Anthony Briley

Victims
4 first-degree murder convictions in Richmond, Virginia, 1980. A court account places him in the house where three people were killed on October 19, 1979; never sentenced to death
Years active
Killings linked to the group: March to October 1979. The household killings in which he took part: October 19, 1979
Location
Richmond and Henrico County, Virginia
Method
Shootings during robberies. Under Virginia law as described by the Fourth Circuit, a principal in the second degree could not be sentenced to death for a murder.
Status
Three 30-year terms and a life term for murder, plus terms for robbery, abduction, weapons offenses and a Henrico robbery. Refused parole twice in 2024; in prison as of December 2024

Anthony Ray Briley is the youngest of three brothers from Richmond, Virginia, whose names became attached to a run of robberies and killings in and around the city in 1979. Police and prosecutors linked the group to 11 deaths that year; a prosecutor who tried the cases later said the true number was at least 11 and probably higher. His older brothers, Linwood and James, were sentenced to death, broke out of Virginia's death row in 1984, and were executed. A teenage neighbor who took part in the crimes testified against the older brothers and went to prison under an agreement with the Commonwealth.

Anthony's own record is narrower than the group's. The decisions the Virginia Parole Board has published on him show four convictions for first-degree murder in the Circuit Court of the City of Richmond, together with robbery, abduction and weapons offenses, and a separate robbery conviction in Henrico County. He was not sentenced to death. He remained in prison as of December 2024, when the board refused him parole for the second time that year.

The brothers

Linwood and James were the two oldest of the brothers; in 1984 United Press International gave Linwood's age as 30 and James's as 28. Both had records before 1979. Linwood had served time for a break-in, UPI reported. James had a 1973 conviction for armed robbery and attempted murder, according to the Supreme Court of Virginia, and he was on parole in 1979: on the morning of October 19 of that year he met a Richmond judge about the conditions of that parole.

Anthony was the youngest. Virginia Lawyers Weekly gave his age as 51 in May 2009, and the parole board recorded his age as 66 at both of his 2024 reviews.

Prosecutors later described the brothers to UPI as violent men who could not tolerate weakness, and said the motives for the killings were never clear. One theory they gave was that Linwood had sworn never to go back to prison and wanted to leave no witnesses. An informer told police the brothers wanted reputations as killers so they could work as hired gunmen. Those are the prosecutors' and the informer's accounts, not findings of any court.

When the two older brothers escaped from death row in 1984, a reporter reached their mother, who declined to comment.

The 1979 killings

Between March and October 1979, a series of killings in Richmond and its suburbs seemed at first to have nothing to do with one another. Robert J. Rice, one of the prosecutors, told Virginia Lawyers Weekly in 2009 that because the cases looked unrelated, different detectives had been assigned to them. Only later did investigators come to see them as the work of one group.

A Washington Post list of the victims, and UPI's reporting in 1984, give these deaths as the ones linked to the Briley group. Those reports also say who was convicted of each killing or blamed for it. It is not a list of Anthony Briley's crimes.

Michael W. McDuffie was killed on March 21, 1979. He worked as a serviceman for a vending company and was shot to death in Henrico County, a suburb of Richmond.

Mary W. Gowen, 76, was shot and killed on April 9, 1979, as she returned home in Richmond after a babysitting job.

Christopher M. Phillips, 17, was killed on July 4, 1979. Prosecutors said Linwood Briley was responsible.

Thomas E. Saunders was shot and killed in Richmond in September 1979, according to the Washington Post. Prosecutors attributed his death to Duncan Meekins, the teenager who later testified for the Commonwealth.

John Harvey Gallaher, 62, a Richmond radio disc jockey known on the air as "Johnny G," was abducted in South Richmond on September 14, 1979, robbed, and shot. Linwood Briley was convicted of his capital murder and sentenced to death.

Mary S. Wilfong, 62, a private nurse, was killed outside her home on September 30, 1979. Linwood Briley was found guilty and sentenced to life plus 50 years, according to the Washington Post.

Blanche Page was killed in her home in Richmond on October 5, 1979, together with Charles Garner, 59, who boarded in her house. The Post reported that the home was about two blocks from the Brileys' house. Linwood received a sentence of life plus 71 years for the two killings, the Post reported. UPI gave Blanche Page's age as 75; the Post gave it as 79.

On October 19, 1979, Harvey Wilkerson, Judy Diane Barton and her five-year-old son, Harvey Wayne Barton, were killed in their home in Richmond. The Supreme Court of Virginia's account places Anthony Briley inside the house during those killings.

