Nancy Rentz Cooper died in Cary, North Carolina, on July 12, 2008, after she had decided to leave her marriage and take her two young daughters home to Canada. Her husband, Brad Cooper, denied any part in her death for six years. Cary police arrested him that October, and in May 2011 a Wake County jury convicted him of first-degree murder after a trial that ran for ten weeks and heard close to a hundred witnesses. He was sentenced to life in prison without parole.
The verdict did not hold. On September 3, 2013, according to reports of the ruling, the North Carolina Court of Appeals found that the trial judge had wrongly kept defense testimony about the computer evidence at the center of the state's case from the jury, and it ordered a new trial. The state's highest court declined to intervene. On September 22, 2014, with a second trial ahead, Cooper pleaded guilty to second-degree murder. He served the rest of a sentence of 145 to 183 months and left prison in November 2020.
Brad Cooper came from Medicine Hat, Alberta. His wife grew up in Edmonton, made friends easily wherever she lived and kept close ties to home through her years in the United States. The couple married in Calgary in October 2000, and in November 2001 they moved to North Carolina for his work. He was employed by Cisco Systems, the networking company, as a specialist in internet telephone technology; at his trial he was described as a certified expert in the field. They settled in Cary, a fast-growing town on the edge of Raleigh, and had two daughters there.
By the summer of 2008 the marriage had failed. Cooper later admitted to police that the couple had serious problems after he had an affair, and that they were separating when his wife died. Witnesses at his trial testified that he controlled the family's money, giving her a weekly allowance, that he monitored her calls and her email, and that he cut off her access to the couple's bank and credit accounts after she told him she wanted to take the girls back to Canada.
For a time the separation seemed headed toward an ordinary, if unhappy, settlement, with plans to sell the family's property in Cary. The prosecution's account was that this changed once he read a separation agreement drafted by her lawyer. Her plans to move were called off. The passports she had kept locked away were taken, a child's passport among them, which would have kept her from leaving the country with the children; witnesses said he was the one who took them.
The investigation into her death took more than three months, and through all of it Cooper denied any role. In October 2008 a Wake County grand jury indicted him for first-degree murder, and Cary police arrested him the same evening. He was 35. He was held without bond and stayed in custody, first in the county jail and then in the state prison system, until November 2020.
The case took more than two years to reach trial. Testimony began in Wake County Superior Court in Raleigh on March 9, 2011, and the state's case was circumstantial from start to finish. Prosecutors argued that he had killed his wife because she meant to divorce him and take their daughters to Canada. They pointed to his hold on the family's money, to the passports, and to statements he had given police and in a sworn deposition that, they said, did not agree with each other. The heart of their case was digital. State witnesses, FBI examiners among them, testified that files recovered from the laptop he used for his work at Cisco tied him to her death and showed no sign of tampering.
The defense answered that detectives had looked at no one else from the start and that the files had been planted. It had two witnesses ready to support the tampering claim. The judge ruled that one of them, a network security professional, was not qualified as an expert in the examination of computers, and he limited what that witness could tell the jury. The other was barred in part because his name had not appeared on a required witness list. Neither gave the jury his opinion that the files had been altered. The judge also denied the defense access to the FBI's own procedures for examining computers.
On May 5, 2011, after more than ten hours of deliberation over three days, the jury found Bradley Graham Cooper guilty of first-degree murder, and the judge sentenced him to life in prison without parole. The trial had lasted 36 court days, the longest non-capital murder trial in Wake County's history. He appealed.
A three-judge panel of the Court of Appeals decided the case unanimously in his favor on September 3, 2013. According to reports of the opinion, the panel held that the trial court had abused its discretion in excluding the network security witness's opinion that the files had been tampered with, and had erred in limiting his testimony about the data taken from the laptop. It treated those files as among the most important evidence admitted at trial and ordered a new trial. The North Carolina Supreme Court granted the state a temporary stay that September, then on January 24, 2014, declined to review the case. The order for a new trial stood.
The second trial never took place. On September 22, 2014, Cooper, by then 40, stood before the judge who had presided over his first trial and pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in his wife's death. Asked directly whether he had killed her, he answered yes. The judge accepted the plea and sentenced him to 145 to 183 months in prison, with credit for the time he had been held since October 2008. The state had offered a plea to second-degree murder at the time of the first trial as well; this time he took it. The first-degree verdict, set aside on appeal, was never restored. The conviction that stands is the one he entered himself.
Cooper served the rest of the sentence in the North Carolina prison system and was released from a state prison in western North Carolina in November 2020, twelve years after his wife's death. Reports of his release that month said that, as a convicted felon who was not a United States citizen, he was to be taken into the custody of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement for deportation to Canada.
The guilty plea settled the central question: in 2014 Cooper admitted in court that he had killed his wife. It did not test the evidence that had divided the two sides at trial. The state's 2011 case rested in large part on the laptop files, and the defense maintained that they had been planted. Because the Court of Appeals held that the jury should have heard the defense expert, and because no second jury ever sat, those competing accounts were never weighed by a court with the full expert testimony before it.
October 2000: Brad Cooper marries in Calgary, Alberta.
November 2001: The couple move to North Carolina for his work at Cisco Systems and settle in Cary.
July 12, 2008: His wife dies in Cary.
October 2008: A Wake County grand jury indicts him for first-degree murder; Cary police arrest him and he is held without bond.
March 9, 2011: Testimony begins in Wake County Superior Court.
May 5, 2011: The jury finds him guilty of first-degree murder; he is sentenced to life in prison without parole.
September 3, 2013: The North Carolina Court of Appeals orders a new trial, holding (as reported) that defense expert testimony on the computer evidence was wrongly excluded.
January 24, 2014: The North Carolina Supreme Court declines to review the case; the new trial order stands.
September 22, 2014: He pleads guilty to second-degree murder and is sentenced to 145 to 183 months, with credit from October 2008.
November 2020: He is released from a North Carolina prison; reports say he is to be taken into immigration custody for deportation to Canada.