On the night of April 3, 1997, a young South Korean man named Cho Joong-pil was killed in the Itaewon district of Seoul. Two teenagers were with him at the moment he died, and neither of them knew him. One was Arthur John Patterson, a 17-year-old American living in Seoul. The other was his friend, a Korean-American youth. Each told the police that the other had done it, and each has held to that account ever since.
For nineteen years South Korea's courts could not settle the question. Prosecutors first charged the friend with murder; he was convicted, then acquitted for want of evidence, and that acquittal became final in 1999. Patterson was convicted in 1997 only of two lesser offenses arising from the same night, freed by a national pardon in August 1998, and allowed to leave the country a year later because a ban on his travel had not been renewed. The case was reopened in 2009. Patterson was detained in Los Angeles in 2011, fought extradition for four years, and was returned to Seoul in September 2015. On January 29, 2016, the Seoul Central District Court found him guilty of murder and sentenced him to 20 years' imprisonment, the heaviest term the law allowed for a defendant who had been under 18. The Seoul High Court upheld the verdict and sentence on September 13, 2016, and the Supreme Court of Korea confirmed them on January 25, 2017. He has never admitted the killing.
The two teenagers were together in Itaewon that evening when the killing took place. The victim had no connection to either of them, and the court that convicted Patterson nineteen years later found no motive at all.
Police held both teenagers within days. Prosecutors faced two suspects, each accusing the other, and a set of physical facts that could be read more than one way. They chose the friend, a decision that rested heavily on his size: he was larger and heavier than both Patterson and the victim. The prosecutors of that year relied largely on what the two teenagers themselves said.
The friend was indicted for murder. Patterson was indicted only for two lesser offenses committed that night and was convicted as an accomplice to them. Under the sentencing rules for juveniles, he received a term of 18 months.
The friend was convicted of murder at trial. The Supreme Court of Korea then set the conviction aside for lack of evidence and sent the case back for a new hearing, and in 1999 the appeals court acquitted him. The acquittal became final in September 1999. In law that ended the matter for him. He could never again be tried for the killing, and nothing in the later proceedings changed that.
Patterson did not wait for the friend's case to end. On August 15, 1998, Liberation Day, he was released under a special pardon that freed about 2,000 prisoners across the country. Once the friend's conviction began to fall apart, attention turned back to Patterson as the other person who had been present, and prosecutors kept a ban on his leaving Korea while they considered further charges.
They let the ban lapse, although they had reserved the right to bring further charges against him. In August 1999 the travel order expired without being renewed, and Patterson left for the United States. He settled in California and in later years lived and worked in the Los Angeles area. Korean prosecutors asked the American authorities for investigative help in 2000 and again in 2002, and in October 2002 the case was suspended with no one charged.
The investigation came back to life in late 2009. In December of that year the Seoul Central District Prosecutors' Office decided to reinvestigate, and it asked the Ministry of Justice to begin the process of seeking Patterson's return from the United States. South Korea issued a warrant for his arrest the same year.
The renewed inquiry took a different view of the evidence. Prosecutors concluded that Patterson, not the friend, was more likely the person who had killed the victim. The new inquiry linked Patterson to the killing by evidence, and the prosecutors set out to show that his smaller build did not rule him out. In 2011 the United States government obtained its own warrant, and in May 2011 Patterson was detained in Los Angeles. In December 2011 prosecutors in Seoul indicted him for murder, charging him as a joint principal offender, before the fifteen-year limit on a murder prosecution had run out.
The extradition was fought at every level. In October 2012, after South Korea's formal request, a federal magistrate judge in California found the request well founded and certified Patterson for extradition. He challenged that custody by petition for a writ of habeas corpus, and in June 2013 a federal court in California upheld the certification, finding that the requirements of the extradition treaty between the two countries had been met.
His appeal reached the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, which decided Patterson v. Wagner on May 4, 2015. He made two arguments. The first rested on Article 6 of the extradition treaty between the United States and South Korea, which says that extradition may be denied where prosecution would be barred by lapse of time under the law of the country asked to surrender the person. Patterson argued that the provision should be read as a mandatory bar, since a prosecution in the United States would by then have been out of time. The second rested on the Status of Forces Agreement that governs American forces in Korea, whose double-jeopardy provision, he argued, protected him from being tried again after his conviction in 1997.
The court rejected both. It held that the treaty's wording was permissive: it allowed the Secretary of State to refuse extradition on lapse-of-time grounds but did not require a court to block it. It also held that even if the agreement's double-jeopardy rule applied to him, it did not give him rights that a court could enforce by halting an extradition. The panel affirmed the denial of his petition, noting that he remained free to ask the Secretary of State for relief. A later appeal that summer also failed.
On September 23, 2015, Patterson arrived at Incheon International Airport, sixteen years after he had left. He denied killing the victim and was taken into custody in Seoul to await trial.
The case went to the Seoul Central District Court. By then the friend had returned to Korea, and on November 4, 2015, when the first full hearing opened, the two men came face to face for the first time in about eighteen years. The friend, acquitted long before and now beyond the reach of any charge, appeared as the prosecution's main witness. He testified that he had seen Patterson carry out the killing, and that this had been his account from the first days of the original investigation.
