Augustin Ndindiliyimana commanded Rwanda's national gendarmerie when the genocide against the Tutsi began in April 1994. A major general and the gendarmerie's Chief of Staff until June 5 of that year, he was arrested in Belgium in January 2000 on a warrant from the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda and spent the next eleven years in its custody in Arusha, Tanzania. On May 17, 2011, Trial Chamber II found him guilty of genocide, of murder and extermination as crimes against humanity, and of murder as a serious violation of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions and of Additional Protocol II. The judges did not find that he had taken part in any killing himself. They held him responsible as a superior for gendarmes who, they found, took part in attacks on Tutsi at Kansi Parish, in Butare Prefecture, and at Saint André College, in Kigali, and they sentenced him to the time he had already served, ordering his immediate release.
The case did not end there. On February 11, 2014, the Appeals Chamber reversed every one of his convictions and acquitted him of all counts in the indictment. In law, no death is attributed to him. In September 2014, after years in a residence the tribunal kept for people it had freed, he obtained a Belgian visa and left Arusha to rejoin family in Belgium.
Ndindiliyimana was born in 1943 in Nyaruhengeri commune, in Butare Prefecture, in the south of Rwanda. In court he would be the officer from the south, tried beside an army chief from the north. When he testified in his own defense in June 2008, he described a long public life spent in government before he ever ran the gendarmerie. In 1982 he entered the cabinet as Minister for Youth and Sports. He later held the portfolio for transport and telecommunications, and after that the defense portfolio. Throughout those posts, he told the court, he had tried to stand above the country's ethnic and regional divisions.
On September 2, 1992, he was appointed Chief of Staff of the Gendarmerie Nationale. The gendarmerie was a paramilitary police force, and together with the army it made up the Rwandan Armed Forces under the Ministry of Defense. Its general staff and the army's general staff sat side by side under that ministry. He held the rank of major general.
On April 6, 1994, the aircraft carrying President Juvenal Habyarimana was attacked. The attack also killed the army's top commanders. The killing of Tutsi began the next day.
The Rwandan Armed Forces set up a crisis committee after the President's death. Ndindiliyimana denied from the witness stand that it was ever meant to seize power. He said he had never presided over it, that the idea came from Colonel Theoneste Bagosora, then director of cabinet at the Ministry of Defense, and that its only mandate was to coordinate the protection of the population, of politicians and of other public figures. By his account, the committee met on April 7, 1994, at the Ecole superieure militaire with Bagosora in the chair, asked army and gendarmerie commanders to stay alert for violence, and sought help from the United Nations. He said he learned only as he left that the Prime Minister, Agathe Uwilingiyimana, had been killed.
He told the court that broadcasts from the rebel Rwandan Patriotic Front in those days falsely announced his assassination, and that he went on the government radio to tell the public he was alive and still working to protect them. On April 22, 1994, he said, he called on Rwandans to stop killing one another and argued that the government had to turn from fighting the rebel army to controlling the violence inside the country.
Once war resumed after April 6, most gendarmes were sent to the front to reinforce the army, which could not stop the advance of the Rwandan Patriotic Front. In Kigali, the gendarmes came under the operational command of the army. The Trial Chamber would later accept that Ndindiliyimana's authority over the gendarmerie after April 6, 1994, was significantly reduced. He remained Chief of Staff until June 5, 1994.
After the genocide, Ndindiliyimana fled to what was then Zaire, and he later settled in Belgium, where he was granted refugee status. He was living there when the tribunal's Prosecutor indicted him, with others, on January 20, 2000, for genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes. Belgian authorities arrested him in Termonde on January 29, 2000, under a Belgian law allowing the arrest and transfer of people accused of crimes within the tribunals' jurisdiction. On April 22, 2000, he was flown to the tribunal's detention facility in Arusha, and five days later he pleaded not guilty to all ten counts.