UPI reported in 1984 that Linwood had been convicted in six of the killings and James in seven, some of the cases naming both brothers. In 1985 the Washington Post described the group as linked to 12 killings.

The Gallaher robbery

Anthony Briley's name appears in one other court account of the 1979 crimes. In April 1984 a federal judge in the Eastern District of Virginia ruled on Linwood Briley's petition challenging his conviction for the Gallaher killing. The opinion summarizes the facts as the state's evidence presented them: Linwood, his two brothers, Anthony among them, and their friend Duncan Meekins went out on the night of September 14, 1979, looking for someone to rob. When Gallaher came out of a South Richmond bar, Linwood robbed him at gunpoint, and Linwood and Meekins drove off with him in his own car. Anthony and James went back to their own car and later met up with the other two. Linwood then shot Gallaher in Richmond, and the group drove his car around the city before stripping and leaving it.

That account comes from the evidence in Linwood's case, which rested chiefly on Meekins. The opinion does not mention any charge against Anthony over Gallaher's death.

October 19, 1979

The fullest court account of the night that led to Anthony Briley's murder convictions is the Supreme Court of Virginia's 1980 opinion in James's appeal, James Dyral Briley v. Commonwealth.

Harvey Wilkerson lived in Richmond with Judy Diane Barton, whom the court described as his common-law wife, and their five-year-old son, Harvey Wayne Barton. UPI gave Judy Barton's age as 23 and reported that she was pregnant; UPI and the Washington Post gave Harvey Wilkerson's age as 26. The Fourth Circuit, in its 1984 opinion on James's federal appeal, described Wilkerson as the boy's father.

On the evening of October 19, according to the Supreme Court of Virginia, James, Linwood, Anthony and Meekins gathered at the Briley home. After drinking and smoking marijuana, the four planned to rob Wilkerson. James and Linwood were armed, and Linwood handed Meekins a handgun.

The four waited in a shed across from Wilkerson's house and then went in, James and Linwood first, Anthony and Meekins behind them. The men searched the house. Meekins testified that Anthony and James searched the upstairs. Police officers who were watching the area that night corroborated part of his account, including that Anthony carried a large shopping bag out of the house.

Linwood left to start the car. Meekins testified that he then heard a shot. Meekins admitted at trial that he himself had shot Harvey Wilkerson. Judy Barton and her son were also killed. After the shots, Meekins ran from the house, and Anthony and James ran out behind him.

The four left in a car driven by Linwood. On a police scanner they heard that officers were following them, and they threw their weapons out on a nearby street before abandoning the car. That night, at the Briley home, they divided the money taken from the house; Meekins's share was about $100. Police later recovered some of the weapons near where they had been thrown, and Meekins identified them; two handguns were never found.

The bodies were found two days later.

Meekins

Duncan Eric Meekins was 16 in October 1979, a neighbor of the Brileys. He became the center of the case against them. According to the Supreme Court of Virginia, he was arrested and confessed, and he then gave evidence under a plea agreement: he received a life sentence for the first-degree murder of Harvey Wilkerson, and his sentences on other charges could not exceed the punishment given to any other participant.

Rice told Virginia Lawyers Weekly that investigators gave Meekins only enough information to focus him on each incident, and that his accounts matched details the police had not released, among them the sound of a train whistle he described near the place where Gallaher was killed. Meekins acknowledged killing two of the victims himself, the paper reported. Under the agreement, as Rice described it, Meekins could expect release after about 15 years, a new name, and a place in another state's prison system away from the brothers.

At James's trial the defense attacked Meekins's credibility, and on cross-examination he admitted differences between his testimony and his earlier statements. The defense in Linwood's Gallaher case made the same attack, pointing to his plea bargain and his inconsistent statements. Both juries convicted.

The brothers' trials

James Briley was tried before a jury in the Circuit Court of the City of Richmond in January 1980, in a trial split into a guilt stage and a penalty stage. He did not testify. The jury convicted him of the capital murder of Harvey Wayne Barton during an armed robbery, the capital murder of Judy Diane Barton during or after a rape, the first-degree murder of Harvey Wilkerson, the robbery of Wilkerson, the rape of Judy Barton, and the use of a firearm in those crimes. At the penalty stage the Commonwealth put in his earlier convictions and his conduct in prison; the defense called one witness, his parole officer. The jury recommended death on both capital counts, and the trial judge imposed those sentences.

The Fourth Circuit, reviewing the case in 1984, explained why James did not face death for Wilkerson's killing: he had been convicted of that murder as a principal in the second degree, and under Virginia law a principal in the second degree could not be sentenced to death. The court noted that the Commonwealth's case rested principally on Meekins.

