Bart Whitaker

Victims
2 murders, his mother and brother, Sugar Land, Texas, 2003. Convicted of capital murder, Fort Bend County, Texas, March 5, 2007; his father survived.
Years active
December 10, 2003
Location
Sugar Land, Texas (killings); Fort Bend County, Texas (trial); Monterrey, Mexico (arrest)
Method
Shot by a gunman Whitaker had recruited (court record); Whitaker did not fire.
Status
Sentenced to death March 8, 2007; affirmed 2009; habeas denied 2010 to 2017. Serving life without parole in Texas since the death sentence was commuted, February 22, 2018.

On the evening of December 10, 2003, a family from Sugar Land, Texas, went out to dinner to celebrate the eldest son's graduation from college. The graduation did not exist. Thomas Bartlett Whitaker, known as Bart, was 23, and he had spent months telling his parents and his younger brother that he was finishing a degree he had never come close to earning. When the family came back to Sugar Land that night, a man he had recruited was waiting for them. His mother and his brother were killed. His father survived.

A Fort Bend County jury convicted Whitaker of capital murder on March 5, 2007, and three days later he was sentenced to death. The courts upheld the conviction and sentence at every level. His father, the only member of the household left alive, asked the state for fourteen years not to execute him. On February 22, 2018, about an hour before the execution was due to begin, Governor Greg Abbott accepted a unanimous recommendation from the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles and commuted the sentence to life in prison without parole. It was the first death sentence Abbott had commuted.

Whitaker was born on December 31, 1979, and grew up in Sugar Land, a suburb southwest of Houston. He went to Baylor University and later transferred to Sam Houston State University, but when detectives checked his records after the killings, they found he was not enrolled at Sam Houston State at all. The last time he had been, he was a freshman on academic probation.

December 10 was not his first attempt. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals found that since at least 2000 Whitaker had planned with several other people, at different times, to murder his family, and that he had made at least one unsuccessful attempt before that night. His motive, the court found, was money: the estate he expected to inherit. None of the people drawn into the earlier plans was charged; they later received immunity in return for their testimony.

Patricia Whitaker, his mother, and Kevin Whitaker, his younger brother, died that night. Bart himself was among those hurt, as part of a plan meant to make him look like one more victim. The man who carried out the killings was his roommate; a neighbor of theirs waited to drive him away. Both had been recruited by Whitaker.

Sugar Land police soon learned that the graduation was invented, and within days a former classmate came forward to say Whitaker had once tried to recruit him to kill the family. As the inquiry narrowed to him, Whitaker fled to Mexico in June 2004. The case broke in August 2005, when the driver confessed and named the roommate as the killer and Whitaker as the planner; both men were arrested. Mexican authorities arrested Whitaker in Monterrey on September 22, 2005, and returned him to Texas.

The two men he had recruited were dealt with separately. The state did not seek death against the man who carried out the killings; he pleaded guilty to murder in 2007 and was sentenced to life in prison. The driver pleaded guilty to a reduced murder charge and received fifteen years in return for his cooperation, which included testifying at Whitaker's trial.

For Whitaker the state sought death. He offered through his lawyers to plead guilty in exchange for two consecutive life sentences, and the state refused. A written statement his lawyers had given the prosecution during those plea talks, known as a proffer, became the most litigated issue in the case.

The trial in early 2007 was not, in practice, a contest over guilt. The driver, the men from the earlier plans and his father, who testified as an eyewitness, described the plot. On March 5, 2007, the jury found Whitaker guilty of capital murder. At the punishment phase the defense built its case on remorse and the family's wish that he be spared. The jury found a probability that he would commit criminal acts of violence constituting a continuing threat to society, and that the mitigating evidence did not warrant a life sentence. On March 8, 2007, the court sentenced him to death.

The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed the conviction and sentence on June 24, 2009, holding that Whitaker had waived any complaint about the state's references to the proffer by not objecting at trial. It denied state habeas relief on June 30, 2010. The federal district court in Houston denied his habeas petition on March 17, 2015, and the Fifth Circuit affirmed on April 4, 2017, holding that any improper reference to the proffer was harmless. The United States Supreme Court declined to review the case later that year.

Whitaker was given an execution date of February 22, 2018. His father, who had forgiven him within hours of the killings, asked the parole board to spare the last member of his immediate family, and on February 20, 2018, the seven-member board voted unanimously to recommend commutation. Two days later, about an hour before the scheduled execution, Abbott issued a proclamation commuting the death sentence to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. The proclamation rested on a condition: Whitaker had waived, forever, any claim to parole, and if he ever withdrew that waiver or challenged the commuted sentence, the commutation would be void. He left death row that night and remains in the custody of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, serving life without parole.

The circumstances of the proffer were never resolved by any court. Whitaker's original lawyers said the lead prosecutor invited a statement limited to the facts and then faulted it for showing no remorse; the prosecutor denied making any offer to forgo death in exchange for a confession. The federal district court called these facts unresolved and decided the claim on the assumption that the defense account was true. Whitaker said at trial that he had not written or approved the document his lawyers submitted.

Whether his remorse was genuine divided the trial and the clemency hearing. The state argued at punishment that his plea overtures were insincere; the courts did not decide the question, and the governor's commutation did not rest on it.

Timeline

December 31, 1979: Thomas Bartlett Whitaker is born.

2000: The appeals court later finds that he began planning with others, by at least this year, to murder his family.

December 10, 2003: After a dinner to celebrate a graduation that did not exist, his mother and brother are killed in Sugar Land, Texas; his father survives.

June 2004: Whitaker flees to Mexico.

August 2005: The driver confesses; he and the man who carried out the killings are arrested.

September 22, 2005: Whitaker is arrested in Monterrey, Mexico, and returned to Texas.

2007: The man who carried out the killings pleads guilty to murder and receives life; the driver receives fifteen years.

March 5, 2007: A Fort Bend County jury convicts Whitaker of capital murder.

March 8, 2007: He is sentenced to death.

June 24, 2009: The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals affirms the conviction and sentence.

June 30, 2010: The same court denies state habeas relief.

March 17, 2015: The federal district court in Houston denies his habeas petition.

April 4, 2017: The Fifth Circuit affirms.

February 20, 2018: The Board of Pardons and Paroles votes unanimously to recommend clemency.

February 22, 2018: Governor Greg Abbott commutes the sentence to life without parole about an hour before the scheduled execution.