In April 1994, as the genocide against the Tutsi spread across Rwanda, Tutsi families from Kivumu commune in Kibuye prefecture sought refuge at Nyange parish and gathered in its church. The man running the parish was Athanase Seromba, a 31-year-old Catholic priest who had been ordained less than a year earlier. On April 16, 1994, the church was destroyed with the refugees still inside. The International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda found that approximately 1,500 of them died.
In December 2006 the tribunal's Trial Chamber convicted Seromba of genocide and of extermination as a crime against humanity as an aider and abettor and sentenced him to 15 years. On March 12, 2008, the Appeals Chamber went further. By a majority, it held that he "was not merely an aider and abetter but became a principal perpetrator in the crime itself," and it replaced the 15 years with imprisonment for the remainder of his life.
Seromba was born in 1963 in Rutziro commune, in Kibuye prefecture in western Rwanda. He trained at the Nyakibanda major seminary, was ordained on July 18, 1993, and arrived at Nyange late that summer or early that autumn. He was a vicar there, not the parish priest. By April 1994 the parish priest had gone, and Seromba, already posted on March 17 to another parish, Crête Zaïre Nil, was handling Nyange's daily management while he waited to take up the new post. The Trial Chamber concluded from the way he acted that month that he was in practice the acting parish priest. Witnesses for both sides said he had been well regarded before 1994, and the Chamber later counted that reputation in his favor.
The President of Rwanda died on April 6, 1994, and attacks on Tutsi began in Kivumu commune within days. Tutsi residents fled to public buildings and to churches, and many of them went to Nyange. From about April 12, militiamen and Interahamwe surrounded the church where the refugees were sheltering.
On April 13, Seromba dismissed four Tutsi members of the parish staff. One of them, Patrice, came back the following day. The Trial Chamber found that Seromba turned him away from the presbytery and that attackers then killed him. In the same days Seromba turned other refugees away from the presbytery, among them a woman named Meriam, and the Chamber found that the attackers killed her afterward. The court treated these two deaths apart from the deaths in the church. Both the Trial Chamber and, unanimously, the Appeals Chamber held that by turning these two people away, Seromba aided and abetted genocide.
On April 15 the attackers moved against the refugees in the church, and many died that day. The Chamber did not find it proven that Seromba ordered or supervised those attacks. On April 16 the communal authorities decided to destroy the church. The Trial Chamber found that Seromba was informed of that decision and accepted it, and that when the man sent to carry it out asked him whether he should go ahead, Seromba said yes and encouraged him. It found that the refugees were killed because they were Tutsi, that Seromba knew the attack on the Tutsi was widespread and systematic, and that he knew his approval "would substantially contribute to the destruction of the church and the death of the numerous refugees inside."
After the killings Seromba left Rwanda, and from 1997 he served as a priest near Florence, Italy, under a false identity. The tribunal's prosecutor indicted him on June 8, 2001, on four counts: genocide; complicity in genocide, in the alternative; conspiracy to commit genocide; and extermination as a crime against humanity. On February 6, 2002, he traveled from Italy to Tanzania and surrendered to the tribunal, and on February 8 he pleaded not guilty to every count. His trial opened before Trial Chamber III in Arusha on September 20, 2004.
The Trial Chamber delivered its judgment on December 13, 2006. It found him guilty under Count 1, genocide, and Count 4, extermination as a crime against humanity; not guilty under Count 3, conspiracy to commit genocide; and it dismissed Count 2, complicity, as charged only in the alternative. It held that the prosecution had not proved that he planned, instigated, ordered or committed the massacres, but that by his words and actions on April 12, 14, 15 and 16, 1994, he aided and abetted the killing of the Tutsi who had sought refuge at Nyange church and the causing of serious bodily or mental harm to them. As aggravating circumstances it counted his standing as a known and respected priest, his betrayal of the trust of the Tutsi who believed they would be safe in his parish, and his flight under an assumed identity; as mitigating circumstances, his good reputation before April 1994, his voluntary surrender and his age. It imposed a single sentence of 15 years, with credit for time in custody since February 6, 2002.
Both sides appealed, and the Appeals Chamber gave its judgment on March 12, 2008. It quashed the findings that Seromba aided and abetted genocide by blocking the refugees' access to food from the parish plantation and by refusing to celebrate Mass for them, rejected the rest of his grounds, and unanimously affirmed the dismissal of the complicity count and the acquittal on conspiracy. On the central question the majority held that the Trial Chamber had erred in law by treating "committing" as requiring direct, physical perpetration; in the context of genocide, other acts can amount to direct participation when they are as much an integral part of the genocide as the killings they make possible. It concluded that Seromba "approved and embraced as his own" the decision to destroy the church in order to kill the Tutsi refugees, and it held that he committed genocide and extermination as a crime against humanity by virtue of his role in the destruction of the church. It affirmed, unanimously, that he aided and abetted genocide in the two killings that followed his turning people away from the presbytery. It ruled that his age could not serve as a mitigating factor, quashed the 15-year sentence and, by majority, entered a sentence of imprisonment for the remainder of his life, with credit for detention since February 6, 2002. Judge Liu Daqun dissented on both the finding of commission and the life sentence; he would have upheld the conviction for aiding and abetting.
On June 27, 2009, Seromba was one of nine convicted prisoners flown from the UN Detention Facility in Arusha to Benin to serve their sentences.
Several allegations in the indictment failed at trial. The Trial Chamber rejected the claim that Seromba drew up a list of Tutsi who had not reached the parish and gave it to the bourgmestre, finding the only witness to that account not credible. It found no proof that he ordered attackers to strike the refugees, that he chaired a planning meeting in the parish office on April 12, or that his talks with the communal authorities were held to plan the extermination of the Tutsi. The conspiracy acquittal stood on appeal. Whether his role is best described as aiding and abetting or as committing divided the Appeals Chamber, and the life sentence rests on the majority's answer.
1963: Seromba is born in Rutziro commune, Kibuye prefecture, Rwanda.
July 18, 1993: He is ordained a Catholic priest; he arrives at Nyange parish later that year.
March 17, 1994: He is posted to the parish of Crête Zaïre Nil but continues managing Nyange.
April 6, 1994: The President of Rwanda dies; attacks on Tutsi in Kivumu commune follow within days.
April 12, 1994: Militiamen and Interahamwe surround the church where Tutsi refugees are sheltering.
April 13, 1994: Seromba dismisses four Tutsi members of the parish staff.
April 14, 1994: A dismissed member of the parish staff is turned away from the presbytery and killed by attackers.
April 15, 1994: Attackers move against the refugees in the church; a refugee turned away from the presbytery is killed.
April 16, 1994: Nyange church is destroyed with the refugees inside.
1997: Seromba begins serving as a priest near Florence, Italy, under a false identity.
June 8, 2001: The ICTR prosecutor files a four-count indictment.
February 6, 2002: Seromba surrenders to the tribunal in Tanzania.
February 8, 2002: He pleads not guilty to all counts.
September 20, 2004: The trial opens before Trial Chamber III.
December 13, 2006: He is found guilty of genocide and extermination by aiding and abetting and sentenced to 15 years.
March 12, 2008: The Appeals Chamber holds that he committed genocide and extermination and imposes life imprisonment, Judge Liu dissenting.
June 27, 2009: He is transferred from Arusha to Benin to serve his sentence.