2001: Brenda Andrew, Pavatt and the two children leave for Mexico before the funeral.
Late February 2002: Both are arrested by U.S. Customs agents in Hidalgo, Texas.
2003: Pavatt is convicted in Oklahoma County and sentenced to death.
July 2004: She is convicted of First-Degree (malice) Murder and Conspiracy to Commit First Degree Murder; the jury returns a death verdict.
September 22, 2004: Formal sentence of death, plus 10 years and a $5,000 fine.
June 21, 2007: The Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals affirms, two judges dissenting in part.
2008: Federal habeas petition filed in the Western District of Oklahoma.
2015: The district court denies relief.
March 2023: A divided Tenth Circuit panel affirms the denial of habeas relief.
January 21, 2025: Andrew v. White; the Supreme Court vacates and remands.
January 13, 2026: Andrew v. Tinsley; the Tenth Circuit affirms again on remand.
August 2026: Rehearing denied, one judge dissenting.
September 25, 2026: Second certiorari petition, No. 26-5711.
November 12, 2026: Pavatt is executed in McAlester, Oklahoma.
As of November 2026: Her petition is distributed for the Supreme Court conference of December 4, 2026; no execution date is set.