Anthony Spero was the consigliere of the Bonanno Organized Crime Family, the third-ranking post in its leadership. In the spring of 1999 a federal grand jury in Brooklyn charged him in a racketeering case that reached back to the early 1980s. At its center were three murders committed by the end of 1993, set beside an illegal gambling business and a loansharking operation that, the government charged, ran until the month of the indictment.
On April 5, 2001, a jury in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York found him guilty of conspiracy to commit racketeering in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1962(d). He was convicted of ordering the three murders, along with loansharking and gambling, all of them charged as acts of a single racketeering conspiracy. The court sentenced him primarily to life in prison, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed the judgment in May 2003. He died while still serving that sentence.
The consigliere stands third in command of a Mafia family, and by the late 1990s the FBI listed Spero in that post in the Bonanno family. When the government later set out the recent history of the family's leadership in a 2010 filing in the Eastern District of New York, it counted him among five consecutive men who had served as boss or acting boss of the Bonanno family and had each been convicted of a crime of violence within the previous decade.
In 1999 he lived on Staten Island and bred racing pigeons in Bath Beach, Brooklyn.
The original indictment was returned on May 25, 1999. It named Spero as one of many defendants and charged him with a single count of racketeering conspiracy. Under the racketeering statute a conspiracy count is built from racketeering acts, and this one listed five. Racketeering Act 1 was a loansharking conspiracy, charged as a conspiracy to make extortionate extensions of credit under 18 U.S.C. § 892 and a conspiracy to collect extensions of credit by extortionate means under 18 U.S.C. § 894(a)(1), in the period between January 1983 and May 1999. Racketeering Acts 2 through 5 were the three murders and the management of an illegal gambling enterprise, and all four of those acts had been completed by the end of 1993.
One of the three murders was that of Paul Gulino in July 1993. Spero was charged with ordering it. The other two murders were charged as acts of the same conspiracy, and the conviction two years later covered all three.
Spero was first held without bail on a finding that he was a danger to the community; in June 1999 the court set conditions under which he could be confined at his residence on Staten Island before trial.
The case went to trial in the Eastern District of New York, in Brooklyn, before the chief judge of that court. The jury returned its verdict on April 5, 2001, and found Spero guilty on the single count. To convict on a racketeering conspiracy, the jury had to find that he conspired to commit at least two of the five racketeering acts in the indictment, and it did. The result was a conviction for ordering three murders, for loansharking and for gambling, joined in one count that reached from 1983 to the eve of his arrest.
On August 23, 2001, Spero moved for a judgment of acquittal under Rule 29(c) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure. He raised two grounds. The first was that the racketeering count was barred by the five-year statute of limitations. The loansharking conspiracy, he argued, had been tied to the gambling enterprise, and that enterprise had folded in December 1993, so nothing within the indictment had happened on or after May 25, 1994, five years before the grand jury acted. The second was that Racketeering Act 1 alleged only a generic conspiracy and so failed to tell him with enough specificity what he had to answer.
The district court heard argument on December 14, 2001, and denied the motion in an unpublished order dated April 15, 2002. On the limitations point it relied on Second Circuit precedent holding that a defendant's continued membership in a racketeering enterprise can carry a conspiracy forward, and it understood the government to have shown that Spero continued to act as a member of the Bonanno family after May 25, 1994.
Judgment was entered on April 19, 2002. The court sentenced Spero primarily to life in prison.
Spero appealed to the Second Circuit. A three-judge panel first affirmed in a summary order filed on February 28, 2003. It then withdrew that order and on May 20, 2003, issued a published opinion that reached the same result and stated its reasons at length.
The court took the limitations claim first. It assumed, without deciding, that Spero had raised it properly, and it chose not to decide whether the district court had read the earlier precedents correctly. It rested instead on a narrower ground. A conspiracy whose aims call for continuing conduct, the panel held, is presumed to continue until there is an affirmative showing that it has ended. Once the government proved the loansharking conspiracy existed, the burden passed to Spero to show that it had ended, or that he had withdrawn from it, before May 25, 1994. He could do neither. The collapse of the gambling business proved nothing about the loansharking, because the indictment had not tied one to the other. And on withdrawal, the court wrote that "Spero produced no evidence that he affirmatively renounced the goal of extorting money through loansharking," adding that the trial evidence tended to support the opposite conclusion. The conspiracy, it held, "must be presumed to have continued past May 25, 1994," and the indictment was timely.
The specificity claim failed for a different reason. Spero had not raised it before trial, and the rules of criminal procedure require objections to the form of an indictment to be made at that stage. A late objection of that kind can be excused only on a showing of cause and prejudice, and Spero had offered no reason for the delay. The court concluded: "the judgment of the District Court is hereby affirmed."
Spero served the life sentence in federal custody. He died in federal custody in North Carolina in 2008.
The jury's verdict required a finding that Spero conspired to commit at least two of the five racketeering acts, and the Associated Press reported the conviction as one for ordering all three murders.
The limitations question was settled against him on the presumption of continuation. In a footnote the appeals court observed that the defense might have been waived or forfeited, because it was raised only after trial and no jury instruction on it was requested, and it left that point undecided.
January 1983: Start of the period charged for the loansharking conspiracy in Racketeering Act 1.
July 1993: Murder charged as ordered by Spero in the 1999 indictment.
December 1993: The gambling enterprise in the indictment folds; by the end of 1993 the three murders and the gambling act are complete.
May 25, 1999: A federal grand jury in the Eastern District of New York returns the original racketeering indictment.
June 24, 1999: The court sets conditions for his release before trial, including confinement on Staten Island and $3.5 million in property security.
April 5, 2001: A jury in Brooklyn finds him guilty of conspiracy to commit racketeering, 18 U.S.C. § 1962(d).
August 23, 2001: He moves for a judgment of acquittal on limitations and specificity grounds.
December 14, 2001: The district court hears argument on the motion.
April 15, 2002: The motion is denied.
April 19, 2002: Judgment entered; he is sentenced primarily to life in prison.
February 28, 2003: The Second Circuit affirms by summary order, later withdrawn.
May 20, 2003: The Second Circuit affirms in a published opinion.
2008: He dies in federal custody in North Carolina.