Anton Graf von Arco auf Valley was a 22-year-old reserve lieutenant and law student from a Bavarian noble family when, on the morning of February 21, 1919, he killed Kurt Eisner in Munich. The victim had led the revolution that ended the Wittelsbach monarchy in November 1918 and had governed Bavaria ever since as its first minister-president. He was on his way to the newly elected state parliament, the Landtag, to announce the resignation of his government. Arco was taken into custody on the spot, badly hurt. Eleven months later the Volksgericht München I, one of Bavaria's revolutionary-era People's Courts, convicted him of murder and sentenced him to death. The Bavarian cabinet commuted the sentence the next day to life in fortress detention, and he walked free after a little more than four years. He died in Salzburg in June 1945, a few weeks after his release from a Nazi labor camp.
The killing opened one of the most violent stretches of the German revolution. The parliament the victim had meant to address never met as planned, and within seven weeks a council republic had been proclaimed in Munich.
Arco was born on February 5, 1897, in St. Martin im Innkreis, in Upper Austria. He was tutored privately until 1914, then attended the humanist Gymnasium at the Benedictine abbey of Ettal and, from 1915, a school in Passau, where he passed the shortened wartime school-leaving examination in 1916.
He entered the army on August 2, 1916, as an officer cadet in the 1st Heavy Cavalry Regiment. From July 1917 he served on the Eastern Front, in Ukraine and Romania, and on August 31 of that year he was made a lieutenant. In the spring of 1918 he commanded a company of the Bavarian Infantry Life Regiment on the Western Front, where he was wounded on April 13. He received the Iron Cross, Second Class, that May. In September he was granted leave for treatment and returned to Munich. He was still formally on the strength of the Bavarian army when he killed the minister-president; his discharge, at his own request, came only on March 31, 1920.
In Munich he enrolled to read law at the university for the winter semester of 1918 to 1919. He described himself as a strict Catholic and a monarchist, and the revolution of November 1918 had swept away the monarchy he believed in.
Kurt Eisner was a journalist before he was a politician. Born in Berlin in 1867, he wrote for the Social Democratic press for most of his working life, at the party's national organ, Vorwärts, then as editor-in-chief of its Nuremberg daily, and from 1910 in Munich. The war turned him into a sharp critic of German war policy, and in 1917 he became the leading figure in Bavaria of the Independent Social Democrats, the antiwar USPD. He helped organize the Munich munitions strike of January 1918 and spent most of that year in custody.
On November 7, 1918, he led a peace rally on the Theresienwiese that became the start of the revolution. That night the Free State of Bavaria was proclaimed, and the next day he was confirmed as minister-president and foreign minister. His government introduced votes for women, ended church supervision of schools and brought in the eight-hour day. He also published prewar Bavarian diplomatic reports to show the imperial government's responsibility for the war, and in February 1919, at the international socialist conference in Bern, he spoke openly of German war guilt. Those steps made him a principal target of the radical right, and antisemitic abuse had followed him for years.
The election of January 12, 1919, went badly for him. The USPD won about 2.5 percent of the vote and three of the Landtag's 180 seats. After some weeks of trying to hold on, he decided to step down, and he prepared a resignation speech for the session that was to open on February 21.
That morning the minister-president set out for the Landtag. Arco killed him on the way, and he died where he fell. Arco was gravely hurt in the moments that followed and survived.
The opening session collapsed in further violence the same day, and many deputies went into hiding. Power in Munich passed to the revolutionary councils, and on April 7, 1919, a council republic was proclaimed. Government troops and Freikorps units put it down at the beginning of May.
Arco spent the eleven months between the killing and his trial in custody, most of that time in a Munich prison. The investigation was short. He confessed in full, and investigators found no accomplices.
He presented himself throughout as a monarchist and a believing Catholic acting against Bolshevism. Historians have recorded that his hatred was directed at the victim's Jewish origins as well as his politics, and that the minister-president had become a target both because he was Jewish and because he had acknowledged German responsibility for the war.
The court that tried Arco was itself a product of the revolution. The People's Courts had been created by decree in November 1918 and placed on a statutory basis in July 1919. Their proceedings were summary, with no appeal, and a convicted defendant's only remedy was a petition for clemency to the Bavarian Council of Ministers, the Ministerrat.
