On December 29, 1969, two brothers from Trinidad took a woman in Wimbledon, in south London, and demanded £1 million for her return. They believed they had seized the wife of the newspaper proprietor Rupert Murdoch. They had not. The woman they held was Muriel McKay, an Australian married to Murdoch's deputy. Arthur Hosein and his younger brother Nizamodeen were arrested in February 1970 and tried at the Old Bailey that autumn. In October 1970 a jury convicted both men of her kidnapping and murder, and both were sentenced to life imprisonment.
The verdict was among the first murder convictions in England reached without the victim ever being found. Arthur died in custody in 2009. Nizamodeen served about twenty years, was deported to Trinidad under an order made in 1990, and in later life gave a series of shifting accounts of what had happened, which led the Metropolitan Police to reopen its inquiry in 2021.
Arthur Hosein was the elder of the two, and in 1969 he was 34. He had settled in England long before his brother, and by the end of the decade he owned a property at Stocking Pelham, a small village in east Hertfordshire near Bishop's Stortford.
Nizamodeen, known as Nizam, grew up in central Trinidad and was 22 when the case came to trial. By the winter of 1969 both brothers were living at Stocking Pelham. Years later Nizamodeen would say that he had been only a young man at the time.
The brothers had meant to take Murdoch's then-wife and hold her until a ransom of £1 million was paid. They soon understood that they held the wife of a newspaper executive instead, and the mistake did not lead them to release her. Nizamodeen later said that by the time they grasped it, news of her disappearance had spread across the country, and they did not let her go.
For roughly forty days the kidnappers kept up their demands. The inquiry led detectives to Stocking Pelham, and on February 7, 1970, Arthur and Nizamodeen Hosein were arrested there. Both were charged with her kidnapping and her murder.
The brothers went on trial at the Central Criminal Court, the Old Bailey, in London, in September 1970, accused of kidnapping her, of holding her and of her murder. The prosecution case rested on a chain of circumstantial evidence that tied the brothers to the ransom demands and to Stocking Pelham.
In October 1970 the jury found both brothers guilty of her murder and her kidnapping. Each was sentenced to life imprisonment for the murder. On the remaining counts the court imposed further terms of 25 years on Arthur and 15 years on Nizamodeen. Appeal proceedings followed, and the convictions stood.
Arthur Hosein died in custody in England in 2009.
Nizamodeen served a little more than twenty years in British prisons. In 1990 he was made the subject of a deportation order and was sent back to Trinidad and Tobago. The order still bars him from entering the United Kingdom without the permission of the Home Office.
In 2021 information Nizamodeen gave in Trinidad led the Metropolitan Police to reopen its inquiry. In interviews in January 2022 he denied having revealed anything new and said that he could not remember the details, while calling himself a "messenger boy" who had carried ransom notes.
His position shifted again in 2023. In a letter to the Home Office that November, asking it to lift the deportation order, he admitted his involvement in the kidnap and in her death. He said publicly that he was "very remorseful" and wanted to give her family closure before he died. Detectives from the Metropolitan Police interviewed him in Trinidad in 2024, and in July of that year the force said its work had produced no further result.
As of 2024, Nizamodeen Hosein was free and living in Trinidad and Tobago. The convictions of both brothers for the murder and kidnapping remain in force.
How and where she died has never been established in any court. The jury convicted both brothers of murder on circumstantial evidence, and the verdict does not set out the circumstances of her death.
Nizamodeen's own accounts since his release have not been consistent. In 2022 he described his part as that of a messenger and said he could not recall details. In 2023 he admitted his involvement in the kidnap and her death. The Metropolitan Police said in 2024 that the accounts he gave its detectives were inconsistent, and nothing he has said has been tested in court.
December 29, 1969: The victim is taken in Wimbledon, south London, and a £1 million ransom is demanded.
February 7, 1970: Arthur and Nizamodeen Hosein are arrested at Stocking Pelham, Hertfordshire.
September 1970: The trial opens at the Old Bailey.
October 1970: Both brothers are convicted of murder and kidnapping and sentenced to life imprisonment, with further terms of 25 and 15 years.
1990: Nizamodeen Hosein is deported to Trinidad and Tobago.
2009: Arthur Hosein dies in custody in England.
2021: The Metropolitan Police reopens its inquiry.
November 2023: Nizamodeen writes to the Home Office admitting his involvement and asking for the deportation order to be lifted.
2024: Metropolitan Police detectives interview him in Trinidad; in July the force says its work produced no further result.