Bachan Athwal

Victims
1 murder, her daughter-in-law, in Punjab, India, 1998. Convicted with her son at the Central Criminal Court, London, July 26, 2007; convictions upheld by the Court of Appeal, May 7, 2009
Years active
December 1998
Location
Punjab, India (killing); Hayes, London, England (residence); London, England (trial)
Method
Strangled in India by others at her instigation (the account a prosecution witness said Bachan Athwal gave her; no one was convicted of the act itself)
Status
Life imprisonment, September 2007, minimum term 20 years; reduced to 15 years by the Court of Appeal, May 7, 2009; conviction upheld. Released on licence, August 2022.

Bachan Kaur Athwal was 70 years old when a jury at the Central Criminal Court in London convicted her of murder on July 26, 2007. The woman she was found to have had killed was her daughter-in-law, Surjit Kaur Athwal, who had traveled with her to India early in December 1998 for two family weddings in Punjab and never came back. Bachan's son, the dead woman's husband, was convicted alongside her. Both had denied murder. Both were sentenced to life imprisonment.

The conviction was the first in a British court for an "honor" killing carried out abroad. It came almost nine years after the young woman vanished, and it rested on circumstantial evidence, above all on what members of the family had seen and heard in west London before and after the trip.

The prosecution's case was that mother and son arranged the journey so that she could be killed in India, because she had decided to seek a divorce and the family regarded a divorce as a disgrace. The Court of Appeal recorded that by December 1998 both husband and wife had contemplated divorce, and it accepted that the jury had heard evidence of that motive.

She flew to India with her mother-in-law on December 4, 1998. Photographs and video from the two weddings, on December 5 and 6, show her alive and present. Bachan flew back to London on December 18, as booked. Her daughter-in-law held a return ticket and did not come home.

The evidence that carried the case came from Bachan's other daughter-in-law, who lived in the adjoining house in Hayes. She told the jury that before the trip Bachan announced at a family meeting that the killing had been arranged in India, and that after her return Bachan told her it had been done. Within weeks she repeated that account to her own father and sister, and she wrote an anonymous letter to the police.

A first Metropolitan Police inquiry in 1999 ended without charges, and a prosecution of Bachan's brother in India ended in his acquittal. After the case was reopened, the witness made formal statements in October 2005 and February 2006, and Bachan and her son were charged with conspiracy to murder.

At the trial, which ran from April to July 2007, a joint count of murder was added to the conspiracy charge. The defense case was that the main witness had lied from the start. A daughter of Bachan who had given the police a supporting account told the jury she could not remember it. The jury convicted mother and son of murder.

In September 2007 the trial judge sentenced both to life imprisonment, with a minimum term of 20 years for Bachan and 27 years for her son. He treated as aggravating features that the killing was planned, that it was meant to bring a gain from insurance on the young woman's life, that it was followed by a cover-up, and that Bachan had acted in breach of trust as the head of the family.

In its judgment of May 7, 2009, the Court of Appeal dismissed both appeals against conviction. It rejected the argument that the difficulty of investigating in India had made the trial an abuse of process. It held that the trial judge should have admitted the evidence of the witness's father and sister under the Criminal Justice Act 2003 rather than at common law, but that the error did not make the convictions unsafe. The appeals against sentence succeeded. The court reduced the minimum terms to 15 years for Bachan and 20 years for her son, finding that Bachan, whom it described as the instigator of the murder, was likely to die within a 20-year term and would face particular hardship in prison because she could not speak or read English.

In August 2022 the Parole Board released Bachan Athwal on licence on the grounds of her poor health; she had developed dementia. The release became public in April 2023.

No one has been convicted of carrying out the killing itself. The London jury convicted Bachan and her son of murder as parties to it. Her brother was tried in India on a charge of abduction and acquitted; the prosecution's case that he and others carried out the killing was never tested against him in an English court.

The account of how and where the young woman died rests on what the main witness said Bachan told her, and on a statement Bachan's daughter gave the police and later said she could not remember. The jury accepted the witness's evidence and the Court of Appeal upheld the verdicts, but the circumstances of the death in Punjab were never established by direct evidence.

Accounts differ on whether the case was reopened in 2004 or 2005.

Timeline

December 4, 1998: Bachan Athwal and her daughter-in-law travel from London to India.

December 18, 1998: Bachan returns to London; her daughter-in-law does not.

1999: A Metropolitan Police inquiry ends without charges.

October 27, 2005, and February 8, 2006: Bachan's other daughter-in-law makes formal witness statements after the case is reopened.

July 26, 2007: Bachan Athwal and her son are convicted of murder at the Central Criminal Court.

September 2007: Both are sentenced to life imprisonment, with minimum terms of 20 and 27 years.

May 7, 2009: The Court of Appeal upholds the convictions and reduces the minimum terms to 15 and 20 years.

August 2022: Bachan Athwal is released on licence.