Azhar Nazir

Victims
1 murder, his sister, Southall, west London, April 23, 2005. Convicted by a jury at the Central Criminal Court, June 16, 2006; appeal dismissed February 20, 2009.
Years active
April 23, 2005
Location
Southall, west London, England (killing); Central Criminal Court, London, England (trial); Court of Appeal, London, England (appeal)
Method
Stabbed (trial evidence; the Crown's case was a joint enterprise to kill with the 17-year-old co-defendant)
Status
Life imprisonment, minimum term 20 years, Central Criminal Court, July 14, 2006. Appeal dismissed February 20, 2009; in custody in England at that date.

Azhar Nazir was a greengrocer in Southall, in west London, and he was 30 when he stood trial for murder in 2006. On April 23, 2005, his sister Samaira Nazir was killed in Southall. A 17-year-old who lived with the family admitted to police that he had caused her death, and Nazir told officers that the teenager had acted alone. A jury at the Central Criminal Court did not accept that. On June 16, 2006, it convicted Nazir of murder, and on July 14, 2006, he was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 20 years. In passing sentence, the trial judge found that she had been murdered by members of her own family because she insisted on marrying a man they considered unsuitable.

The case was reported as an "honor" killing from the day of the verdict, and it reached deep into the law of evidence. When Nazir appealed, the Court of Appeal had to decide whether a conviction resting partly on an anonymous eyewitness could stand after a 2008 House of Lords decision on anonymous witnesses and a statute Parliament passed the same year. It held that it could.

The teenager lived in a building at the bottom of the family's garden. In the words of the Court of Appeal he was treated as the family's youngest son, although the court described him as not related to the family.

The emergency services were called to the family's address in Southall on April 23, 2005, and two police officers arrived first. Nazir told them his sister was dead, said he was not responsible and pointed them toward the teenager, who then came to the officers and told them he had killed her. Both young men were arrested and cautioned. Nazir's mother was arrested the same day.

The teenager gave a full account in interview. He said he alone had caused her death, that he had meant only to frighten her, and that he had called the police himself. Nazir took a different course. At his first interview, on April 24, 2005, he answered "No comment." By the time he was interviewed again, in August 2005, the police had scientific evidence about his clothing, and when they put it to him he could not explain it. He said he had not seen what happened to his sister.

Nazir's father was also arrested in connection with the death. He was released on bail and left for Pakistan before the trial, and he was never tried. The charges against Nazir's mother were dropped.

Nazir and the teenager were tried together for murder at the Central Criminal Court in London in 2006. The Crown's case was a joint enterprise to kill: that both had taken part in her death with the shared intention that she should die. The teenager did not deny causing her death. His defense was diminished responsibility, and he did not give evidence. Nazir did. He accepted that he had been present but denied playing any part, and he told the jury he had gone to telephone the police.

The Crown built its case against him from several strands: his presence, the evidence of motive, a neighbor who heard a woman calling for help and was told by Nazir that his sister was having fits, expert scientific evidence that the Crown said could not be squared with his account of where he had been, and an eyewitness whose account, if believed, made him an active participant rather than a bystander.

That eyewitness had told the police she feared for her safety and would testify only if her identity was protected. The trial judge accepted that her fear was genuine and justified and allowed her to give evidence anonymously. The jury never learned her name, and her voice was not disguised.

During its deliberations the jury asked whether it could use the teenager's statements to police, in which he said he had acted alone, in deciding Nazir's case. With the agreement of both counsel, the judge said it could not, following the general rule that what one defendant tells the police is not evidence for or against another. On joint enterprise he gave the Judicial Studies Board's specimen direction: standing by as a passive spectator is no crime, but encouragement can make a person who is present a party to it.

The jury convicted the teenager of murder first, and the next day, June 16, 2006, it convicted Nazir of murder. On July 14, 2006, at the Central Criminal Court, Nazir was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 20 years. The teenager was sentenced to life, to be detained with a minimum term of 10 years.

Nazir appealed against his conviction on three grounds. The jury, he argued, had been wrongly told that it could not use the teenager's police statements in his favor; the eyewitness should never have been allowed to give evidence anonymously, and the judge's direction about her evidence was inadequate; and the direction on joint enterprise was wrong or incomplete.

On the first ground, the court noted that since April 2005 a confession made by one defendant could, in some circumstances, be given in evidence for a co-defendant. It assumed in Nazir's favor that the rule could have applied, and that the whole of the teenager's interviews would then have been admissible. But the statements could not have changed the verdict. The teenager had told police that he was alone, that he had called the police himself and that Nazir had come back with the officers, and the court found each of those claims to be a lie. He had, it found, persistently lied to protect Nazir and other members of the family, and his claim to have acted alone was not reliable.

The second ground was the heart of the appeal. Nazir's trial had taken place before the House of Lords decided R v Davis in 2008 and before Parliament passed the Criminal Evidence (Witness Anonymity) Act 2008, which gave the courts a statutory power to grant anonymity and told appeal courts how to treat convictions from earlier trials. The question was whether the order in Nazir's trial could have been made under the new Act and, if so, whether he had still been denied a fair trial. The court answered both against him. The witness's fear for her safety was genuine and supported by the police. Her evidence was important, and she would not have testified without anonymity. Her account was supported by the neighbor, and it was not the sole or decisive evidence against Nazir, because his presence, his motive, the neighbor and the scientific evidence were enough without her. Suggestions that she was biased against him were considered and rejected. A complaint that the lack of voice disguise had made her recognizable came two and a half years after the trial, with no evidence that anyone had identified her, and the court rejected it. The order could have been made under the Act, the trial had not been unfair, and the judge's direction about anonymous evidence was adequate.

On the third ground, the court held that the judge had used the standard specimen direction and that "encouragement" was an ordinary English word needing no further explanation. One sentence of the summing-up, read alone, could have suggested that presence plus intention was enough, but the direction as a whole was clear, and neither counsel had raised the point at trial.

Taking the grounds together, the court found the case against Nazir strong, independently of the anonymous witness. The Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) dismissed his appeal against conviction on February 20, 2009, [2009] EWCA Crim 213.

Nazir was in custody in England, serving life with a minimum term of 20 years, when his appeal was dismissed on February 20, 2009.

Nazir has never admitted any part in his sister's death. He told the police and the jury that the teenager acted alone and that he himself went to call for help. The jury rejected that account, and the Court of Appeal found the evidence against him strong.

The teenager's claim to sole responsibility did not survive either. The jury convicted both men, and the Court of Appeal found that he had lied repeatedly to protect Nazir and others in the family.

The part played by other members of the family was never tested in court.

The teenager's relationship to the family is stated two ways: press reports during the trial and at sentencing called him the victim's cousin, while the Court of Appeal described him as not related to the family but treated as its youngest son.

The victim's age was given as 25 in press reports of the trial and as 26 in the appeal judgment.

Timeline

April 23, 2005: Nazir's sister is killed in Southall, west London. Nazir and a 17-year-old living with the family are arrested; Nazir's mother is also arrested.

April 24, 2005: Nazir answers "No comment" in his first police interview.

August 2005: Nazir is interviewed again and cannot explain the scientific evidence put to him.

By June 2006: Nazir's father, released on bail, has left for Pakistan; the charges against Nazir's mother have been dropped.

June 2006: The two are tried for murder at the Central Criminal Court; the teenager is convicted the day before Nazir.

June 16, 2006: The jury convicts Nazir of murder.

July 14, 2006: Nazir is sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 20 years; the teenager is sentenced to life with a minimum term of 10 years.

February 20, 2009: The Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) dismisses Nazir's appeal against conviction, [2009] EWCA Crim 213.