On the night of April 15, 2021, eight people were killed at the FedEx Ground facility in Indianapolis. Five women and three men died, and four of them belonged to the city's Sikh community. Several more were wounded, five of them seriously enough to be taken to hospitals. Police and the FBI attributed the killings to Brandon Scott Hole, a 19-year-old from Indianapolis who had worked at the same facility for a few months the year before. He died by suicide inside the building before officers entered it. He was never charged with anything, and there was never a trial.
Everything known about why comes from an investigation, not a court. On July 28, 2021, after three months of work, the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department, the FBI and the Acting United States Attorney for the Southern District of Indiana announced that Hole had acted alone and that no one else had known what he meant to do. They found no sign that he had been driven by bias against the Sikh community or any other group, a finding the Sikh Coalition would not accept. And a year before the killings, police had taken an arm from him in a matter that no judge ever heard.
That matter began in March 2020, when Indianapolis police officers placed Hole, then 18, on an immediate temporary mental health detention hold. He was taken to a hospital for evaluation and released within hours, with no medication prescribed. Officers took a firearm from the family residence, and it was never returned. The case came to the FBI, and agents interviewed Hole in April 2020. They found no criminal violation and did not identify him as holding a racially motivated violent extremist ideology. The inquiry went no further.
Indiana's red flag statute calls for a case before a judge once police have taken firearms from a person without a warrant. No petition was ever filed in Hole's case. The Marion County Prosecutor's Office treated the matter as resolved because the firearm had been surrendered under an agreement that it would not come back, and no judge ever ruled on whether Hole was dangerous within the meaning of the law.
In August 2020 Hole went to work at the FedEx Ground facility, the same building where the killings would take place eight months later. The job did not last. He stopped coming in, and in October 2020 the company ended his employment after he failed to return. Police found no recorded dispute with a supervisor or a co-worker, and no animosity on his part toward the company. He had simply stopped showing up.
On April 15, 2021, he returned. Eight people were killed. Five wounded people were taken to hospitals that night, one of them in critical condition, and two others were treated at the scene and released. Hole died by suicide inside the building before officers reached him.
The names of the dead were released the next day.
Matthew R. Alexander was remembered as a warm and generous man who loved to travel and loved sports. He had played baseball in high school in Avon, the suburb west of Indianapolis where he grew up and where he had recently settled again.
Samaria Blackwell loved life and wanted to spend it helping other people, and she hoped one day to become a police officer. Those closest to her knew her by the nickname "Stitches."
Karli Smith was remembered as funny, kind-hearted and devoted to her family. She loved softball and was saving to buy a car.
Amarjeet Johal was remembered as a mother, grandmother and sister who put family, friends and community first, who cooked for others and made people feel welcome, and who got up early to see her grandchildren off to school.
Jasvinder Kaur was remembered as a charming woman.
Jaswinder Singh was known for his warmth and his big smile. He did not need to work, but he liked being among people, and he was cheerful to everyone around him.
Amarjit Sekhon was a hard worker who rarely sat still. She had recently moved from Ohio to Indianapolis to be closer to her family.
John "Steve" Weisert went by his middle name. He loved trivia, had a goofy sense of humor and gave a great deal of his time to volunteer work in his community.
The Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department led the investigation, with the FBI's Indianapolis field office and other federal agencies working beside it. Hole was identified within hours, and on April 16 the FBI disclosed its 2020 contact with him. Through the spring and early summer investigators conducted more than 120 interviews and worked through more than 150 items of evidence, and the FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit was asked to assess his motive.
The three agencies announced their conclusions together on July 28, 2021. Hole had acted alone, they said, and he had not shared his plans with family or friends. Investigators found that he had struggled with mental health stressors throughout his life without ever being diagnosed with a mental illness, and that in the months before April 2021 he had thought about suicide almost daily. The Acting U.S. Attorney described the case as a murder and suicide made worse by those personal problems. In the Behavioral Analysis Unit's assessment, as the agencies presented it, Hole viewed the attack as "suicidal murder," believed it would demonstrate his masculinity and capability, and wanted to experience killing; it found no sign that he acted to address injustices, out of bias or to advance an ideology. The agencies acknowledged that three months of work had not uncovered the specific reason, which only Hole had known, and the investigation was closed.
Hole was never charged or tried, and every finding about him comes from police, the FBI and federal prosecutors rather than from a court. Their conclusion that he acted alone has not been challenged.
Their conclusion about bias has been. The Sikh Coalition, a national civil rights organization, said it was disappointed that the agencies had not explained in more detail how they ruled bias out, and argued that bias might have played a part alongside the factors they named.
The red flag question is also unresolved. No court ever decided whether Hole's case should have gone before a judge in 2020, or whether a judge, on the record that existed then, would have found him dangerous.
March 3, 2020: Indianapolis police place Hole on an immediate temporary mental health detention hold and take an arm from the family residence; it is never returned.
April 2020: FBI agents interview Hole and find no criminal violation and no racially motivated extremist ideology.
August 2020: He begins work at the FedEx Ground facility in Indianapolis.
October 2020: His employment ends after he fails to return to work.
April 15, 2021: Eight people are killed and several wounded at the facility; Hole dies by suicide there before officers enter.
April 16, 2021: Police identify Hole and release the names of the eight who died; the FBI discloses its 2020 contact with him.
July 28, 2021: Police, the FBI and the Acting U.S. Attorney announce that Hole acted alone, with no bias motive found, and close the investigation.