The indictment charged him with conspiracy to commit genocide, genocide, complicity in genocide, crimes against humanity and violations of the Geneva Conventions. It alleged that he had taken part in planning and preparing the massacres of Tutsi and moderate Hutu in 1994 and had conspired with others to stay in power, and that he and other senior officials failed to prevent the massacres carried out by gendarmerie, army and Interahamwe militia forces, or to punish those responsible. It also accused him of undermining a joint disarmament operation with the UN force in early 1994, and charged him, with others, in connection with the murder of ten Belgian UN peacekeepers at Kigali military camp on April 7, 1994. None of these allegations became a finding against him.
He was tried with three other former officers of the Rwandan Armed Forces in what the tribunal called the Military II case: General Augustin Bizimungu, the former Chief of Staff of the army; Major Francois-Xavier Nzuwonemeye, the former commander of the Reconnaissance Battalion; and Captain Innocent Sagahutu, who commanded a squadron in that battalion. All four pleaded not guilty. The trial opened on September 20, 2004, before Trial Chamber II.
Ndindiliyimana testified in his own defense from June 16 to June 23, 2008. He told the judges he had never supported anyone in killing members of the population in 1994. He called the prosecution's allegations "unfair and baseless," urged the prosecution to look for the "real killers" and said he should not be made a scapegoat. He maintained that he had done everything he could to keep the country from sliding into violence and to save lives, that he had always held a neutral position above ethnic and regional loyalties, and that after April 6 the gendarmerie, absorbed in defending against the Rwandan Patriotic Front, could no longer guarantee public safety. On his last day in the witness box he spoke about the failure of the UN mission in Rwanda to complete its work, and asked the tribunal to pursue true justice and uncover the truth.
The Trial Chamber delivered its judgment on May 17, 2011. It acquitted Ndindiliyimana of conspiracy to commit genocide, finding the charge unproved beyond reasonable doubt, and dismissed the count of complicity in genocide. It convicted him on four counts: genocide; murder as a crime against humanity; extermination as a crime against humanity; and murder as a serious violation of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions and of Additional Protocol II. The convictions rested on superior responsibility, not on any finding that he had acted directly. The Chamber found that gendarmes had taken part in killings of Tutsi at Kansi Parish and at Saint André College in April 1994. It accepted that his authority over the gendarmes was significantly reduced after hostilities resumed, but concluded that the gendarmes it held responsible at those two sites remained under his control.
In sentencing, the Chamber weighed three mitigating factors in his favor: his limited command over the gendarmerie after April 6, 1994; his consistent support for the Arusha Accords, the peace agreement with the Rwandan Patriotic Front; and his opposition to the massacres in Rwanda. It sentenced him to the time he had served since his arrest on January 29, 2000, and ordered his immediate release. The same judgment sentenced Bizimungu to 30 years' imprisonment and Nzuwonemeye and Sagahutu to 20 years each. After the hearing, Ndindiliyimana said he was very happy to be free after eleven years.
Release did not mean a return to Belgium. Ndindiliyimana moved into a villa the tribunal ran in Arusha for acquitted detainees who had no country willing to receive them, and he shared it with three men the tribunal had acquitted. Unlike them, he still stood convicted, and a prosecution appeal could bring him back before the judges. On May 20, 2011, the Trial Chamber refused a prosecution request to restrict his liberty, asking only that, while the time for an appeal remained open, he tell the tribunal in advance if he wished to change residence, leave Arusha or obtain travel documents.
On August 15, 2011, the prosecution announced that it would appeal against his sentence and against the findings on which he had been acquitted. Ndindiliyimana appealed his convictions. At the appeal hearing in May 2013, he again maintained his innocence and asked the judges to acquit him.
