On the morning of Tuesday, February 12, 2008, a 14-year-old eighth grader named Brandon McInerney killed a classmate in Oxnard, California. The boy he killed died within two days. Oxnard police took McInerney into custody the same morning, and within days the Ventura County District Attorney had done something California law had allowed only since 2000: filed a charge of premeditated murder against a 14-year-old in adult court, with a hate-crime allegation attached.
The case took almost four years to resolve, and it never reached a verdict. A jury that heard eight weeks of testimony in the summer of 2011 deadlocked, seven to five, over whether McInerney had committed murder or voluntary manslaughter. Prosecutors dropped the hate-crime allegation and prepared to try him again. On the day the retrial was to begin, November 21, 2011, he pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, voluntary manslaughter and a sentencing-enhancement count. On December 19, 2011, at 17, he was sentenced to 21 years in state prison, with no credit for the nearly four years he had already spent in custody.
McInerney and the boy he killed were in the same eighth-grade class in Oxnard, a city on the coast of Ventura County, northwest of Los Angeles. Officers detained McInerney the same morning. In the first reports he was a 14-year-old classmate booked for investigation of attempted murder; his name became public only when charges were filed. Reports differ on whether the victim died on February 13 or February 14.
Classmates told Oxnard police of a running feud between the two boys and of a threat McInerney was said to have made the day before. Those accounts, untested at the time, became the outline of the case prosecutors would later present.
California's Proposition 21, approved by voters in 2000, gave district attorneys the power to file certain felony charges against juveniles as young as 14 directly in adult court, without a juvenile-court hearing on fitness. Ventura County prosecutors used it. Within days of the death they charged McInerney in Ventura County Superior Court with premeditated murder, with a hate-crime enhancement and a further sentencing enhancement. He had no juvenile record. As filed, the charges carried 25 years to life for the murder, up to 25 more years for that enhancement and one to three years for the hate-crime enhancement.
His public defender challenged the adult prosecution itself. The motion argued that an adult conviction would bring a mandatory sentence of 51 years to life, imposed without any weighing of the boy who received it, in breach of the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment. In late July 2008 a Ventura County Superior Court judge denied the motion to send the case to juvenile court and held that Proposition 21 was constitutional. The case stayed in adult court.
The preliminary hearing came in July 2009, when McInerney was 15, and lasted almost three days. Witnesses testified about the relationship between the two boys and about threats McInerney was said to have made before the killing. Prosecutors alleged that he held white-supremacist views and that those beliefs, together with hostility toward the victim, supplied the motive. The defense questioned witnesses about the victim's conduct toward McInerney, laying the ground for an argument of provocation.
At the close of the hearing, a Ventura County Superior Court judge found probable cause to try McInerney for premeditated murder, with the hate-crime allegation and a lying-in-wait special circumstance. With the special circumstance in place, his exposure rose to 53 years to life.
A plea offer was already on the table. On July 8, 2009, prosecutors had offered to let McInerney plead guilty to first-degree murder for a term of 25 years to life, with the hate-crime enhancement included. He did not accept it, and he pleaded not guilty to murder and the hate-crime allegation.
The killing had drawn national attention, and the defense won a change of venue out of Ventura County on the ground of pretrial publicity. The trial went to the courthouse in Chatsworth, in the San Fernando Valley in Los Angeles County, with the Ventura County District Attorney's office still prosecuting. Reports differ on whether the court sitting there was Los Angeles County Superior Court or Ventura County Superior Court. McInerney had turned 17 by the time the trial opened in July 2011.
The charge before the jury was first-degree murder, and conviction with the allegations would have meant at least 53 years to life. The defense did not dispute that McInerney had caused the death. Its case was about the degree of his guilt. His lawyers argued for voluntary manslaughter, a killing in the heat of passion after provocation, which would have kept a life sentence off the table and carried about 20 years.
The trial ran for eight weeks of testimony and heard nearly 100 witnesses. The jury began deliberating in late August 2011, reported itself deadlocked after several days, was sent back, and still could not agree.
On Thursday, September 1, 2011, the judge declared a mistrial. Polled in court, the jurors split seven to five: seven for voluntary manslaughter and five for murder. The question the case had turned on from the beginning, whether this was a planned murder or a killing in the heat of passion, had been left unanswered by the only tribunal empowered to answer it. The next day the Ventura County District Attorney's office announced that it would retry him.
On October 5, 2011, prosecutors told the Ventura County Superior Court that McInerney would be tried again as an adult for first-degree murder, with the lying-in-wait allegation still in place. The hate-crime allegation was gone. The retrial was set to begin on Monday, November 21, 2011, and on that morning a plea agreement was reached.
That afternoon McInerney, 17, pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, voluntary manslaughter and a sentencing-enhancement count. Under the agreement the murder conviction stood but was stayed, and the sentence rested on the other two counts: 11 years for voluntary manslaughter, the highest term California law allows for that offense, and 10 years for the enhancement count, a total of 21 years. Because he had pleaded guilty to murder, he was not eligible for credit for the time he had already served or for good-behavior credit, so the nearly four years he had spent in custody since February 2008 would not count against the 21. The agreement also ended the prospect of a second trial that could have ended in a life sentence.
On Monday, December 19, 2011, McInerney was sentenced to 21 years in state prison under the terms of the plea agreement. He did not address the court. His release date was then projected for shortly before his 39th birthday. As of his sentencing in December 2011, he was serving a determinate 21-year term in California custody.
The motive was never decided by a court. The hate-crime allegation was charged in 2008, went before the first jury, which reached no verdict on any charge, and was dropped before the retrial was due to begin; McInerney's plea did not include it. The killing therefore stands in law as second-degree murder and voluntary manslaughter, with no hate-crime finding.
The degree of his guilt was also never fixed by a verdict. The first jury divided over murder and manslaughter, and the plea resolved that division by including both offenses, with the murder conviction stayed. The defense's account of provocation was put to the jury but was neither accepted nor rejected by a verdict.
February 12, 2008: A classmate is fatally wounded in Oxnard, California; Brandon McInerney, 14, is detained the same morning.
February 13 or 14, 2008: The victim dies (reports differ on the date).
February 2008: Ventura County prosecutors charge McInerney as an adult with premeditated murder, with hate-crime and further enhancements.
July 2008: A Ventura County Superior Court judge denies a motion to move the case to juvenile court and rules Proposition 21 constitutional.
July 8, 2009: Prosecutors offer a plea to first-degree murder for 25 years to life.
July 2009: After a preliminary hearing of almost three days, a judge orders McInerney to stand trial for premeditated murder with hate-crime and lying-in-wait allegations.
July 5, 2011: Opening statements are set in the trial, moved to Chatsworth, Los Angeles County.
August 26, 2011: The jury begins deliberating after eight weeks of testimony.
September 1, 2011: A mistrial is declared; the jury splits seven to five, voluntary manslaughter to murder.
October 5, 2011: Prosecutors drop the hate-crime allegation and set a retrial for November 21.
November 21, 2011: McInerney pleads guilty to second-degree murder, voluntary manslaughter and a sentencing-enhancement count.
December 19, 2011: He is sentenced to 21 years in state prison, with no credit for time served.