Anthony Todt

Victims
Wife and 3 children murdered in Celebration, Florida, 2019. Convicted April 14, 2022, of four counts of first-degree murder and one count of animal cruelty
Years active
Late December 2019
Location
Celebration, Osceola County, Florida; Colchester, Connecticut
Method
First-degree murder (four counts); animal cruelty (one count)
Status
Four consecutive life terms without parole plus one year (April 14, 2022); appeal filed April 2022

Anthony Todt was a physical therapist who ran a practice in Colchester, Connecticut, while his wife and their three children lived in Celebration, in Osceola County, Florida. His wife, Megan Todt, and their children, Alek, Tyler and Zoe, died there in late December 2019. Their deaths came to light on January 13, 2020, when federal agents arrived with a warrant for his arrest in a health care fraud case that had nothing to do with them. Todt confessed to the killings that week and later took it all back. On April 14, 2022, a jury in Kissimmee convicted him of four counts of first-degree murder and one count of animal cruelty, and the trial judge sentenced him the same day to four consecutive terms of life in prison without the possibility of parole, with an additional year for the animal cruelty count. He denied the killings at trial, and he appealed within days of the verdict.

Todt's working life was in eastern Connecticut. His business, Family Physical Therapy, had two offices in Colchester. He told federal agents in November 2019 that he had run the practice for eleven years and that he alone was responsible for its billing. The family itself had moved to Florida, to a rented property in Celebration, and Todt divided his weeks between the two places, working in Connecticut and spending weekends with his wife and children in Florida.

By the end of 2019 his finances had come apart, and his Colchester office closed in early January 2020.

Behind those debts lay the federal case. From April 2019, agents of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and the FBI had been investigating the practice, and in January 2020 a federal affidavit and criminal complaint were unsealed in Connecticut accusing Todt of health care fraud by billing Medicaid and private insurers for physical therapy that was never provided.

The federal fraud case brought the deaths to light. On Monday, January 13, 2020, federal agents and Osceola County deputies went to the Celebration property to serve the federal arrest warrant on Todt. Todt was taken into custody that day.

On Wednesday, January 15, 2020, the sheriff's office arrested him on four counts of murder and one count of animal cruelty. He was held without bond. On the same day, the federal affidavit and complaint in the Connecticut case were unsealed.

Todt's statements to detectives in the days after January 13 became the core of the prosecution. The jury later heard that in them he described the killings and spoke of an agreement with his wife that the family would "pass over" together because, he said, they believed the end of the world was near.

Todt pleaded not guilty. While in custody in 2020 he wrote a letter in which he denied the killings and laid the blame elsewhere, the same account he would give the jury two years later. The case moved through the Ninth Judicial Circuit, which covers Orange and Osceola counties, before a circuit judge in Kissimmee. Prosecutors did not seek the death penalty: the state attorney then in office withdrew it before leaving office in January 2021.

In January 2020 Todt had confessed to detectives three times, and the first of those statements became the main battleground before trial. His lawyers moved to keep it from the jury on the ground that he had not been read his Miranda rights before that first interview.

The evidentiary hearing came on Tuesday, October 26, 2021. The judge ruled that day that the federal fraud investigation was to be kept out of the trial, and the jury in Kissimmee heard nothing of the fraud inquiry that had brought agents to the door.

In March 2022 the judge ruled on the confessions. The first statement, given before Todt had been read his Miranda rights, was excluded. The two later statements, given after full warnings, were admitted, and they were the account the jury would hear.

At a final status hearing the week before jury selection, the court ruled that the defense could not discuss Todt's mental health in front of the jury. His lawyers later named that ruling as one of the decisions they would ask an appeals court to review.

The trial was held in Kissimmee in April 2022. Jury selection began on Monday, April 4, and opening statements followed on Monday, April 11.

The prosecution's case turned on his own words. On Tuesday, April 12, the jury watched the video recording of Todt's interview with detectives, and on Wednesday, April 13, the state rested.

The defense case rested on Todt himself. He was the only witness it called. Later on April 13, he took the witness stand and denied that he had killed his family. He testified that his statements to detectives had been false, given to cover for his wife, and that he did not know how his children had died.

Closing arguments were heard on Thursday, April 14, 2022. The jury retired the same day and that evening returned guilty verdicts on every count: four counts of first-degree murder, one for each of the four victims, and one count of animal cruelty.

Sentence followed the same day. The circuit judge imposed four consecutive sentences of life in prison without the possibility of parole, one for each murder count, and an additional year for the animal cruelty count, which was ordered served in the county jail.

Todt appealed both his convictions and his sentences in April 2022, and his lawyers said they would ask the appeals court to review several of the trial judge's rulings, among them the order that kept his mental health out of the trial. The four life sentences committed him to the Florida state prison system.

Todt's own accounts are the central conflict in the case. In January 2020 he confessed to detectives three times and spoke of a shared plan with his wife. The first of those confessions was excluded before trial because he had not been read his Miranda rights; the jury heard the two that followed. In a letter written in custody in 2020 and again on the witness stand in April 2022, he denied killing anyone and said his confessions had been false. The jury rejected the denial and convicted him on every count, and that verdict is the legal finding.

The defense contention that evidence about Todt's mental health was wrongly excluded at trial was raised for appeal in April 2022.

The federal health care fraud complaint unsealed in Connecticut in January 2020 was an accusation only.

Timeline

April 2019: Federal agents of the Department of Health and Human Services and the FBI begin investigating billing at Todt's Colchester practice.

November 2019: Agents interview Todt at his offices in Colchester.

Late December 2019: Todt's wife and their three children die in Celebration, Florida.

January 13, 2020: Federal agents and Osceola County deputies arrive to serve a federal arrest warrant on Todt, and the deaths come to light.

January 15, 2020: The Osceola County Sheriff's Office arrests Todt on four counts of murder and one count of animal cruelty; a federal affidavit and criminal complaint accusing him of health care fraud are unsealed in Connecticut.

2020: In a letter written in custody, Todt denies the killings.

January 2021: The state attorney then in office withdraws the death penalty before leaving office.

October 26, 2021: At an evidentiary hearing the judge rules that the federal fraud investigation may not be raised at trial.

March 2022: The judge excludes the first of Todt's three confessions because he had not been read his Miranda rights, and admits the other two.

April 4, 2022: Jury selection begins in Kissimmee.

April 11, 2022: Opening statements; the state begins its case.

April 12, 2022: The jury watches the recorded interview with detectives.

April 13, 2022: The state rests; Todt, the only defense witness, testifies and denies killing his family.

April 14, 2022: The jury convicts him of four counts of first-degree murder and one count of animal cruelty; the judge imposes four consecutive sentences of life in prison without the possibility of parole, plus one year.

April 2022: Todt appeals his convictions and sentences to Florida's Fifth District Court of Appeal.