The defense held to the position Patterson had taken since 1997: the friend alone was responsible, Patterson had only been present, and parts of what Patterson said had been mistranslated.
On December 4, 2015, the court held a closed reconstruction in which each man's account was acted out in turn, so that the judges could test which version the physical evidence supported. On January 15, 2016, at the final hearing, prosecutors asked for 20 years' imprisonment, the upper limit of the penalty available. Patterson maintained his innocence in his closing arguments.
On January 29, 2016, Criminal Panel 27 of the Seoul Central District Court convicted Arthur John Patterson of murder and sentenced him to 20 years' imprisonment. The court found that he, and not the friend, had killed the victim. It relied on the physical evidence, on his conduct immediately afterward and on the friend's testimony, which it found more credible than Patterson's own account. The court held that Patterson's own conviction for the 1997 offenses had no bearing on the murder question, and it rejected the defense argument that the time limit for prosecution had run out.
The sentence followed from Patterson's age. The court said that it had chosen life imprisonment as the appropriate penalty, but that the law fixed the term for a defendant who had been under 18 at the time at 20 years. It held that the friend could not be tried again: the Supreme Court's acquittal was final, double jeopardy barred a second trial, and the limitation period had in any case expired for him.
Patterson appealed to the Seoul High Court on the day of the verdict. On September 13, 2016, Criminal Division 5 of the Seoul High Court upheld the conviction and the 20-year term. It agreed that Patterson was the person who had killed the victim. On sentence, the High Court considered that he had already served more than a year for the 1997 offenses and had been held for about four years during the extradition proceedings, and it held that, even taking those periods into account, the district court's term could not be called too heavy.
Patterson appealed again. On January 25, 2017, Criminal Division 3 of the Supreme Court of Korea dismissed the appeal and confirmed the 20-year sentence. It held that the finding that Patterson had killed the victim was proved to a degree that left no room for reasonable doubt and that the lower courts' judgment was justified. It also upheld the High Court's refusal to reduce the sentence. With that ruling the conviction became final, twenty years after the killing.
Patterson has served his sentence in South Korea. As of October 19, 2026, he was in custody in South Chungcheong Province. That August, corrections staff caught him exchanging food and other items with inmates held in U.S. Forces Korea cases and disciplined him.
Two pieces of Korean law shaped the outcome. The first was the Act on Special Cases Concerning the Punishment of Specific Violent Crimes. The Juvenile Act would ordinarily cap a sentence for an offender under 18 at 15 years. Article 4 of the special act overrides that cap for listed violent crimes, murder among them: where a defendant who was under 18 at the time would otherwise be sentenced to death or life imprisonment, the penalty becomes a fixed term of 20 years. Patterson was 17 on the night of the killing. The district court's choice of a life term, converted under Article 4, is why every court that heard the case arrived at exactly 20 years and why the prosecutors could ask for no more.
The second was the limitation period. In 1997 a murder prosecution in Korea had to begin within fifteen years. That clock is suspended while a suspect is outside the country, provided the prosecution can show he left to avoid trial. The indictment of December 2011 came before the period ran out, and the district court rejected Patterson's argument that the time had expired.
Patterson denies the murder. From 1997 through his final appeal he has said that he was only present. The Korean courts rejected that account at three levels, and the conviction is final.
The friend was convicted of the murder in 1997 and acquitted by the Supreme Court for lack of evidence, an acquittal that became final in 1999. He was never tried again after his acquittal and cannot be.
No motive was established at any of the trials.
April 3, 1997: The victim is killed in Itaewon, Seoul; Patterson and his friend are held by police within days.
1997: The friend is convicted of murder; Patterson is convicted of two lesser offenses and sentenced to 18 months.
1998: The Supreme Court of Korea sets aside the friend's conviction and orders a new hearing.
August 15, 1998: Patterson is released under a Liberation Day special pardon.
August 1999: The ban on Patterson's travel lapses; he leaves for the United States.
September 1999: The friend's acquittal becomes final.
October 2002: The investigation is suspended with no one charged.
December 2009: Seoul prosecutors decide to reinvestigate and seek Patterson's extradition.
May 2011: Patterson is detained in Los Angeles.
December 2011: Prosecutors in Seoul indict Patterson for murder.
October 2012: A U.S. magistrate judge certifies him for extradition.
June 2013: A federal court in California upholds the certification.
May 4, 2015: The Ninth Circuit affirms the denial of his habeas petition in Patterson v. Wagner.
September 23, 2015: Patterson is extradited to South Korea.
November 4, 2015: His murder trial opens at the Seoul Central District Court.
December 4, 2015: The court holds a closed reconstruction of both accounts.
January 29, 2016: The Seoul Central District Court convicts Patterson of murder and sentences him to 20 years' imprisonment.
September 13, 2016: The Seoul High Court upholds the verdict and sentence.
January 25, 2017: The Supreme Court of Korea confirms the 20-year sentence.
October 19, 2026: Patterson is in custody in South Chungcheong Province.