The Appeals Chamber delivered its judgment in Arusha on February 11, 2014. According to the tribunal's press release, it reversed his convictions for genocide, extermination as a crime against humanity and murder as a serious violation of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions and of Additional Protocol II, all of which rested on his superior responsibility for gendarmes at Kansi Parish and Saint André College, after finding errors in the Trial Chamber's assessment of the evidence and in its conclusions that he had exercised effective control over those gendarmes. As the published case summaries record it, the trial judges had accepted that most gendarmes were under the army's operational command by then yet still held him responsible for the two sites, and the appeal judges found no proof that he controlled the men involved. On the remaining conviction, for murder as a crime against humanity, the press release records that the prosecution conceded nothing supported it, because it had withdrawn the allegations on which it rested. That conviction was reversed too.
Ndindiliyimana was acquitted of all counts in the indictment, and the prosecution's appeal, as it related to him, was dismissed. The same judgment acquitted Nzuwonemeye of all counts and reduced Sagahutu's sentence from 20 years to 15.
The acquittal settled his legal position but not his place to live. He stayed on in the tribunal's Arusha residence with other acquitted men who were waiting for a country to take them. On September 17, 2014, the tribunal's Registry confirmed that Belgium had granted him a visa, and he left Arusha for Belgium that week to rejoin members of his family who lived there. That is the last dated record of him, as of September 2014.
The two judgments in his case reached opposite conclusions on the question that decided it. The Trial Chamber held that the gendarmes at Kansi Parish and Saint André College remained under his control despite his reduced authority after April 6, 1994. The Appeals Chamber found that conclusion and the trial judges' assessment of the evidence to be in error, and its judgment is final. He stands acquitted of all counts.
Much of the prosecution's original case never became a finding of any court. The Trial Chamber acquitted him of conspiracy to commit genocide and dismissed the complicity count. The indictment's allegations about the disarmament operation of early 1994, about planning the massacres and about the deaths of the ten Belgian peacekeepers were not among the findings on which he was convicted in 2011, and the convictions that were entered were all reversed.
The killings at Kansi Parish and Saint André College are on record as findings the Trial Chamber made about gendarmes and other attackers. In law they are not his crimes.
His account of April 1994, his work on the crisis committee, his radio appeal and his opposition to the killing came from his own testimony. The Trial Chamber accepted his opposition to the massacres and his support for the peace process as mitigating factors.
1943: Born in Nyaruhengeri commune, Butare Prefecture, Rwanda.
1982: Enters the government as Minister for Youth and Sports; later holds the transport and telecommunications and defense portfolios.
September 2, 1992: Appointed Chief of Staff of the Gendarmerie Nationale.
April 6, 1994: President Habyarimana's aircraft is attacked; the killing of Tutsi begins the next day.
April 7, 1994: Attends the crisis committee meeting at the Ecole superieure militaire, by his own testimony.
April 1994: Killings of Tutsi at Kansi Parish, Butare Prefecture, and Saint André College, Kigali; the Trial Chamber found gendarmes took part (its findings against him reversed on appeal).
April 22, 1994: Appeals on the radio for an end to the killing, by his own testimony.
June 5, 1994: Ceases to be Chief of Staff of the gendarmerie.
After the genocide: Flees to Zaire; later receives refugee status in Belgium.
January 20, 2000: Indicted by the ICTR Prosecutor with others.
January 29, 2000: Arrested in Termonde, Belgium, on an ICTR warrant.
April 22, 2000: Transferred to the tribunal's detention facility in Arusha.
April 27, 2000: Pleads not guilty to ten counts.
September 20, 2004: Military II trial opens before Trial Chamber II.
June 16 to 23, 2008: Testifies in his own defense.
May 17, 2011: Convicted on four counts as a superior; acquitted of conspiracy; sentenced to time served and released.
May 20, 2011: The Chamber refuses to restrict his liberty pending appeal.
August 15, 2011: The prosecution announces its appeal.
May 2013: Appeal hearing.
February 11, 2014: The Appeals Chamber reverses all his convictions and acquits him of all counts.
September 2014: Granted a Belgian visa; leaves Arusha for Belgium.