Linwood Briley was convicted of capital murder in the course of a robbery for the Gallaher killing and sentenced to death; the federal court recorded that the jury found two aggravating circumstances. He also received prison terms in other cases, among them life plus 50 years for Mary Wilfong's death and life plus 71 years for the deaths of Blanche Page and Charles Garner, according to the Washington Post. UPI reported in 1984 that he was also serving seven life terms.

The Supreme Court of Virginia upheld James's convictions and death sentences on direct appeal in 1980. Both brothers then brought federal challenges. The federal district court dismissed James's petition on June 22, 1984, and the Fourth Circuit affirmed on December 28, 1984, rejecting his claims about the penalty-stage jury instructions, the exclusion of two prospective jurors who opposed the death penalty, and the performance of his lawyers. The district court ruled against Linwood's petition in April 1984, and the Fourth Circuit affirmed the denial of his petitions.

Anthony Briley's convictions

According to the Virginia Parole Board's decisions of March and December 2024, Anthony Ray Briley is serving 30 years on each of three first-degree murder convictions entered in Richmond City Circuit Court on April 30, 1980, along with 15 years for robbery and one year on each weapons count from the same day. A judgment of June 24, 1980, in the same court added a life term for a fourth first-degree murder and 10 years for abduction without ransom. A robbery conviction in Henrico County Circuit Court brought 20 more years on October 5, 1981.

The records list no suspended time on any count. The board's two 2024 documents differ on one point: the March decision lists four weapons counts, the December decision three.

The parole records do not name the victims of any count. Nor do they say which killing the life sentence of June 24, 1980 covers. When James was executed in April 1985, the Washington Post described Anthony as serving a life sentence "for his role in another murder"; it did not say which. Three first-degree murder convictions entered on the same day would fit the three deaths of October 19, 1979, at the house where the Supreme Court of Virginia placed him, but the parole records do not state that link.

Contemporary and later reports summarized his punishment in different ways. UPI in June 1984 described him as serving several life sentences for murder. Virginia Lawyers Weekly in 2009 put his sentence at life plus 139 years. The parole records, which list each count, show one life term.

He was never sentenced to death. Virginia Lawyers Weekly reported in 2009 that he had been present at many of the killings but had not killed anyone himself.

Death row and the escape

Anthony Briley was not on death row and was not part of what followed there. On the night of May 31, 1984, six condemned men broke out of the death row cellblock at the Mecklenburg Correctional Center in Boydton, Virginia, UPI reported; Linwood and James were believed to have led the escape, which UPI later described as the largest death row escape in the country up to that time. In its report on the breakout, UPI noted that their brother Anthony was serving his sentence at another prison and had no part in it.

The brothers were free for more than two weeks. WTVR CBS 6 in Richmond recorded that they were recaptured in Philadelphia on June 19, 1984; UPI reported that they were found in a Philadelphia garage 19 days after the escape. The Washington Post, in 1985, said all of the escapees had been recaptured, and that the brothers were the last.

Two executions

Linwood Briley was executed in the electric chair at the Virginia State Penitentiary in Richmond on October 12, 1984, UPI reported. He was 30. His lawyer said he maintained his innocence. Governor Charles Robb was asked to intervene by the lawyer, the NAACP and a group of Black ministers, but his aides said he saw nothing to warrant stopping the execution. The Supreme Court had refused four appeals. Warren Von Schuch, the Richmond prosecutor, had called the group "killing machines."

Anthony, serving a life term, telephoned his brother in Linwood's last hours, according to UPI.

James Briley was executed in the same prison in April 1985, at 28. A federal judge had rejected as unreliable a woman prisoner's claim that another member of the gang had committed the killings for which James was condemned, the Washington Post reported. About 600 people gathered outside, some supporting the execution and others holding a candlelight vigil. Inside the state's prisons that morning, officials said, a group of inmates had staged a disturbance meant to disrupt the execution; guards and an inmate were hurt, none critically.

The Post's account of James's execution noted that a third brother, Anthony, was serving a life sentence.

Meekins and the question of parole

Meekins's plea agreement, as Rice described it to Virginia Lawyers Weekly, was understood to mean he would be released after about 15 years. Under Virginia's parole system at the time, the paper reported, people serving life for murder typically served no more than 15 years for one killing and 20 for two. Meekins was not released on that schedule. By 2009 he was 46, had earned a high school equivalency diploma and certificates in plumbing and heating and air-conditioning repair, and had been refused parole the year before.