The trial opened in Munich on January 15, 1920, on a charge of murder under § 211 of the Reich Criminal Code. With Arco's confession, the facts were not in dispute, and the hearing lasted two days. The prosecution asked for the full penalty. Two court-appointed psychiatrists found no grounds to treat him as lacking criminal responsibility. The defense asked for acquittal.
On January 16, 1920, the court found Arco guilty of murder and sentenced him "zum Tode und in die Kosten," to death and to pay the costs of the proceedings. It declined to strip him of his civil honor rights, a step the law left to its discretion, finding that he had not acted from base motives.
The decision on clemency fell to the Ministerrat. On January 17, 1920, it voted unanimously to commute the death sentence to life fortress detention, "lebenslängliche Festungshaft," a separate and privileged category of custody that spared him compulsory labor.
At the end of January 1920 Arco was moved to the fortress detention facility at Landsberg am Lech, west of Munich, where he was the first inmate held in that category. The life term did not last. On July 4, 1923, the sentence was reduced to 15 years. On April 13, 1924, it was interrupted and he was released early. The rest of the sentence was remitted on October 2, 1927, in the amnesty marking the Reich president's 80th birthday.
Arco built an ordinary professional life in Munich. In 1926 he became managing director and publisher of the newspaper Bayerisches Vaterland, and from 1926 to January 1930 he held commercial signing authority for the airline Transeuropa Union, later Süddeutsche Lufthansa. From 1926 to 1929 he belonged to a monarchist association, the Bavarian Homeland and King's League. On June 18, 1931, he founded a real estate company in Munich.
The Nazi state held him more than once. From March to May 1933 he was in so-called protective custody in the Munich police jail, and he was held again from June 28 to June 30, 1933, at Schrobenhausen. After the failed plot of July 20, 1944, he was arrested once more, and from July 22, 1944, until May 1, 1945, he was a prisoner at the Schörgenhub labor education camp near Linz.
He died in a road accident in Salzburg on June 29, 1945.
Arco's conviction for murder was never in doubt. He confessed in full, and the court found the offense proved.
Whether the court and the Ministerrat arranged the death sentence and the reprieve in advance cannot be proven. Historians who have studied the case regard such an understanding as plausible, given that the reprieve came within a day and rested on the court's own finding about his motive, but no evidence of an agreement has come to light.
The legal standing of the court is contested. Courts and most legal scholars of the time held the People's Courts to be constitutional; much modern scholarship holds that the Bavarian statute of July 1919 conflicted with the Weimar Constitution's ban on exceptional courts, so that judgments passed after it took effect are void.
Accounts differ on the month of his release: one gives April 13, 1924, another May 1924.
Whether the minister-president had secretly meant to dissolve the Landtag rather than resign is unproven. The resignation speech he had prepared for February 21 was never delivered.
February 5, 1897: Anton Graf von Arco auf Valley is born in St. Martin im Innkreis, Upper Austria.
1916: He passes the wartime school-leaving examination in Passau and enters the army on August 2.
April 13, 1918: He is wounded on the Western Front.
November 7 to 8, 1918: The Free State of Bavaria is proclaimed; the revolutionary leader becomes minister-president and foreign minister.
January 12, 1919: The USPD wins about 2.5 percent of the vote and three seats in the Bavarian Landtag election.
February 21, 1919: Arco kills the minister-president in Munich on his way to the opening of the Landtag and is taken into custody.
April 7, 1919: A council republic is proclaimed in Munich; it is put down at the beginning of May.
January 15, 1920: Arco's trial opens before the Volksgericht München I.
January 16, 1920: He is convicted of murder and sentenced to death.
January 17, 1920: The Bavarian Ministerrat commutes the sentence to life fortress detention.
Late January 1920: He is moved to fortress detention at Landsberg am Lech.
March 31, 1920: He is discharged from the Bavarian army at his own request.
July 4, 1923: His sentence is reduced to 15 years.
April 13, 1924: The sentence is interrupted and he is released.
October 2, 1927: The remainder is remitted in an amnesty.
March to May 1933: He is held in protective custody in Munich.
July 22, 1944: He is arrested after the July 20 plot and held near Linz until May 1, 1945.
June 29, 1945: He dies in Salzburg.