Magne Andreassen died in Lillehammer on the night of August 21, 1992. For a year the case stood open, with no suspect and no apparent reason for the killing. When it was finally solved, the answer came out of a different investigation altogether: a special police inquiry into a wave of church fires, which in the late summer of 1993 broke open a closed circle of young musicians and fans. One of the men it reached was Bård Eithun, a drummer who recorded under the name Faust. In 1994 a Norwegian court convicted him of the murder and of taking part in a church arson, and he was sentenced to 14 years. He served nine years and four months before he was released.
Eithun was the original drummer of the Norwegian band Emperor, part of the black metal scene that had taken shape in Norway around 1991. He stood near the center of that small world, and the two men he would later confide in about the death in Lillehammer were among its most prominent figures.
The killing in Lillehammer was committed without any apparent reason. Nothing pointed investigators toward the Oslo music scene, and nothing pointed them toward Eithun. With no motive to work from and no suspect, the case remained unsolved through the fall and the following winter.
Eithun said nothing to the police. He did tell the two scene figures, and what he told them stayed inside that circle for the better part of a year.
On the night of August 24, 1992, Holmenkollen Chapel in Oslo burned to the ground in a deliberately set fire, one of a series of church fires across Norway that summer and after. Eithun took part in the Holmenkollen fire together with the same two men he had told about the killing, and the arson became one of the counts on which he was convicted.
The case against Eithun grew out of the special unit that Norway's Director of Public Prosecutions set up to examine the church fires together rather than as scattered local cases. The one consistent line of inquiry was that signs at several of the sites pointed toward the small black metal scene, and the unit set out to map it. The scene proved hard to penetrate, and in interviews everyone denied any part in the fires. In August 1993, after a killing in Oslo, police arrested three men in Bergen, and with them in custody the young men around them began to talk.
The arrests changed the inquiry. Statements from witnesses opened up several of the fire cases, and the same names kept surfacing. Some of the fires turned out to be the work of young people who had been inspired by the scene without belonging to it. Others led back to its core.
During these interviews investigators came upon a second case they had not expected. One of the central figures they had brought in for questioning could be tied not only to the Holmenkollen fire but also to the unsolved death in Lillehammer the year before. That man was Eithun. What he had told the two scene figures about the killing came to light in the course of the investigation into the Oslo killing, and a case that had stood open for a year was closed.
Eithun was tried in 1994. The court convicted him of the murder in Lillehammer and of taking part in the church arson, and sentenced him to 14 years in prison. Several of the other fire cases and the Oslo murder case also ended in convictions that year.
Eithun served his sentence in Norway, and while in custody he completed a bachelor's degree at the University of Oslo in the history of religions and the history of ideas.
By November 2002 Eithun had spent nine years and four months in custody, and he was due to be freed the following month. He returned to music on his release and has remained free since.
The motive for the killing has never been explained in public beyond Eithun's own account of it as an unplanned act of aggression.
August 21, 1992: the murder in Lillehammer; the case stays unsolved for a year.
August 24, 1992: Holmenkollen Chapel in Oslo is destroyed by a deliberately set fire; Eithun is later convicted of taking part.
August 21, 1993: police arrest three men in Bergen; the interviews that follow tie Eithun to the Lillehammer death and the Holmenkollen fire.
1994: Eithun is convicted of murder and of taking part in a church arson and sentenced to 14 years.
November 2002: Eithun has served nine years and four months and is due for release the following month.