Rice, by then a defense lawyer in Henrico County, said the Commonwealth had not kept its side of the deal. He and Warren B. Von Schuch, by then a prosecutor in Chesterfield County, agreed to speak for Meekins at his next parole hearing, in June 2009, and the lead detective in the case, Norman Harding, was also expected to stress how much Meekins's evidence had mattered. Rice said Meekins's testimony was largely responsible for the executions of Linwood and James.

Anthony Briley's sentences, too, have brought him before the parole board.

The 2024 parole decisions

On March 18, 2024, the Virginia Parole Board considered Anthony Briley under its dual-eligibility category and did not grant parole. He was 66, and the board estimated he had served 44 years, 4 months and 26 days. The reasons it gave were that he should serve more of his sentence before release on parole, that release at that time would diminish the seriousness of the crime, the serious nature and circumstances of his offenses, and an extensive criminal record.

On December 27, 2024, the board considered him again, this time for geriatric parole. Two board members voted not to grant it. The board estimated his time served at 45 years, 2 months and 6 days. Its reasons listed the three first-degree murder convictions, an extensive criminal record, a history of violence, and the serious nature and circumstances of his offenses.

As of the Virginia Parole Board's decision of December 2024, Anthony Briley remained in the custody of the Virginia Department of Corrections, serving the sentences imposed in 1980 and 1981. His brothers Linwood and James were executed in 1984 and 1985.

Disputed and unproven points

How many people died. UPI in 1984 linked the group to 11 killings in 1979. The Washington Post, reporting on James's execution in 1985, linked it to 12. Robert Rice told Virginia Lawyers Weekly in 2009 that the group was responsible for at least 11 and probably more. None of these figures is a count of Anthony Briley's convictions, which number four murders.

Which killings Anthony was convicted of. The parole records list four first-degree murder convictions without naming the victims. The Supreme Court of Virginia's opinion in James's case places him inside the house on October 19, 1979; a federal opinion in Linwood's case places him with the group on the night of the Gallaher robbery, in a separate car. Which deaths the four counts cover is not stated in the parole records.

Who killed whom on October 19. Meekins admitted shooting Harvey Wilkerson, and James was convicted of capital murder for the deaths of Judy Barton and her son. The court accounts of that night do not describe Anthony firing a shot.

Ages. Blanche Page is given as 75 by UPI and 79 by the Washington Post.

The escape. UPI reported six escapees; the Post, in 1985, put the number at five.

The sentence. "Several life sentences" (UPI, 1984), "a life sentence" (Washington Post, 1985) and "life plus 139 years" (Virginia Lawyers Weekly, 2009) are three press descriptions of one set of sentences; the parole board's itemized list shows one life term and terms of years.

Timeline

1973: James Briley is convicted of armed robbery and attempted murder (Supreme Court of Virginia).

March 21, 1979: Michael W. McDuffie is shot and killed in Henrico County.

April 9, 1979: Mary W. Gowen, 76, is shot and killed in Richmond.

July 4, 1979: Christopher M. Phillips, 17, is killed; prosecutors blame Linwood Briley.

September 1979: Thomas E. Saunders is shot and killed; prosecutors blame Duncan Meekins.

September 14, 1979: John Harvey "Johnny G" Gallaher, 62, is abducted, robbed and shot in Richmond; Linwood is later sentenced to death for his killing. A federal opinion places Anthony with the group that night, in a separate car.

September 30, 1979: Mary S. Wilfong, 62, is killed.

October 5, 1979: Blanche Page and Charles Garner, 59, are killed in Richmond.

October 19, 1979: Harvey Wilkerson, Judy Diane Barton and Harvey Wayne Barton, 5, are killed in Richmond; Anthony is one of four men in the house.

January 1980: James is convicted and sentenced to death.

April 30, 1980: judgment on three of Anthony's first-degree murder convictions (30 years each), with weapons and robbery counts.

June 24, 1980: judgment on Anthony's fourth first-degree murder conviction (life) and an abduction count.

November 1980: the Supreme Court of Virginia decides James's appeal.

October 5, 1981: judgment on Anthony's Henrico County robbery conviction (20 years).

April 1984: a federal district judge rules on Linwood's habeas petition.

May 31, 1984: Linwood and James lead the escape of six men from death row at Mecklenburg.

June 19, 1984: the brothers are recaptured in Philadelphia.

October 12, 1984: Linwood is executed in Richmond; Anthony telephones him in his last hours.

December 28, 1984: the Fourth Circuit affirms the dismissal of James's petition.

April 1985: James is executed.

May 2009: Virginia Lawyers Weekly reports Meekins still in prison and prosecutors backing his parole.

March 18, 2024: the Virginia Parole Board refuses Anthony parole.

December 27, 2024: the board refuses him geriatric parole.